jeff said:
<snipped>
I don't think I did attack the poster. I just didn't want hear what he
had to say. Which he didn't seem to understand nor do you it seems.
"Mr Arnold" you say you don't think you attacked Seth. This is of course
good because, even if your posts came across badly, it means that you did
not intend them to. We are all guilty from time to time of rash decisions
and of jumping to conclusions.
However we now have a total of 3 people (Seth, jeff and myself) who think
Seth's position is a valid one. Save for myself (I'm sure there is time yet),
I would say you have been, at the very least, unpleasent to all of them.
These people are simply giving their opinion.
Seth's point was a direct counterpoint to your own and in the natural flow
of a conversation it made most sense that he reply to you rather than directly
to the OP. This is usually to help the flow of understanding from one post
to the next.
I'll tell anyone who is doing Web development with no exceptions. One
uses a workstation O/S that supports a Web Server such as Win 2k Pro,
XP Pro and Vista, and I don't care what VS 2005 has in it.
There is no maybe(s), black or white and in betweens with me
concerning this - none.
About whether this is your opinion or not, I agree - There can of course
be no debate.
About whether this is reasonable or not. Well... you have as I say, had 3
people suggest the opposite.
I hate to break it to you, but in the real world...
.... there are shades of grey
.... there are business concerns
.... there is opinion
.... there are exceptions
all with good reason.
Are you really saying that when confronted with an apparent choice between
option a and option b, you never look for an option c because "There is no
maybe(s), black or white and in betweens with me"
"I'll *tell* anyone", "One uses", "I don't care" - *If* this is truely the
case (but I suspect not) then don't be surprised if *most* ignore you.
The balance of probability suggests that the OP would care about "what VS
2005 has in it".
That's my opinion and my take on things that I
have applied to IT since 1971.
Again opinion should be flexible to new idea's. If your opinion had not changed
at all in all those years then it would be a miracle if you were still employed/in
business. Again I suspect that you are in fact more flexible than you let on.
There would be no way some thing like
XP Home Edition would even be considered, and XP Pro should have been
the O/S the OP should have gotten right out of the gate.
As indicated, the world is not Black and White.
Depends if the user had any say in the matter or even knew about the limitation
in the first place.
he might have been hopeing to turn a hobby into something more. Typically
people not based in the industry have very little need of XPPro and would
have to use the family PC (Very likely to have XPHome on it) for any experimental
programming that they might be doing.