- Joined
- Mar 5, 2002
- Messages
- 20,281
- Reaction score
- 1,794
psd99 said:Each to their own Flopps.
Well yes............... and no.
This is a subject that always makes me roll my eyes, so to speak.
Let's state this:
Every make of hard drive has failed.
As I've often said before, the reliability of the hard drive purchase of your choice will not depend on the manufacturer's stamp on the case but rather:
1) The factory/plant where it was made.
2) The quality of the materials used to make the disk.
3) Luck.
I've had every single make of hard disk fail on me except - Maxtor, which is probably just luck as I know of many people who have had Maxtor hard drives fail on them.
The make of drive that's failed the most on me is Western Digital.
Human nature being what it is though once a person experiences a brand failure he or she will then probably boycott that brand. Now if I were to do that, I'd be limited to Maxtor drives wouldn't I? So perhaps you can see how senseless the argument is about one drive being more reliable than another.
All people do is forward their own personal experiences when the question is asked and never, ever, does a clear picture emerge as to one brand being more reliable than another.
Myself, I look at three factors when buying a hard drive: price, quietness and warranty.
Which is why I like Samsung even though I've had one fail on me (successfully and quickly rma'd) and yes, Maxtor drives are a little noisy compared to their peers.
Sometimes, a manufacturer will get it completely wrong, as with the IBM Desk Star drives around 8 years ago, they failed by the thousands. Hitachi took over the IBM disk franchise as IBM could not recover from all those failures, their sales just tailed off.
Lots of people won't buy Hitachi drives now because of that fiasco but I do, they're fine drives (see my sig).
The only drive I've not heard of failing is the Western Digital Raptor drives, they have a five year warranty. They're good, but they're noisy. Of course some will have failed, I expect somebody on this forum will be able to tell me of such an occurence.
And that is why I do get a little irritated when some folk go dissing a hard drive manufacturer because, really, they're all just as bad/good as each other when it comes to reliability.