Whew, sometimes you just over analyze things. If you didn't get the joke
about Farm Animals, then you were not around the right people. Though it's
hard to believe you've never heard the stereotypes about country boys and
farm animals
Though the Army is full of good ol country boys, I don't know that Military
bases really count as being in the Rural part of those states. (as they
called it Cream beef and toast, and I grew up calling it gravy, or sausage
gravy) Maybe I should have said "Rural Southern states". I myself have been
to the northeast a fair amount, and never heard them say Dinner for Lunch or
Supper for Dinner" I have been to little places like Big Spring, Texas,
Muskogee, OK and Co-worker from somewhere in West Kansas and quite a few say
"Supper" for dinner. Most of us, who've been out of the sticks for a while,
have switched to lunch, mostly because the proper English people just get
all worked up when we say Dinner for Lunch, much like those same people get
worked up for the words "ain't", "Fixin'" and "Reckon". I had an amusing
conversation with guys in Boston once, over the what's the difference
between, "Y'all", "All Yall" and "You All"
My Statement was you normally, Not a You always. Much like the original guy
said, it's generally the Northern Englanders say Supper for Dinner. I'm sure
that doesn't apply to100% of them, I'd give you five to one odds, if you
hear someone say Dinner for Lunch or supper for dinner, they are going to be
from the south or Mid west, Probably over 35 and from the rural parts of the
state (cause those are the areas where education is top priority) .
I'm not the only one who thinks like this, check out some of the answers in
these polls
http://ca.answers.yahoo.com/question/index.php?qid=20070319204203AAUwuW8&show=7
http://www.postpunkkitchen.com/forum/viewtopic.php?id=21717