Fwedfwelldown said:
Thanks for nothing. Typical response from so called "support."
I apologise on behalf of my colleague; I think he was a bit hard-arsed on
this score.
Be aware that 99.9% of folks answering questions here are just guys hanging
out in their spare time. None of us work for Microsoft and - apart from the
MVPs - most of us have no association with Microsoft at all. We're just
fellow users. So the level of support here won't be what you should expect
from paid calls to Microsoft PSS.
As I clearly explained and indicated, the issue is happening in more than
one
app, the only thing the two programs have in common is that they are text
editing and running under Vista...one made by Microsoft and one made by
Sun
Microsystems. I run both under Windows XP and don't have this problem, so
it's clear the only difference is Vista.
Now, I dunno exactly what is causing this problem. But I believe that both
Office XP and OpenOffice use the COMCTL32.DLL to present the File, Open
dialogue. This file is shipped with Windows, as a convenience to
applications; but it isn't really a core part of the Windows operating
system itself. Many applications (such as Office) also ship with a copy of
this DLL and will install it when they get installed. Unfortunately this
leads to a whole class of problems, when you get multiple copies of the file
installed and an application picks up the "wrong" version. This is an aspect
of the so-called "DLL Hell" problem, particularly acute here because it is
such a widely used DLL. An illustrative example on XP is
http://support.microsoft.com/kb/829502.
So in terms of investigating your problem I'd suggest you start looking to
see what COMCTL32.DLL files you have installed and if there's anything
strange about them (eg you have a file in System32 dated 2001 instead of
2006, etc.)
If you just want a remedial step, without detailed forensics ... what I'd do
in this situation is totally uninstall Office XP and OpenOffice, reboot, and
then re-install them one by one. Re-install Office XP first (just because it
is officially supported on Vista; see
http://support.microsoft.com/kb/932087) and see if the problem still occurs.
(I expect everything will work fine). After you're satisfied it's working
okay again, take a snapshot backup of your system. Then, install OpenOffice
again as well. First, verify that Office XP is still opening files okay,
same as before. If it is, now run OpenOffice and try to open a file. If
everything works okay - well and good, whatever the glitch was has gone. If
OpenOffice starts to play up ... well, it seems like there's something
blocking them all running together on that machine. You'll want to check the
Event Logs to see if there is any information about what EXE or DLL files
are actually involved, when Word or Write "crash" - most likely there is an
access violation in a shared library. Since many Windows applications share
libraries, there can be co-existence problems.
But Office XP on its own, should definitely run okay on Vista.
Notwithstanding that Vista may have some role to play in the problem, you're
more likely to get good responses in a group like
microsoft.public.office.misc. There just won't be many people here in the
Vista group who have a similar scenario of Office Xp and OpenOffice (most
folks are running Office 2003 or 2007 on Vista).
Good luck, hope this helps a bit.
Andrew