J
Jack B
Paul said:
Thanks - I will stew on this for a day or 2, and then probably buy the
Newegg PC Chips board.
Jack
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Thanks - I will stew on this for a day or 2, and then probably buy the
Newegg PC Chips board.
Jack
K
kony
The new PSU is an Antec BP350 that I bought at Circuit City for $40. It
would be an unlikely coincidence that this brand new PSU, plus the one I
removed from the computer, plus the old 200 PSU I tried were all bad, so I
think the problem must be elsewhere.
I agree it's unlikely, but really the first PSU wasn't bad
until (it might've) failed, the second 200W was likely of
insufficient capacity. You'd just have to be exceptionally
unlucky if this new one had a defect though stranger things
have happened.
I disconnected both the hard drive and the CD Rom drive and the computer
still does not start (once in a while it starts, but only runs for a few
seconds). I've taken the memory out and reseated it and no change. I see
the capacitors you've mentioned, but I don't know how to check if one or
more are bad.
They tend to look domed on top, crusty residue on top or
bottom, or sometimes canted funny from pulling away from the
rubber plug. Examples:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v711/whurd/Bad.jpg
http://heliosstudios.net/temp/DSCF0646_small.jpg
I haven't pulled the heat sink or CPU, as it's a little
awkward getting at it and I don't want to force anything. Anyway, since the
main problem is that the computer won't start at all, even after it's been
sitting for hours, I'm thinking heat is not the problem.
If it were overheating so badly that it kept the system from
even posting, the processor would've probably been fried
already and you wouldn't have had any success at all, which
you did have just getting it to start to POST again before
shutting down.
I guess I'll buy a board online, and swap that in, unless someone has
another suggestion.
With a multimeter, monitor the PSU voltages while trying to
power up the system. You might also remove the video card
and memory and then try turning the system on. Of course it
won't post, but you could then see if the system shut itself
off or stayed on. Same with the processor, pull it out and
see if the system stays powered or shuts off. I think I
would at least pull the heatsink off and examine the CPU
(including the back, if these Athlons run really hot for
more than a moment it will tend to make the back center look
darker brown) then remount it, before ordering the
replacement motherboard (since you have to pull the board
out to swap it anyway). Then again if that means making
another trip to do so, it may be time to just replace the
board lacking any other damning evidence.
K
kony
Whatever board you get, you'll need to do a Repair Install of
Windows, and that will give you an opportunity to load in some
new drivers.
http://www.michaelstevenstech.com/XPrepairinstall.htm
If he gets an nForce2 board, the odds are good there will be
no repair install needed, that it will boot Windows far
enough to plug-n-play any minor differences, and this
without any prior preparation to the OS. Of course there
might still be a driver or two that needs installed.
J
Jack B
Well, here is the latest on this thread, and no, I haven't solved the
problem yet. I put in a new mb, PC Chips M848A, and also added a stick of
512 mem, doubling what was there. I also have the new power supply in,
although, at this point, I don't think the original one was bad. The result
of all that is that now the computer mostly does not turn on. That is,
sometimes it does and sometimes it doesn't. When it turns on, it stays on.
I have not hooked up the video or modem cards, HD, or Cd Rom yet. Mostly,
when I press the on button nothing happens. Occasionally, it does turn on,
but when I turn it off and then on, it stays off. I've tried shorting the
power switch pins on the mb by hand, but nothing happens there either.
I'm at a loss, and don't know what to do now.
Jack
problem yet. I put in a new mb, PC Chips M848A, and also added a stick of
512 mem, doubling what was there. I also have the new power supply in,
although, at this point, I don't think the original one was bad. The result
of all that is that now the computer mostly does not turn on. That is,
sometimes it does and sometimes it doesn't. When it turns on, it stays on.
I have not hooked up the video or modem cards, HD, or Cd Rom yet. Mostly,
when I press the on button nothing happens. Occasionally, it does turn on,
but when I turn it off and then on, it stays off. I've tried shorting the
power switch pins on the mb by hand, but nothing happens there either.
I'm at a loss, and don't know what to do now.
Jack
P
Paul
Jack said:Well, here is the latest on this thread, and no, I haven't solved the
problem yet. I put in a new mb, PC Chips M848A, and also added a stick
of 512 mem, doubling what was there. I also have the new power supply
in, although, at this point, I don't think the original one was bad.
