6800GT vs. X800Pro...with an eye to the future

  • Thread starter Thread starter dookie
  • Start date Start date
JB said:
So, since the pro's don't have the video in, and the mod works
only on cards with video in, the mod doesn't work on pro's which is
exactly what I proved with my experiment. Thanks for clearing that up.

Jeff B
Click to expand...

There are pros with vivo
 
The V5's FSAA methods were employed in the GF3 and higher cards.
Click to expand...

Really? I had a GF3 and GF4200 and the FSAA on both was poor compared to
the V5. I did side by side visual comparisons with 2 PCs and the V5's x4
mode really was much better. Slow, but better.

The 9700Pro was a big improvement on Nvidia (to my eyes anyway), though
even with the x800 I'm disappointed that there's *still* no option to do
proper FSAA... some elements of the drawn picture still don't get AA'd.
That's a big flaw in the whole DX/FSAA thing at the moment.
Did the P4's vastly superior Quake III engine scores play a part
in your decision?
Click to expand...

I know nothing about Q4 apart from the fact it's in the pipeline.

Andrew McP
 
I was talking about Q3. The P4 is faster than the AXP in Q3, and in all
Q3-engined games, yet it didn't prevent a lot of gamers from buying AMD
parts. The point is, Doom III is just a single game, and in the words of
John Carmack, "innocuous code changes can 'fall off the fast path' and cause
significant performance impacts, especially on NV30 class cards." It's not
wise to go for a 6800GT over the X800Pro just based on D3 scores, because
it's easy to turn the tables when it comes to other games in the future.
 
Andrew MacPherson said:
Really? I had a GF3 and GF4200 and the FSAA on both was poor compared to
the V5. I did side by side visual comparisons with 2 PCs and the V5's x4
mode really was much better. Slow, but better.
Click to expand...

Have you compared the 2xFSAA modes? Like I said in a previous post, the
GF3's 2x mode uses a rotated-grid, just like the V5. The GF3's 4x mode uses
ordered grid, while the V5 uses rotated-grid on 4x. Rotated-grid looks
better for lines at most angles.

Then there's the additional Quincunx mode which is blurry as hell.
 
So what are you saying, Doom3 etc. is about to suddenly run great on ATI
hardware? So the benchmarks run by ID software mean nothing??
LOL! If ATI knew how to fix the problem, they would have done so
long ago. To think otherwise is to set yourself up for a big
dissappointment.
Click to expand...

I am a proud owner of the 9800Pro.... but OpenGL has always been the
weakness of the ATI line... which is not a problem when Quake3 is
running 200+ fps... They had access to Doom3 for months...

What I've seen sofar from BETA enhancements is about 5~8fps faster...
which is still NOTHING when the 6800GT is 65fps and the X800Pro is
40fps!! (Important note: unless your CPU is an AMD64 or P4-EE - none
of this MATTERS as your CPU is the bottleneck to the GPU)

Its a problem when the $300 6800 is up there with the $500 ATI XT
version!!

I hope ATI does better on the next round... more competition!



- - - - -
Remember: In the USA - it is dangeroud to draw or write about Heir Bush in a negative way. The police or SS are called, people threaten to kill you. (What country is this again?)

- Fahrenheit 9/11 - Unless you see it for yourself, don't call it "a bunch of lies"... that would be unAmerican.
- White House blows cover of an undercover agent because her husband said there were no WMD (before the USA started the war) - her job was finding terrorist.
God bless the land of the free. Where you can burn the Constitution... Ashcroft does it every day.
 
Its a problem when the $300 6800 is up there with the $500 ATI XT
version!!
Click to expand...

In OpenGL, try taking a more overall view of the games market with the
vast bulk of games being D3D and things look a lot better for ATI
owners.
 
Darthy said:
I am a proud owner of the 9800Pro.... but OpenGL has always been the
weakness of the ATI line... which is not a problem when Quake3 is
running 200+ fps... They had access to Doom3 for months...

What I've seen sofar from BETA enhancements is about 5~8fps faster...
which is still NOTHING when the 6800GT is 65fps and the X800Pro is
40fps!! (Important note: unless your CPU is an AMD64 or P4-EE - none
of this MATTERS as your CPU is the bottleneck to the GPU)

Its a problem when the $300 6800 is up there with the $500 ATI XT
version!!

I hope ATI does better on the next round... more competition!
Click to expand...


I guess it's a good thing for ATI that Doom 3 sucks!

That, and the fact that 98% of the PC games on the market use D3D instead of
OpenGL...
 
In OpenGL, try taking a more overall view of the games market with the
vast bulk of games being D3D and things look a lot better for ATI
owners.
Click to expand...

While most games are D3D, a good amount of them will continue to use
OPenGL - since afterall many games will be using the Quake3 & Doom3
engines.



- - - - -
Remember: In the USA - it is dangeroud to draw or write about Heir Bush in a negative way. The police or SS are called, people threaten to kill you. (What country is this again?)

- Fahrenheit 9/11 - Unless you see it for yourself, don't call it "a bunch of lies"... that would be unAmerican.
- White House blows cover of an undercover agent because her husband said there were no WMD (before the USA started the war) - her job was finding terrorist.
God bless the land of the free. Where you can burn the Constitution... Ashcroft does it every day.
 
I guess it's a good thing for ATI that Doom 3 sucks!

That, and the fact that 98% of the PC games on the market use D3D instead of
OpenGL...
Click to expand...


Theres a lot more OpenGL than you think...

Castle Wolfenstien
Battlefield 1942
Quake3
Doom3
Metal of Honor
Star Wars Jedi series...
and more...

With the new HalfLife2 engine, Nvidia & ATI are neck and neck...


- - - - -
Remember: In the USA - it is dangeroud to draw or write about Heir Bush in a negative way. The police or SS are called, people threaten to kill you. (What country is this again?)

- Fahrenheit 9/11 - Unless you see it for yourself, don't call it "a bunch of lies"... that would be unAmerican.
- White House blows cover of an undercover agent because her husband said there were no WMD (before the USA started the war) - her job was finding terrorist.
God bless the land of the free. Where you can burn the Constitution... Ashcroft does it every day.
 
Theres a lot more OpenGL than you think...

Castle Wolfenstien
Battlefield 1942
Quake3
Doom3
Metal of Honor
Star Wars Jedi series...
and more...
Click to expand...

BF1942 is D3D.
With the new HalfLife2 engine, Nvidia & ATI are neck and neck...
Click to expand...

Hardly, there are far more D3D games.
 
While most games are D3D, a good amount of them will continue to use
OPenGL - since afterall many games will be using the Quake3 & Doom3
engines.
Click to expand...

Doom 3 isn't a general purpose engine, if licensed, it will have very
limited appeal compared to the HL2 engine.
 
I think he was referring to d3d performance with the hl2 engine, and they
are close.
Not that I'm an nvidia fan, but facts are facts.
Mike
 
Back
Top