S
Skybuck Flying
Some more interesting reports and possible conclusions.
Yesterday the DreamPC was on for a long time running Linux Mint 11, suddenly
I started hearing this ticking sound.
Tick, Tick, Tick, Tick, Tick.
Apperently it was coming from the DreamPC.
I suspect one of the harddisk heads was hitting the platter repeatedly over
and over and over again.
I decided to turn off the system.
Today I turn on the system and immediatly boot into Linux Mint 11 also
because yesterday Windows did not want to boot because
of boot manager/disk problems/bad sectors ? Which was kinda weird. Linux
Mint 11 yesterday had some trouble starting because of bad sectors
it seems but ultimately managed to boot from dvd.
I was surprised that today Linux Mint 11 booted up just fine and I was also
surprised that the harddisks are working again.
Even Windows 7 came back alive surprisingly which is what I am using now.
I also checked the bad sectors on the Windows 7 System drive which is one of
the new 2 TB hitachi drives.
The drive now has 366 bad sectors, which is reported by Linux Mint 11 as
"some bad sectors".
The number of bad sectors seems to have increased I think... probably caused
by the ticking yesterday.
The ticking is gone today, the ticking yesterday occured very suddenly,
therefore I shall have to come to the following conclusion:
The cause of the ticking could be:
Micro vibrations and resonance.
So my hypothesis is now the following:
The spinning of the harddisk bay fans cause micro vibrations, if these micro
vibrations somehow match the frequency of the material of the harddisk head
then the harddisk head starts to vibrate/resonante, like that famous bridge
which ultimately collapsed because of wind and resonance.
I also tried to cause more damage to the remaining harddisk by bumping my
table a couple of times and rocking it back and forth a little bit, the
monitor rocked a bit back and forth but the PC not... probably too heavy...
I also checked with Linux Mint 11 and the other two harddisks which were
undamaged remain undamaged, so bumping the table does not lead to damage or
bad sectors, at least not immediatly.
I also thought about smacking the horn of the phone on it and maybe that
caused damage when I was angry once, but that seems to be impossible as
well.
Rocking back and forth my table wasn't too smart, the table is a bit shacky
as well, fortunately no damage occured.
I am starting to believe the "micro vibration and resonance" hypothesis and
therefore I have secured my remaining harddisks, by attaching the 24
harddisk bay screws to the drive bays.
I am now also starting to believe that Antec company must have known about
the need for 24 screws, they must have known this is necessary to provide
the harddisk with some more stability.
The advice of somebody else on usenet to leave only a few screws attached or
none at all appears to have been foolish, at least assuming this is cause of
damage, which starts to become more believable.
I also notice the bottom harddisk bay has slightly more vibrations, this can
be explained by two factors:
1. The power fan is on the bottom.
2. The bottom tray contains two harddisks.
The other two middle and top bays are nearly vibrationless now that the
screws have been attached.
So without screws there was some vibration feeling by fingers touching it.
With screws the vibration is nearly gone.
This was felt/measured at low fan speed.
Since filters are gone I keep fans at low fan speed to prevent hairs from
being sucked in, this seems smart setting to use at least for my much lower
heat graphics card.
Perhaps my system could now take much more heatfull graphics cards, but I
dare not risk it and the graphics card would get full with dust anyway and
then overheat motherboard again so I am not going to do that.
I also wonder if perhaps electrical issue might still be cause of some
strange behaviours, but for now it's probably the vibrations and bad sectors
which caused some weird stuff to happen.
I shall now enjoy my computer a bit more... and hopefully soon I will be
able to buy some new harddisks. It's could to try and figure out what cause
of death was to try and prevent it in future otherwise it would be useless
to buy new stuff.
For now I am still a bit skeptical though So I will run my system some
more to see if the ticking returns
I have one more good idea, I shall now place the speakers on the ground
instead of the table, perhaps the gaming I did also contributed to
damage/bad sectors/vibrations.
Perhaps I should test that theory by blasting some sound from speakers, but
I don't feel that test is worth... I might as well place speakers on ground
unless perhaps I can then enjoy music and sound less, but that is something
I am going to try it probably won't matter
that much so the speakers are going on the floor for now... It's a bit dirty
there but so what
Bye,
Skybuck.
