I just toast mine in one of those 'fat-free grill' thingies. Just set the height, shove in the sandwhich, & wipe when you're done. No mess or gunk to clean, easy as.
There's no way I'd get one of those things inside my toaster... & it does fit regular toast bread in. Mine cant handle sanwhich sliced bread though... bread's too skinny, toaster keeps eating it
Nevermind the tray and white plate ...what you need to show off your lovely toastie is good old Staffordshire tableware...the kind i have been overseeing for 20 years ...introducing Botanic Rose .