Hard drive clunking, now seems dead

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert Downes
  • Start date Start date
Trent© said:
I don't want to beat a dead horse to death...so I guess I'll just quit
with the advice. Drives do indeed go bad...and some are even DOA. So
it looks like that may indeed by your problem.

But I've just got this gut feeling that you've got something
configured wrong in the BIOS for this drive...or a bad cable...or...?

Especially when you're testing back and forth between an EIDE drive
and then comparing it to the results when you try to use the SATA
drive.

More important than XP installer is the BIOS. You should be able to
see the drive in the CMOS screen as the computer boots.

Well, seeing as overclockers.co.uk are suddenly very quiet since I asked
to return the drive, I'm happy to keep investigating.

But can the rest of the machine get damaged by trying to talk to a
damaged drive (assuming it is damaged)? Voltages aren't going to be
wild, and risk screwing the I/O chip, or similar woe?

If not, I'll plug it in again and see whether anything can see the drive
anymore.
 
Well, seeing as overclockers.co.uk are suddenly very quiet since I asked
to return the drive, I'm happy to keep investigating.

But can the rest of the machine get damaged by trying to talk to a
damaged drive (assuming it is damaged)? Voltages aren't going to be
wild, and risk screwing the I/O chip, or similar woe?

No...no problem of screwing up the rest of the machine.

If not, I'll plug it in again and see whether anything can see the drive
anymore.

Forget about talking about Windows for now. Windows is simply an
operating system. You don't need to worry about Windows at this
point.

You said its a SATA drive. Make sure you have the cables connected
the way they should be...and that you have your BIOS set up to
recognize that drive. Then boot the computer.

What's the make and model of that drive?...or your mainboard?

You should be able to see that drive...at pretty close to its stated
size...in the CMOS screen as it boots. I'm assuming that its plugged
into the mainboard...and not into a controller card.

When you boot it, you can actually boot into a Windows 98 rescue disk
if you want...or some other boot disk...as long as its not an NTFS
drive at this point.

Do you have S.M.A.R.T. for that drive turned on in the BIOS? Some of
the modern drives will clunk quite a bit if they're trying to repair
themselves. But if it never stops...or even if it does...you may
indeed have a bad drive...as everyone has said.

If you've installed a SATA drive before, you should know what yer
doin'. So I'd tend to agree with the others at this point...that its
a bad drive. Just send it back and get another.

Good luck...let us know.


Have a nice week...

Trent

Follow Joan Rivers' example --- get pre-embalmed!
 
You can run the diagnostic software for the maxtor drive. It will either fix
it or fail it .
Then just contact Maxtor and they will ship you another drive and you return
the old one.
The software spits out a code or information that tells the Maxtor people
the drive is dead. I returned a drive under warrantee and they shipped back
a bigger and better one.
 
Back
Top