I refuse to spend $90 on Partition Magic in order to fix a problem
caused by faulty software.
I'd suggest that this problem is more down to user error than software
problems. It appears your repeated pissing about and reinstallation has
caused this latest problem. Remember the saying about the poor workman
always blaming his tools?
Either way, if you wish to bitch, the people you should be bitching are are
Microsoft, or, secondarily, the hard disk manufacturers for having the
temerity to break the 28 bit LBA barrier in the first place.
(XP's limited ability to recognize large drives)
The initial vanilla WinXP's codebase was set back in 2001, at a time when
hard disks larger than 137GB were largely vapour. Microsoft patched the OS
at the first possible opportunity.
There must be another way to recover this 'used' (nonexistent)
hard drive space.
If you don't want to shell out on Partition Magic, you could look for a
freeware or shareware utility that will do the same job. Alternatively, you
could either try creating a slipstreamed WinXP CD with SP2 already
integrated, low-level format your disk to remove the current error, then
reinstall XP with the new SP2 CD.
Alternatively, low-level format the disk, reinstall the vanilla XP, stick
SP2 on and then do what you did before, creating an extended partition, and
a new virtual disk, in the remaining space via Disk Management.
Since I deleted the partition in FDISK, why wouldn't
I have the same problem as before?
Seeing as we don't have your system in front of us, it is impossible to say
with 100% clarity what caused this problem. However, seeing as FDISK doesn't
support large disks, it is likely that your use of this utility to delete
the partition has caused your current problem by creating an incorrect
partition table.
Again, this is caused by outdated software.
Yeah, the PC market just keeps advancing. Sucks doesn't it.
It's ridiculous to have such difficulty recognizing large
hard drives in 2005.
Your problems are atypical, it's not like we hear of these issues every day.
As mentioned above, one can't help but wonder how much of this issue is down
to the tools, and how much to the workman.
--
Richard Hopkins
Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom
(replace nospam with pipex in reply address)
The UK's leading technology reseller
www.dabs.com