Mark said:
Hello Paul and guys,
Sorry to have been absent for so long but
I have been trying to find DVD-RW disks. I
finally went to Walmart and they had them but
only Memorex. I remembered what you guys said,
so I passed them by. I ended up having to go
online and bought:
(5)Maxell DVD-RW- 4.7GB 2 x 635125
Will that be ok? When I get them I'll create
the recovery boot cd.
Thanks,
Robert
I use a different Maxell product than you, and
the discs were actually made by Ritek. They should
be OK.
*******
Optical media are made in relatively large plants.
There are one or two plants that make cheap (and not
very good) media. And it's up to any reseller, to
make bulk purchases of product from suppliers with
a good reputation. Ritek and Taiyo Yuden are examples
of suppliers with a good rep. The Maxell I bought in
the past was Ritek (which is why I bought more of them).
And Ridata brand (which was also in my computer store
next to the Maxell), is a Ritek company (i.e. how they
sell their own media).
You can see in the paragraph here, how the supply
system works.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiyo_Yuden_Co.,_Ltd.#Recording_media
"Rebranded Taiyo Yuden media can be found under
Fujifilm, Fusion, Maxell (Maxell Music CD-R,
Maxell CD-R Pro, and Maxell CD-R Music Pro (discontinued)),
Miflop, Panasonic, Plextor, Sony (Sony Music CD-R (discontinued 2008)),
TDK, and Verbatim Corporation brands."
If we look at the Memorex article:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memorex
"Few if any of these products are actually manufactured
by Memorex or Imation; for example,
CD-Rs are made by CMC Magnetics Corp of Taiwan,
Ritek of Taiwan and Moser Baer of India. CD-Rs were
formerly made by Daxon of Malaysia and Prodisc Technology"
While Ritek is in their list, we don't really know what
percentage of Memorex product might be those. You'd need
to research those company names, to find out if their
media was reputable.
I've bought Fujifilm branded media before, and they were OK.
And the media tag on discs can be faked. A counterfeiter
can make their own "Ritek" if they want. So if some big factory
with a bad reputation isn't able to sell product any more, they
can put the name of a company with a good reputation, on the
media tag that the burner program can read. Imgburn may be
able to tell you the discs are Ritek. So if I ever run into
some Ritek, with splotches in the dye layer, we know what
happened :-( It might not be real Ritek.
Staples, the stationary store, is selling a lot of media with
their own store brand printed on the packaging. As a result
of doing that, I no longer buy optical media at Staples. Who
wants to waste time, "testing" media again, to find out
who actually makes the Staples branded optical discs ? It's
because of this "two layer supply system", that purchasing
media is so hard. Imagine if Moser Baer or Ritek had to put
their own name on the outside of every package, how easy this
would be. As it is, the system is "anti-consumer", intended
to sucker customers into buying things they don't want. And
that Staples example, of introducing products with no known
history, is how this game is played. It's like buying
generic-branded Cheerios, which turn out to be as hard
as rock when you put them in your cereal bowl. Some testing
required.
HTH,
Paul