The result of all that is that now the computer mostly does not turn
on. That is, sometimes it does and sometimes it doesn't. When it turns
on, it stays on. I have not hooked up the video or modem cards, HD, or
Cd Rom yet. Mostly, when I press the on button nothing happens.
Occasionally, it does turn on, but when I turn it off and then on, it
stays off. I've tried shorting the power switch pins on the mb by hand,
but nothing happens there either.
I'm at a loss, and don't know what to do now.
Jack
These are the perils of home computer repair - a mounting pile of swapped
in hardware, as you try to narrow down the problem. Which is why my previous
posting, had an option to just bail on the Athlon.
If the fans twitch just for an instant, on the occasions when it fails
to turn on, then you know the motherboard is sending PN_ON# to the power
supply, so it actually tried to turn on. If it just "sits there", and there
is no response at all to pressing the computer case power button, then
you might suspect the motherboard is not sending PS_ON# at all. In that
case, it could be a bad power button on the computer front case, or since
this is a new motherboard, it could also be a motherboard defect.
OK, I have another test you can try. Try removing the processor from
the S462 socket (with power disconnected from the wall of course). Then
see if the power button can be used to reliably turn the power supply on
and off. Basically, you are testing motherboard, power supply, and computer
case front power button. If it seems to work better, without the processor
in there, then perhaps the processor is overloading things. But I'd really
expect to see a little bit of fan twitching or spinning, before Vcore
overcurrent trips and causes things to shut off.
If the motherboard has a LED that is connected to +5VSB, that should stay
lit and not blink. The +5VSB rail should be present and on solid, for as
long as the power switch on the back of the PSU is in the ON position.
If +5VSB winks out, that can prevent things from starting too. On motherboards
without a monitoring LED for +5VSB, you have one less feature to help with
the debugging.
Paul
J
Jack B
Paul said:These are the perils of home computer repair - a mounting pile of swapped
in hardware, as you try to narrow down the problem. Which is why my
previous
posting, had an option to just bail on the Athlon.
If the fans twitch just for an instant, on the occasions when it fails
to turn on, then you know the motherboard is sending PN_ON# to the power
supply, so it actually tried to turn on. If it just "sits there", and
there
is no response at all to pressing the computer case power button, then
you might suspect the motherboard is not sending PS_ON# at all. In that
case, it could be a bad power button on the computer front case, or since
this is a new motherboard, it could also be a motherboard defect.
OK, I have another test you can try. Try removing the processor from
the S462 socket (with power disconnected from the wall of course). Then
see if the power button can be used to reliably turn the power supply on
and off. Basically, you are testing motherboard, power supply, and
computer
case front power button. If it seems to work better, without the processor
in there, then perhaps the processor is overloading things. But I'd really
expect to see a little bit of fan twitching or spinning, before Vcore
overcurrent trips and causes things to shut off.
If the motherboard has a LED that is connected to +5VSB, that should stay
lit and not blink. The +5VSB rail should be present and on solid, for as
long as the power switch on the back of the PSU is in the ON position.
If +5VSB winks out, that can prevent things from starting too. On
motherboards
without a monitoring LED for +5VSB, you have one less feature to help with
the debugging.
Paul
Thanks for the advice - here are a few more tidbits of info on things I've
tried or seen that may trigger something with somebody:
1)I've put an ohmmeter on the power switch wires and when I push the power
button, I do see a drop in resistance to 0, so I assume from that the power
switch is working.
2) I've replaced the power cord to the computer - no change.
3) With the computer plugged in, I measure 25 mv on the larger power
connectors in the pc (like the ones that plug into HD). I don't know if
that's normal, but that's what I get.
4) When I press the power switch, the fans (2 fans - CPU fan plugged into mb
and case fan plugged into PSU connector) do not budge EXCEPT - sometimes
after I have pressed the on button and nothing has happened, a few seconds
later both fans move. They don't move much, maybe a turn or 3, but they
definitely turn. The first couple of times it happened, I thought I just
jostled something to cause that, but that is not it - they just turn by
themselves. Maybe a capacitor is discharging or something - I don't know.
This has happened maybe 5 or 10% of the time I have pressed the switch.
5)My new mb does not have an LED lite, but the old one does. I just plugged
the PSU into the old board, and the LED lite lit up.
