Leythos said:
Been there a LONG TIME AGO.
So stop dancing around and tell us the answer. How does 2K / XP native
backup behave when it's running on a FAT-32 drive?
If they do a backup of their computer to a USB Drive they
will.
What does USB have to do with it?
My experience has been that FAT gets corrupted way more often
than NTFS and that anyone that thinks NTFS has anything to do
with backups has missed the boat.
When was the last time your primary OS was win-9x?
It kills me to hear people badmouth FAT32/9x when the vast majority of
them globbed onto 2K back in '00 or '01 and never looked back.
My experience with Drives is that people leave their computers
on 24/7, drives are being made cheaper, they fail a lot more
often because of those two issues.
I've got 2 servers running NT and they've been running continuously for
the past 7 years with the same WD 40gb drives. Drive longevity is more
of a function of brand first, then vintage second.
I've had first-hand, direct personal experience with installing, using
or maintaining about 425 to 475 hard drives starting around 1992 (and
probably about a dozen MFM/RLL drives between 1984 - 1992). I can say
with certainty that Fujitsu drives 10-20 gb failed significantly more
often than any other type of drive. WD and Seagates were the most
common for me, and I'd say I have maybe 5 failed drives of those types
in total.
RAID-0, typical for home users that believe it will improve their
performance so much that they will notice it, is problematic,
for many reason, but RAID-1 is almost rock stable and rarely
causes any problem for users.
A few of our developers have had grief with XP-pro running raid. The
performance increase is not worth the hassle when you have to rebuild
the file system.
Raid as implimented on most motherboards is for shit. They don't start
splitting files unless they're more than 32 or 64 mb in size, and then
only in 32 or 64 mb chunks. My idea of raid is that for every byte you
pull off your file system, the low 4-bits comes from drive 1, and the
upper 4 bits comes from drive 2. Doesn't matter if it's a 32 byte text
file or a 1 gb VOB file. That's what I think raid is (or should be).
No motherboard that comes with raid does that.
Backups are for recovering data for many reasons.
I've got a closet full of tape drives and tapes circa 1997-1999 that
were used but never needed.
A lot of money, time, and hand-wringing gets spent over backup issues,
and 99% of the time it's all for not, and 1% of the time there was a
simpler and cheaper solution that could have been used.