Yesterday the DreamPC was on for a long time running Linux Mint 11, suddenly
I started hearing this ticking sound.
Tick, Tick, Tick, Tick, Tick.
Apperently it was coming from the DreamPC.
I suspect one of the harddisk heads was hitting the platter repeatedly over
and over and over again.
I decided to turn off the system.
Today I turn on the system and immediatly boot into Linux Mint 11 also
because yesterday Windows did not want to boot because
of boot manager/disk problems/bad sectors ? Which was kinda weird. Linux
Mint 11 yesterday had some trouble starting because of bad sectors
it seems but ultimately managed to boot from dvd.
I was surprised that today Linux Mint 11 booted up just fine and I was also
surprised that the harddisks are working again.
Even Windows 7 came back alive surprisingly which is what I am using now.
I also checked the bad sectors on the Windows 7 System drive which is one of
the new 2 TB hitachi drives.
The drive now has 366 bad sectors, which is reported by Linux Mint 11 as
"some bad sectors".
The number of bad sectors seems to have increased I think... probably caused
by the ticking yesterday.
The ticking is gone today, the ticking yesterday occured very suddenly,
therefore I shall have to come to the following conclusion:
The cause of the ticking could be:
Micro vibrations and resonance.
So my hypothesis is now the following:
The spinning of the harddisk bay fans cause micro vibrations, if these micro
vibrations somehow match the frequency of the material of the harddisk head
then the harddisk head starts to vibrate/resonante, like that famous bridge
which ultimately collapsed because of wind and resonance.
I also tried to cause more damage to the remaining harddisk by bumping my
table a couple of times and rocking it back and forth a little bit, the
monitor rocked a bit back and forth but the PC not... probably too heavy...
I also checked with Linux Mint 11 and the other two harddisks which were
undamaged remain undamaged, so bumping the table does not lead to damage or
bad sectors, at least not immediatly.
I also thought about smacking the horn of the phone on it and maybe that
caused damage when I was angry once, but that seems to be impossible as
well.
Rocking back and forth my table wasn't too smart, the table is a bit shacky
as well, fortunately no damage occured.
I am starting to believe the "micro vibration and resonance" hypothesis and
therefore I have secured my remaining harddisks, by attaching the 24
harddisk bay screws to the drive bays.
I am now also starting to believe that Antec company must have known about
the need for 24 screws, they must have known this is necessary to provide
the harddisk with some more stability.
The advice of somebody else on usenet to leave only a few screws attached or
none at all appears to have been foolish, at least assuming this is cause of
damage, which starts to become more believable.
I also notice the bottom harddisk bay has slightly more vibrations, this can
be explained by two factors:
1. The power fan is on the bottom.
2. The bottom tray contains two harddisks.
The other two middle and top bays are nearly vibrationless now that the
screws have been attached.
So without screws there was some vibration feeling by fingers touching it.
With screws the vibration is nearly gone.
This was felt/measured at low fan speed.
Since filters are gone I keep fans at low fan speed to prevent hairs from
being sucked in, this seems smart setting to use at least for my much lower
heat graphics card.
Perhaps my system could now take much more heatfull graphics cards, but I
dare not risk it and the graphics card would get full with dust anyway and
then overheat motherboard again so I am not going to do that.
I also wonder if perhaps electrical issue might still be cause of some
strange behaviours, but for now it's probably the vibrations and bad sectors
which caused some weird stuff to happen.
I shall now enjoy my computer a bit more... and hopefully soon I will be
able to buy some new harddisks. It's could to try and figure out what cause
of death was to try and prevent it in future otherwise it would be useless
to buy new stuff.
For now I am still a bit skeptical though So I will run my system some
more to see if the ticking returns
I have one more good idea, I shall now place the speakers on the ground
instead of the table, perhaps the gaming I did also contributed to
damage/bad sectors/vibrations.
Perhaps I should test that theory by blasting some sound from speakers, but
I don't feel that test is worth... I might as well place speakers on ground
unless perhaps I can then enjoy music and sound less, but that is something
I am going to try it probably won't matter
that much so the speakers are going on the floor for now... It's a bit dirty
there but so what
Bye,
Skybuck.