6) I just removed the CPU and still no start. So, now I have just the mb,
PSU connected to anything.
Any thoughts will be greatly appreciated.
Thanks,
Jack
K
kony
Thanks for the advice - here are a few more tidbits of info on things I've
tried or seen that may trigger something with somebody:
1)I've put an ohmmeter on the power switch wires and when I push the power
button, I do see a drop in resistance to 0, so I assume from that the power
switch is working.
2) I've replaced the power cord to the computer - no change.
3) With the computer plugged in, I measure 25 mv on the larger power
connectors in the pc (like the ones that plug into HD). I don't know if
that's normal, but that's what I get.
4) When I press the power switch, the fans (2 fans - CPU fan plugged into mb
and case fan plugged into PSU connector) do not budge EXCEPT - sometimes
after I have pressed the on button and nothing has happened, a few seconds
later both fans move. They don't move much, maybe a turn or 3, but they
definitely turn. The first couple of times it happened, I thought I just
jostled something to cause that, but that is not it - they just turn by
themselves. Maybe a capacitor is discharging or something - I don't know.
This has happened maybe 5 or 10% of the time I have pressed the switch.
5)My new mb does not have an LED lite, but the old one does. I just plugged
the PSU into the old board, and the LED lite lit up.
6) I just removed the CPU and still no start. So, now I have just the mb,
PSU connected to anything.
1) Unplug AC power from the PSU.
2) Unplug everything (really, everything) from the
motherboard. No CPU, no video, no memory, no front panel
connectors.
3) Double-check to be sure you don't have an extra standoff
on the motherboard tray that might be shorting out the back
of the board. A commonly overlooked stray standoff might be
on the left row (looking inside an ATX chassis) 2nd from the
bottom. Some boards have this mounting stud hole,
(including mATX and some ATX) and other ATX don't.
4) Take the battery out and check it's voltage. Check for
a battery insulator behind it (a piece of plastic). Check
the Clear CMOS jumper to ensure it's in the normal/running
position. Even if it is, now clear CMOS.
5) Check the PSU input 110/220 voltage switch to ensure
it's correct per your location.
6) Plug AC back into PSU, turn PSU rear switch on if so
equipped.
7) Use multimeter to measure 5VSB voltage. You'll need
needle probes to insert into the back of the ATX connector.
If these are not available, unplug AC, unplug PSU from mobo,
plug AC in and then measure 5VSB voltage from the pin-side
of the connector.
8) Plug PSU back into mobo, plug AC back into PSU.
9) Attempt to power on system by shorting the mobo's PS-On
pin to the (adjacent?) ground pin. Does the PSU fan spin,
even ever so slightly the moment you short the PS-On pin to
ground? If yes, measure voltages. If no, try plugging in
something putting a 12V load on the system like a hard
drive, then try again to power on system. If no still,
measure the power-good pin through the connector back while
shorting the mobo PS-On pin to ground. You may have to use
your 3rd arm to do this.
10) If no luck yet, disconnect PSU from mobo, connect PSU
only to a few hard drives. Short it's PS-On pin to ground
pin and see if it comes on. If it does, measure voltages.
If it does not, take a small ohm resistor (approx 10 Ohm,
2W+ rated) and put that between a 3.3V PSU pin and a ground
pin. Most PSU don't need this 3.3V load but I mention it to
be more thorough. Retry to turn on PSU shorting PS-On to
ground.
11) If the PSU came on, stayed on, and during that the
output voltages looked acceptible, I would speculate that
you are very unlucky and the new PCChips board is defective
and the old board died from the PSU failure... but just for
kicks, whichever board you used to try the above steps, now
lather rinse and repeat using the other board, then one of
the other PSU with both boards. That should keep you busy
till you don't give a damn anymore if it works or not. ;-)
J
Jack B
kony said:1) Unplug AC power from the PSU.
2) Unplug everything (really, everything) from the
motherboard. No CPU, no video, no memory, no front panel
connectors.
3) Double-check to be sure you don't have an extra standoff
on the motherboard tray that might be shorting out the back
of the board. A commonly overlooked stray standoff might be
on the left row (looking inside an ATX chassis) 2nd from the
bottom. Some boards have this mounting stud hole,
(including mATX and some ATX) and other ATX don't.
