G
Gary
Why not just buy two Seasonics for the same price or less? Very good
quality, and they use the same Teapo brand capacitors found in most
PCP&Cs.
I tried them and had two fail.
Why not just buy two Seasonics for the same price or less? Very good
quality, and they use the same Teapo brand capacitors found in most
PCP&Cs.
I had one in 2005, it was definitely not overloaded. The firstJim said:I have had THREE (3) Antec power supplies fail in the last 9 months.
The first failure was August 2006, and was a PS that came with an
Antec Sonata case originally purchased in 2005 (I believe it was
a 400W PS). I replaced it with an Antec SP-450.
In November 06 I bought a second case, an Antec Sonata-II for a new
system. This system came with an SP-450, and the power supply
failed in February 07. I couldn't find the receipt so Antec
wouldn't replace it under warranty. I replaced it with a different
brand PS.
Then last week the replacement SP-450 that I purchased in August 06
started failing randomly. It would power up but within 5-10 minutes
the system would stop responding and lose monitor signal (but not
hard disk power). Replacing the PS with a Thermaltake 430W cured
that problem.
I do have the receipt for the replacement SP-450 I bought in August
06 so I'm going to try to get Antec to replace it. We'll see what
happens.
I've had one or more PCs since 1987, and in the 19 years prior to
August 2006 have seen exactly ONE power supply go bad (it was a
spectacular *BANG* and puff of smoke Three bad Antec power
supplies seem to indicate a trend.
Anybody else having problems with Antec?
Bob said:Jim said:I have had THREE (3) Antec power supplies fail in the last 9 months. [snip]
Anybody else having problems with Antec?
Were they plugged into a battery back up or UPS? I have an Antec 550W
True Control PSU that is going on 4 years now with no problems. But I've
always had mine plugged in to a good UPS.
Jim said:I have had THREE (3) Antec power supplies fail in the last 9 months.
The first failure was August 2006, and was a PS that came with an
Antec Sonata case originally purchased in 2005 (I believe it was
a 400W PS). I replaced it with an Antec SP-450.
In November 06 I bought a second case, an Antec Sonata-II for a new
system. This system came with an SP-450, and the power supply
failed in February 07. I couldn't find the receipt so Antec
wouldn't replace it under warranty. I replaced it with a different
brand PS.
Then last week the replacement SP-450 that I purchased in August 06
started failing randomly. It would power up but within 5-10 minutes
the system would stop responding and lose monitor signal (but not
hard disk power). Replacing the PS with a Thermaltake 430W cured
that problem.
I do have the receipt for the replacement SP-450 I bought in August
06 so I'm going to try to get Antec to replace it. We'll see what
happens.
I've had one or more PCs since 1987, and in the 19 years prior to
August 2006 have seen exactly ONE power supply go bad (it was a
spectacular *BANG* and puff of smoke Three bad Antec power
supplies seem to indicate a trend.
Anybody else having problems with Antec?
It ain't just Antec. ;-{Yes, I've had problems. I built 4 SLI gaming systems about a year
ago, and in that time I've had 2 of the Antec SP 500 SLI power
supplies go bad. It's to the point now that I keep an extra power
supply on hand to keep the network up.
Antec or not, keeping an extra known-good PSU around, just makes sense.Maybe I've just had bad luck, or maybe Antec's contracted out to the
wrong people, but as it is, a year ago I would have recommended Antec
to anyone. Now I wouldn't.
Going back several years I had string of power supply failures as well.Jim said:I have had THREE (3) Antec power supplies fail in the last 9 months.
The first failure was August 2006, and was a PS that came with an
Antec Sonata case originally purchased in 2005 (I believe it was a
400W PS). I replaced it with an Antec SP-450.
In November 06 I bought a second case, an Antec Sonata-II for a new
system. This system came with an SP-450, and the power supply failed
in February 07. I couldn't find the receipt so Antec wouldn't
replace it under warranty. I replaced it with a different brand PS.
Then last week the replacement SP-450 that I purchased in August 06
started failing randomly. It would power up but within 5-10 minutes
the system would stop responding and lose monitor signal (but not
hard disk power). Replacing the PS with a Thermaltake 430W cured
that problem.
I do have the receipt for the replacement SP-450 I bought in August
06 so I'm going to try to get Antec to replace it. We'll see what
happens.
I've had one or more PCs since 1987, and in the 19 years prior to
August 2006 have seen exactly ONE power supply go bad (it was a
spectacular *BANG* and puff of smoke Three bad Antec power
supplies seem to indicate a trend.
Anybody else having problems with Antec?
Were they plugged into a battery back up or UPS? I have an Antec 550W
True Control PSU that is going on 4 years now with no problems. But I've
always had mine plugged in to a good UPS.
Bob
Going back several years I had string of power supply failures as well.
Turns out it wasn't their fault entirely. A key culprit was a
defective main panel box (aka: circuit breaker box)
If the power doesn't get by that cleanly the power supply has a much
harder job to do
Antec would like to apologize for any trouble or inconvenience caused by
the recent increase in problems with our SmartPower 2.0 power supplies.
The problems were primarily caused by the transition at one factory to
RoHS manufacturing and compliant components and one component in
particular, a capacitor on the +5V standby line. There were two
primary failure modes due to this: the first being lower than normal
output voltages on the +5V SB line,
AntecRep said:Antec would like to apologize for any trouble or inconvenience
caused by the recent increase in problems with our SmartPower 2.0
power supplies. The problems were primarily caused by the
transition at one factory to RoHS manufacturing and compliant
components and one component in particular, a capacitor on the +5V
standby line. There were two primary failure modes due to this:
the first being lower than normal output voltages on the +5V SB
line, making a good power supply appear to be DOA due to boot
failure; or the second being a failure of the same capacitor
after some time in service, resulting in power supply failure.
Antec has taken the most stringent possible actions to remove any
suspect power supplies from our supply chain. We have corrected
the problem at the factory and instituted the highest possible
level of testing and quality control.
If you have any problems with previously purchased products,
remember you have a three year warranty on all SmartPower 2.0
products. You can contact Antec Customer Support at
customersupport antec.com or at europe.techsupport antec.com and
you will be provided with immediate hassle-free service to resolve
your problems.
We appreciate your support and faith in Antec and our products.
Again, we apologize for any disappointment we may have caused.