R
Rob R. Ainscough
Sorry to hear about the job cuts and Oracle now out sourcing to India.
Rob.
Rob.
Or, Larry needs a new mega-yachtKevin Spencer said:Always sorry to hear that some company has voted for "the cheapest
possible tech help," regardless of what country the help lives in. Anyone
that can do the job as well as someone in this country with a given salary
will almost always command the given salary. And cheap tech help is only
cheap in the short run. It is very expensive in the long run.
Sounds like Oracle is circling the drain.
--
HTH,
Kevin Spencer
Microsoft MVP
.Net Developer
We got a sick zebra a hat,
you ultimate tuna.
Rob said:Sorry to hear about the job cuts and Oracle now out sourcing to India.
Rob.
They are late, it was the start of the success from Baan.Rob R. Ainscough said:Sorry to hear about the job cuts and Oracle now out sourcing to India.
code be written by a team of software engineers in country A if you can
get it done by a team of software engineers in country B for half the
price.
Kevin said:Again, that may be true for labor, but for technicians, well, let me
put it this way: If I lived in India, and I could make twice as much
money with my skill level in the U.S., I would come to the U.S. and
get a job here.
If I lived in India, and I could make twice as much
money with my skill level in India, I would stay in India, and make
that amount of money. In other words, it is almost always skill level
that determines the amount of money that a technician (such as a
developer) makes, not country of origin. Therefore, any company that
outsources to another country to find cheaper technical help is going
to get poorer quality technical help.
That will save money in the
short run, but cost more money in the long run due to buggy software,
poorly-designed software, maintenance time, support time, etc. The
biggest cost factor in the software business is not development; it's
support.
I wear Rockport shoes. They cost twice as much as other shoes, but
last 4 times as long. Do the math.
I buy Lithium batteries. They cost twice as much as Alkaline
batteries, but last 7 times as long. Do the math.
There is no such thing as a free lunch. You get what you pay for.
no, that's a myth. Lots of people from India went to the US years ago,
but go back now. In the 'west', people often think that only in the
'west' universities deliver proper technicians. Not so. Remember, in
India there live near 1 billion people, and they have a lot of
universities, which every year deliver highly trained people. You
really think these people are educated beyond 'community college' level
? If you do, think again.
only if your assumption that everyone with proper skills leaves the
country to the US. Which isn't the case anymore.
Well, I own an ISV and I think you're wrong. I don't outsource to
india, but I can tell you that money spend on development of our
product is way higher than we spend on support personell, and we don't
sacrifice on support at all (ask around, we deliver top notch quality).
Now, we here in the 'west' can pretend these people are just not on
'our' level of education and can only do what we think is work for the
uneducated, but I can assure you, unless we work together with these
raising economies, we here in the west will play second fiddle.
Be aware, I don't say they're all good, but that also applies to a LOT
of the software engineers here in the west. We have customers in over
50 countries and therefore receive support calls from those countries
as well, and I can't see a pattern of which you can conclude the people
in the 'west' are higher skilled than the people 'outside the west'.
That has nothing to do with software engineers. You forget that once
you've designed a piece of software (part of a software program for
example), the most time is spend on typing it in!
I wasn't talking about the free lunch, I was talking about the large
part of the labour which is simply boring and repetitive work, and
which can also be done by evenly skilled people elsewhere for a lower
price tag.
Welcome to the world economy. Embrace it or fade away.....
Kevin Spencer said:Yes, the cost of living is different around the world. But again, if I
could compete with the talent and make twice the money I do working in the
UK, I'd move there. Otherwise, I'd find a job here where I could make that
kind of money. It's pretty simple economics.
Yes, there are plenty of poor programmers right here in the USA. And there
are companies that hire them, looking for a bargain. And those companies
usually fail.
Neither a follower nor a lender be. Think for yourself. Just because
something is popular doesn't make it a good idea. Don't forget how popular
Adolf Hitler was before 1939...
Yes, there is a world economy. And it's the same all over. Economics is
not that complicated. It's all about math, it's all about supply and
demand, and it's all about competition. You either compete, or you get the
s**t kicked out of you. You compete, not by being cheaper than the next
guy, but by being wiser than the next guy. Take a look at General Motors,
here in the U.S. They slept while Japan competed. Now, they're going
under. Fortunately, Japanese car companies have plenty of factories here
to handle the people who have been laid off by GM. If you follow the
crowd, be sure they're not a bunch of Lemmings.
Neither a follower nor a lender be. Think for yourself. Just because
something is popular doesn't make it a good idea. Don't forget how popular
Adolf Hitler was before 1939...
Cor said:Frans,
Although I agree almost complete what you write, is there an other
aspect. What I will show with a real Dutch product. (Not that it is
for our market a important product however for ourselves it is very
much Dutch.) The bicycle.
You forgot to mention one of the most important countries in computer
hardware Taiwan.
One of their starting products was as far as I know bicycles.
Americans and Dutch have sent their bicycles to copy them and produce
them in Taiwan. Now they are making much better bicycles as those
they got to copy and are one of the leaders in the inventions around
the bicycle.
The counterpart is that it forced at least the Dutch to make as well
better bicycles. Ko Gaastra, from the neighbourhood where you are
born. was one of those who succeeded in that. Most Dutch were at the
start thinking that KoGa Miyatea was from Japan, however that was
just a marketing thing, it is/was made by hand in Friesland. I assume
that you know the quality of that product and the ones which are look
alikes now from that in Holland (sorry Friesland).
True For years I thought they were made in Japan. But I think that
focussing on hand-made quality products isn't the point. The point is
that the bulk work, the work the majority of the people will
participate in, that work is doable everywhere, you just have to
instruct the workers well enough. Also in our business.
I think you miss my point about cost of living. For example, I can have a
job in Texas that pays $50,000 a year or I can have a job in New York that
pays $100,000 a year. Which is the better paying job? To answer the
question, you have to look at cost of living. Say that cost of living is
2.5 times that in New York compared to Texas. So, my $50,000 in Texas is
equivalent to $125,000 in New York. So, Texas actually looks like a
better paying job. Granted, there are other factors, but overall, economy
of scale as associated with cost of living is still important to consider.
I'm not disagreeing with you. I'm only saying that we cannot be ignorant
of how one country fits into the world economy as compared to another. If
it's cheaper to build it Japan, then so be it. The US manufacturers will
either adapt or fail. That's my point, which doesn't seem to be too far
from your own.
By the way, that's neither a BORROWER nor a lender be.
show that what you tell is right.
Europe. The total delivery cost will probably be much lower to produce it
their, while the Americans and Europeans have people enough to control
those robots in the same way as when it was done in Japan.