Is this true about ASUS?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Post Replies Here Please
  • Start date Start date
Locutus> nothing wrong with that Linux sucks so why support it

Just an opinion ;-)
 
Post Replies Here Please said:
Locutus> nothing wrong with that Linux sucks so why support it

Just an opinion ;-)
Click to expand...

yeh I meant no offense to you sorry :(

just my opinion
 
I have owned 2 ASUS motherboards
1. ASUS P4B
2. ASUS A7N8X

Both ran Redhat and Mandrake very well.
 
http://www.mozillaquest.com/Linux04/Asus_Sucks_Story-01.html

I'm a big fan of ASUS and was not aware of this.
Click to expand...

It's very hard for me to understand the article. They talk about using
a K8V SE Deluxe motherboard which is what I have. Mandrake 10, 64bit
RC1 found and installed ALL my hardware including the on-board sound,
on-board NIC, etc.

FWIW, MB = ASUS K8V SE Deluxe with latest BIOS and AMD64 3400 chip.
Video card is ATI Radeon 7000. 1Gig (2 500MB sticks) of Fry's cheapest
3600 DDR RAM. Canon S900 Photo Printer, HP LaserJet 6L, Microtek V6upl
scanner connected via USB2 port. HP DVD Writer 200i, LG DVD ROM.

The on-board sound is SoundMax Integrated Digatal Audio and the LAN is
Marvell Yukon Gigabit Ethernet 10/100/1000 Base-T adaptor, Copper RJ-
45.

No problems with any of this. Conclusion, WTF is he talking about?

I have also installed Fedora 64bit which did have a problem with my
sound card, SuSE 64bit which had NO problems and Linspire (formerly
Lindows) which installed all the hardware with no problems.

Again, WTF is he talking about?

BTW, ASUS has NO need or requirement to supply drivers for ANY OS and
never has.

Windows XP is running on the same system using drivers supplied by the
manufacturers of the sound card and LAN, NOT drivers by ASUS. The
drivers that run the sound card and LAN in Linux are supplied by
various folks in the open source community or possibly by the same
manufacturers who supplied the drivers for Windows XP so.....

The total article is pure, unadulterated horsepucky from someone who
has no idea of what he/she/it is talking about.
 
Wes> Really. Could you tell me why it sucks? And what OS should I be
Wes> using, and why?

Don't take the bait ;-)). Anyway all operating systems suck ;-)).

I use ______. Whatever it takes to get the job done.

Whatever.
 
Wes said:
Really. Could you tell me why it sucks? And what OS should I be using, and
why?
Click to expand...


It sucks because it takes a certain level of brain power to get it up and
running.

It sucks because for Average Joe, it's too complicated.

It's great because it free, powerful, stable, provides you with choice and
the community can, and do contribute in so many ways.

Ben
 
Wes said:
Really. Could you tell me why it sucks? And what OS should I be using, and
why?
Click to expand...

Of course he won't be able to reply to you with any meaningful answers, that
would require the interuption of his blissful state of ignorance.
 
XS11E said:
It's very hard for me to understand the article. They talk about using
a K8V SE Deluxe motherboard which is what I have. Mandrake 10, 64bit
RC1 found and installed ALL my hardware including the on-board sound,
on-board NIC, etc.

FWIW, MB = ASUS K8V SE Deluxe with latest BIOS and AMD64 3400 chip.
Video card is ATI Radeon 7000. 1Gig (2 500MB sticks) of Fry's cheapest
3600 DDR RAM. Canon S900 Photo Printer, HP LaserJet 6L, Microtek V6upl
scanner connected via USB2 port. HP DVD Writer 200i, LG DVD ROM.

The on-board sound is SoundMax Integrated Digatal Audio and the LAN is
Marvell Yukon Gigabit Ethernet 10/100/1000 Base-T adaptor, Copper RJ-
45.

No problems with any of this. Conclusion, WTF is he talking about?

I have also installed Fedora 64bit which did have a problem with my
sound card, SuSE 64bit which had NO problems and Linspire (formerly
Lindows) which installed all the hardware with no problems.

Again, WTF is he talking about?

BTW, ASUS has NO need or requirement to supply drivers for ANY OS and
never has.

Windows XP is running on the same system using drivers supplied by the
manufacturers of the sound card and LAN, NOT drivers by ASUS. The
drivers that run the sound card and LAN in Linux are supplied by
various folks in the open source community or possibly by the same
manufacturers who supplied the drivers for Windows XP so.....

The total article is pure, unadulterated horsepucky from someone who
has no idea of what he/she/it is talking about.
Click to expand...
Exactly what I thought reading this crap.
I'm using a L5-series ASUS notebook, running debian 3.1 sarge (from
dvd). The only hardware not yet compatible is the WLAN-network adapter.
The author judges ASUS only because they're not T H E company changing
the world of computing.

Michael
 
It sucks because it takes a certain level of brain power to get it
up and running.

It sucks because for Average Joe, it's too complicated.

It's great because it free, powerful, stable, provides you with
choice and the community can, and do contribute in so many ways.
Click to expand...

It sucks because some of the applications I need are available only for
Windows and/or MAC. I'm hoping that will change sometime in the future
and the many, many people who *need* to run Windows will be able to go
to Linux full time or, more likely, someday I'll finally decide to give
up my attempts at learning Linux.

Until then, I'm still quadruple booting.. <sigh>
 
XS11E's last words before the Sword of Azrial plunged through his body
were:
It sucks because some of the applications I need are available only for
Windows and/or MAC. I'm hoping that will change sometime in the future
and the many, many people who *need* to run Windows will be able to go
to Linux full time or, more likely, someday I'll finally decide to give
up my attempts at learning Linux.
Click to expand...