4) Take the battery out and check it's voltage. Check for
a battery insulator behind it (a piece of plastic). Check
the Clear CMOS jumper to ensure it's in the normal/running
position. Even if it is, now clear CMOS.
5) Check the PSU input 110/220 voltage switch to ensure
it's correct per your location.
6) Plug AC back into PSU, turn PSU rear switch on if so
equipped.
7) Use multimeter to measure 5VSB voltage. You'll need
needle probes to insert into the back of the ATX connector.
If these are not available, unplug AC, unplug PSU from mobo,
plug AC in and then measure 5VSB voltage from the pin-side
of the connector.
8) Plug PSU back into mobo, plug AC back into PSU.
9) Attempt to power on system by shorting the mobo's PS-On
pin to the (adjacent?) ground pin. Does the PSU fan spin,
even ever so slightly the moment you short the PS-On pin to
ground? If yes, measure voltages. If no, try plugging in
something putting a 12V load on the system like a hard
drive, then try again to power on system. If no still,
measure the power-good pin through the connector back while
shorting the mobo PS-On pin to ground. You may have to use
your 3rd arm to do this.
10) If no luck yet, disconnect PSU from mobo, connect PSU
only to a few hard drives. Short it's PS-On pin to ground
pin and see if it comes on. If it does, measure voltages.
If it does not, take a small ohm resistor (approx 10 Ohm,
2W+ rated) and put that between a 3.3V PSU pin and a ground
pin. Most PSU don't need this 3.3V load but I mention it to
be more thorough. Retry to turn on PSU shorting PS-On to
ground.
11) If the PSU came on, stayed on, and during that the
output voltages looked acceptible, I would speculate that
you are very unlucky and the new PCChips board is defective
and the old board died from the PSU failure... but just for
kicks, whichever board you used to try the above steps, now
lather rinse and repeat using the other board, then one of
the other PSU with both boards. That should keep you busy
till you don't give a damn anymore if it works or not. ;-)
Thanks for the detailed info. I will make the above my mission to
accomplish tomorrow. A few questions if I may, to make sure I understand? :
In 7) you mean I should measure V between pins 9 and 13 on the mb cable out
of the PSU? I'm getting that from a picture of an ATX connector on Inet.
In 10) are you saying I should short pins 14 and 13 on atx cable when it is
disconnected from mb? That would be the equivalent of turning on the power
switch if the cable were plugged in and everything was working? In other
words, if the PSU is plugged into AC, and I short pins 14 and 13, should the
PSU go on?
Thanks again,
Jack
K
kony
In 7) you mean I should measure V between pins 9 and 13 on the mb cable out
of the PSU? I'm getting that from a picture of an ATX connector on Inet.
http://69.36.166.207/usr_1034/atx_on.gif
Yes, pin 9 to any common ground pin like 13.
In 10) are you saying I should short pins 14 and 13 on atx cable when it is
disconnected from mb?
Yes, though I omitted that if you short 13-14 and it doesn't
come on, the next attempt should be attaching a small load
to 5V & 12V (ie - a hard drive) then trying again shorting
13-14.
That would be the equivalent of turning on the power
switch if the cable were plugged in and everything was working? In other
words, if the PSU is plugged into AC, and I short pins 14 and 13, should the
PSU go on?
Yes shorting 13-14 should turn the PSU on, sometimes it will
need an external load like the hard drive, and rarely a load
on 3.3V. As for it being the equivalent of turning it on by
the power switch, the power switch through the board does
cause the same logical state of pulling the PS-On line low
to turn on the PSU as you do by shorting PS-On to ground,
but the scenario is different since the PSU has much less
load.
It can't qualify the PSU as "good" but if it can't even do
that, it can show it is not functioning normally (usually
not correctly, but if we want to be strict/anal about the
specs, many PSU spec a minimal load per some rails that is
even higher than only one attached hard drive, but it is
very rare that only one HDD isn't enough to keep the PSU
running, even rarer a 3.3V load would also be needed).
There are always some "ifs", "ands", and "buts"... for
example I have a PSU here that has failed and has correct
5VSB readings while unplugged from a motherboard, and it
comes on if PS-On is shorted to ground, but the 5VSB circuit
has failed to an instable state and so while connected to a
motherboard it can't turn a system on. It was an old PSU
though not new like yours, and a failed fan seems to be the
initial cause.
