G
Ground Cover
Thanks. Yes, there's the phenomenon of "Crown Corporations". These are
corporations owned by the government but which operate at arms length from
the government e.g. the CBC works independently of the government which
simply funds it. They usually exist to fulfill some need that it is felt
will not or cannot be met by private industry.
But you made some mistakes:
CN is now publicly traded, as is Air Canada. CBC operates at a decided arms
length. It's not the official organ of the government, rather quite often
its critic. And there are plenty of private television radio companies in
Canada. Canada Post has to compete with FedEx and UPS. I don't think CP was
ever a Crown Corporation.
Furthermore, beyond what you mentioned, the federal government's stake in
the once national gasoline company Petrocan was sold off.
There's a difference between universal health care and socialist health
care. In Canada, the goal is universal health care. But the providers of
said health care can be either government or business - it's just that the
government will provide the monies to make sure the care is universally
available. I admit for the time being that it is hugely a government run
project. The federal government funds the health care, but the provinces
administer it. The biggest problem they face is keeping it efficient
(enough) and timely. In my opinion, universality should be extended to
include prescribed drugs and basic dentistry.
But I think you think Canadians demand government-only health care - that's
not necessarily the case. Heck, almost all doctors are essentially private
business men who charge the government for services rendered. It's not
government-only health care most Canadians want, it's quality timely
*universal* health care we want. Rich or poor you get the cure. Ugly or fair
you'll get good care. Whether a particular service is delivered by
government or by private company is beside the point.
One of the generally accepted reasons for the CBC is that it is considered
stalwart vis a vis Canadian culture - a culture that would otherwise be
swamped by the huge cultural machine to the south. It provides a sort of
cultural common ground for Canadians. CBC's role varies from decade to
decade. For instance, it is the big hockey broadcaster. But now there's
discussion that the private companies should handle the Hockey Night in
Canada contract.
And, for sure, there's plenty of competition .. we have all the usual
channels on basic cable except, of course, FOX News <snicker> and the
channel that plays every al-Qaeda video bin Laden sends it, Aljazeera. FOX
News and the specialty channels you can get if you buy a bundle on digital
cable. Aljazeera is available, I think, only if you use "grey market"
satellite stuff if you can get it at all - let's just say Aljazeera is not
exactly welcome. But basic cable even includes some BBC News on the CBC news
network. And we even have stuff coming in from Paris on some of the French
channels. But there are plenty of privately owned television and radio
networks in Canada and, of course, we get the big American channels.
So overall I think you misunderstand how "socialist" Canada is. There are
some crown corporations, sure, but these usually [not always] have to
compete with private ones. Crown Corporations exist because there's a
perceived need for them, not to serve socialism. Yes, our flag is white and
red, but the official colours of Canada (white and red) come from Queen
Victoria in the nineteenth century not from socialism. The socialists in
Canada use the colour orange.
corporations owned by the government but which operate at arms length from
the government e.g. the CBC works independently of the government which
simply funds it. They usually exist to fulfill some need that it is felt
will not or cannot be met by private industry.
But you made some mistakes:
CN is now publicly traded, as is Air Canada. CBC operates at a decided arms
length. It's not the official organ of the government, rather quite often
its critic. And there are plenty of private television radio companies in
Canada. Canada Post has to compete with FedEx and UPS. I don't think CP was
ever a Crown Corporation.
Furthermore, beyond what you mentioned, the federal government's stake in
the once national gasoline company Petrocan was sold off.
There's a difference between universal health care and socialist health
care. In Canada, the goal is universal health care. But the providers of
said health care can be either government or business - it's just that the
government will provide the monies to make sure the care is universally
available. I admit for the time being that it is hugely a government run
project. The federal government funds the health care, but the provinces
administer it. The biggest problem they face is keeping it efficient
(enough) and timely. In my opinion, universality should be extended to
include prescribed drugs and basic dentistry.
But I think you think Canadians demand government-only health care - that's
not necessarily the case. Heck, almost all doctors are essentially private
business men who charge the government for services rendered. It's not
government-only health care most Canadians want, it's quality timely
*universal* health care we want. Rich or poor you get the cure. Ugly or fair
you'll get good care. Whether a particular service is delivered by
government or by private company is beside the point.
One of the generally accepted reasons for the CBC is that it is considered
stalwart vis a vis Canadian culture - a culture that would otherwise be
swamped by the huge cultural machine to the south. It provides a sort of
cultural common ground for Canadians. CBC's role varies from decade to
decade. For instance, it is the big hockey broadcaster. But now there's
discussion that the private companies should handle the Hockey Night in
Canada contract.
And, for sure, there's plenty of competition .. we have all the usual
channels on basic cable except, of course, FOX News <snicker> and the
channel that plays every al-Qaeda video bin Laden sends it, Aljazeera. FOX
News and the specialty channels you can get if you buy a bundle on digital
cable. Aljazeera is available, I think, only if you use "grey market"
satellite stuff if you can get it at all - let's just say Aljazeera is not
exactly welcome. But basic cable even includes some BBC News on the CBC news
network. And we even have stuff coming in from Paris on some of the French
channels. But there are plenty of privately owned television and radio
networks in Canada and, of course, we get the big American channels.
So overall I think you misunderstand how "socialist" Canada is. There are
some crown corporations, sure, but these usually [not always] have to
compete with private ones. Crown Corporations exist because there's a
perceived need for them, not to serve socialism. Yes, our flag is white and
red, but the official colours of Canada (white and red) come from Queen
Victoria in the nineteenth century not from socialism. The socialists in
Canada use the colour orange.