Have you tried Wine, Cedega (formally WineX), or Crossover Office? And do
they have a decent Open Source alternative? Right now I have two apps that
aren't linux friendly by the last two measures, 3d Studio Max 3.1 (yeah,
its old but its what I could afford and dont really like the new versions
as much), and Poser 4. 3dsmax craps out before it can get the loading
splash screen up if I try with a Windows API of some sort (Wine, etc), and
Poser loads, but the on screen graphical controls are invisible (but
everything else, including the viewport, works).
 
http://www.mozillaquest.com/Linux04/Asus_Sucks_Story-01.html

I'm a big fan of ASUS and was not aware of this.

Whatever.
Click to expand...

The bigger issue is that Taiwanese companies are focused entirely on cost,
quality and customer support take a back seat. A couple of years ago I
developed a file server for a medium sized (~$500M) company. Dealing with
Supermicro or 3Ware, which are Silicon Valley based, was easy. If there
was a problem they did their best to address it. Dealing with Taiwan based
companies was impossible, they simply didn't have the capacity or the
inclination to respond to even a $500M company so you can imagine how bad
the service for smaller OEMs must be like. Unfortunately SuperMicro
doesn't make Opteron boards.
 
General Schvantzkoph said:
The bigger issue is that Taiwanese companies are focused entirely on cost,
quality and customer support take a back seat. A couple of years ago I
developed a file server for a medium sized (~$500M) company. Dealing with
Supermicro or 3Ware, which are Silicon Valley based, was easy. If there
was a problem they did their best to address it. Dealing with Taiwan based
companies was impossible, they simply didn't have the capacity or the
inclination to respond to even a $500M company so you can imagine how bad
the service for smaller OEMs must be like. Unfortunately SuperMicro
doesn't make Opteron boards.
Click to expand...

I believe Supermicro doesn't make any AMD based motherboards.
 
XS11E said:
Yes.
Click to expand...

1. Tell me the file type (not the application, because there's no use
using these crap-apps like microsoft office, adobde photoshop/cinemaXd,
internet explorer when there are openoffice.org, gimp/blender, mozilla
firefox doing the better work for you with the same file types) not
supported by any GNU/Linux ported application
2. I do not hope that there is going to be a microsoft office for linux,
but I do hope openoffice.org for win to be used more often.

michael
 
Yes.
Click to expand...

What type apps are you talking about? Are they custom to support a
proprietary product? if so, you may never see a Linux version. You also
may never see a version for the next version of windows. But, AFAIK, there
are linux equivalants of almost any win apps. Do you want to share the
name of the app you are talking about. If not, then you might as well drop
the subject. Here's a list (although certainly not complete) of linux to
win equivalant apps.

http://linuxshop.ru/linuxbegin/win-lin-soft-en/table.shtml
 
Wes Newell said:
What type apps are you talking about? Are they custom to support a
proprietary product? if so, you may never see a Linux version. You also
may never see a version for the next version of windows. But, AFAIK, there
are linux equivalants of almost any win apps. Do you want to share the
name of the app you are talking about. If not, then you might as well drop
the subject. Here's a list (although certainly not complete) of linux to
win equivalant apps.

http://linuxshop.ru/linuxbegin/win-lin-soft-en/table.shtml
Click to expand...

The biggest problem I have with using Linux only is GAMES.
1. The Sims
2. Sim City 4
3. Sacrifice
4. Diblo 2
5. Dungeon Siege
6. Command & Conquer: Generals
7. Command & Conquer: Red Alert
8. Hitman 2
9. Tomb Raider:The Angel Of Darness
10. Evolva
11. Age Of Empires
12. Flight Simulater 2004
13. Raven Shield
14. Warcraft 3

Just to name a few. LOL
 
Pseudo Namen's last words before the Sword of Azrial plunged through his
body were:
The biggest problem I have with using Linux only is GAMES.
1. The Sims
Click to expand...

There is a linux port
2. Sim City 4
Click to expand...

has a linux port
6. Command & Conquer: Generals
Click to expand...

Hmm, cant remember if this one can run with the Wines. I know after EA
bought out Eastwood, they started putting in antidebugger code, which
messes with Wine.
7. Command & Conquer: Red Alert
11. Age Of Empires
Click to expand...

Runs with Cedega
4. Diblo 2
Click to expand...

One of the games that is supposed to work flawlessly under Wine
12. Flight Simulater 2004
Click to expand...

Can't run under Wine, cedega or Crossover Office
8. Hitman 2
Click to expand...

First one works, but this one has some conflicts that make it not run.
Think the anti-debugger issue
3. Sacrifice
Click to expand...

Runs under Cedega
5. Dungeon Siege
Click to expand...

Has some issues, but runs
9. Tomb Raider:The Angel Of Darness
Click to expand...

This one doesnt install, because the installer doesnt want to switch disks
under Wine, but I'm not sure if a preexisting install would work
10. Evolva
Click to expand...

Installs but can't be run
13. Raven Shield
Click to expand...

Installs, runs, but has some problems with things like key configuration,
etc. Since its based off UT2003, shouldnt be that much longer till its
run able I dont think.
14. Warcraft 3
Click to expand...

Again one of the ones that works flawlessly under cedega.

What other games do you have questions on? Just because you think they
dont have a native linux port, doesnt mean they won't run (plus as I said,
a couple do have native ports).
 
Back
Top