J
Jack B
kony said:1) Unplug AC power from the PSU.
2) Unplug everything (really, everything) from the
motherboard. No CPU, no video, no memory, no front panel
connectors.
3) Double-check to be sure you don't have an extra standoff
on the motherboard tray that might be shorting out the back
of the board. A commonly overlooked stray standoff might be
on the left row (looking inside an ATX chassis) 2nd from the
bottom. Some boards have this mounting stud hole,
(including mATX and some ATX) and other ATX don't.
4) Take the battery out and check it's voltage. Check for
a battery insulator behind it (a piece of plastic). Check
the Clear CMOS jumper to ensure it's in the normal/running
position. Even if it is, now clear CMOS.
5) Check the PSU input 110/220 voltage switch to ensure
it's correct per your location.
6) Plug AC back into PSU, turn PSU rear switch on if so
equipped.
7) Use multimeter to measure 5VSB voltage. You'll need
needle probes to insert into the back of the ATX connector.
If these are not available, unplug AC, unplug PSU from mobo,
plug AC in and then measure 5VSB voltage from the pin-side
of the connector.
8) Plug PSU back into mobo, plug AC back into PSU.
9) Attempt to power on system by shorting the mobo's PS-On
pin to the (adjacent?) ground pin. Does the PSU fan spin,
even ever so slightly the moment you short the PS-On pin to
ground? If yes, measure voltages. If no, try plugging in
something putting a 12V load on the system like a hard
drive, then try again to power on system. If no still,
measure the power-good pin through the connector back while
shorting the mobo PS-On pin to ground. You may have to use
your 3rd arm to do this.
10) If no luck yet, disconnect PSU from mobo, connect PSU
only to a few hard drives. Short it's PS-On pin to ground
pin and see if it comes on. If it does, measure voltages.
If it does not, take a small ohm resistor (approx 10 Ohm,
2W+ rated) and put that between a 3.3V PSU pin and a ground
pin. Most PSU don't need this 3.3V load but I mention it to
be more thorough. Retry to turn on PSU shorting PS-On to
ground.
11) If the PSU came on, stayed on, and during that the
output voltages looked acceptible, I would speculate that
you are very unlucky and the new PCChips board is defective
and the old board died from the PSU failure... but just for
kicks, whichever board you used to try the above steps, now
lather rinse and repeat using the other board, then one of
the other PSU with both boards. That should keep you busy
till you don't give a damn anymore if it works or not. ;-)
I've tried most of what you suggested above, and got some interesting
results, I think.
No stray standoffs, batt voltage was 2.91 V, no insulation behind it, cmos
was set for normal, so I set for clear and replaced jumper to normal, PSU is
set for 115.
Now for the rest: Both the original and new PSU show 5 V at 5VSB pin. The
new PSU would not start when shorting pins anywhere with or without HD and
CDRom loads. (I didn't try the 10 ohm resistor thing) However, the old PSU
does start when I short the proper pins, but it does not stay on - it runs
for maybe 5 seconds and stops.
So, now I'm thinking/hoping that maybe the original PSU was the problem all
along, and the new one I bought from Circuit City happened to be defective,
meaning the original mb may be ok and I'll be able to return the new one to
Newegg. Anyway, I am off to CC to return the PSU.
Any suggestions will be appreciated.
Jack
K
kony
I've tried most of what you suggested above, and got some interesting
results, I think.
No stray standoffs, batt voltage was 2.91 V, no insulation behind it, cmos
was set for normal, so I set for clear and replaced jumper to normal, PSU is
set for 115.
Now for the rest: Both the original and new PSU show 5 V at 5VSB pin. The
new PSU would not start when shorting pins anywhere with or without HD and
CDRom loads. (I didn't try the 10 ohm resistor thing) However, the old PSU
does start when I short the proper pins, but it does not stay on - it runs
for maybe 5 seconds and stops.
Assuming the old PSU also had the HDD (& CDROM) connected
when it shuts off, it does seem it is also bad.
So, now I'm thinking/hoping that maybe the original PSU was the problem all
along, and the new one I bought from Circuit City happened to be defective,
meaning the original mb may be ok and I'll be able to return the new one to
Newegg. Anyway, I am off to CC to return the PSU.
Yes this seems the best next step.