will ATA100 automatically switch to ATA33?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bill
  • Start date Start date
B

bill

I have an old (reliable) celeron 400, 98SE, with ATA33 disk.
Since disks are getting so cheap, I thought it might be a good
idea to purchase a 160GB disk (ATA100). And, I believe that
all the ATA100 disks are backward compatable with ATA33.
It is not clear if the disk will properly switch from ATA100
to ATA33 automatically. I kinda got that idea because seagate
has a tool utility that will toggle disks from ATA100 to ATA33:
http://www.seagate.com/support/kb/disc/ultra_ata100.html
So, my concern is that if I cannot write to the disk, I would
not be able to use that toggle utility, catch22.
I have 40 conductor cable, which is supposed to be used only
up to and including ATA33. Maybe the disk will detect that, and
automatically set its speed to ATA33, regardless?

Are seagate or western digital good brands?

regards,
bill
 
bill escribió:
I have an old (reliable) celeron 400, 98SE, with ATA33 disk.
Since disks are getting so cheap, I thought it might be a good
idea to purchase a 160GB disk (ATA100). And, I believe that
all the ATA100 disks are backward compatable with ATA33.
It is not clear if the disk will properly switch from ATA100
to ATA33 automatically. I kinda got that idea because seagate
has a tool utility that will toggle disks from ATA100 to ATA33:
http://www.seagate.com/support/kb/disc/ultra_ata100.html
So, my concern is that if I cannot write to the disk, I would
not be able to use that toggle utility, catch22.
I have 40 conductor cable, which is supposed to be used only
up to and including ATA33. Maybe the disk will detect that, and
automatically set its speed to ATA33, regardless?

Are seagate or western digital good brands?

regards,
bill
Click to expand...
i dont think it will work on your motherboard
 
bill said:
I have an old (reliable) celeron 400, 98SE, with ATA33 disk.
Since disks are getting so cheap, I thought it might be a good
idea to purchase a 160GB disk (ATA100). And, I believe that
all the ATA100 disks are backward compatable with ATA33.
It is not clear if the disk will properly switch from ATA100
to ATA33 automatically. I kinda got that idea because seagate
has a tool utility that will toggle disks from ATA100 to ATA33:
http://www.seagate.com/support/kb/disc/ultra_ata100.html
So, my concern is that if I cannot write to the disk, I would
not be able to use that toggle utility, catch22.
I have 40 conductor cable, which is supposed to be used only
up to and including ATA33. Maybe the disk will detect that, and
automatically set its speed to ATA33, regardless?

Are seagate or western digital good brands?

regards,
bill
Click to expand...
The problem will be that your old motherboard wont support a drive that
large and nor will windows 98 (natively). Certainly an ATA 133 drive will be
backwards compatible to ATA 33 speeds (should be automatic with a 40 wire
cable). You're best bet is to investigate what the largest size drive is
that the motherboard supports (probably either 137 GB limit - i.e. buy a 120
GB drive or 32 GB limit - i.e. buy a 30 GB drive if you can find one) and
get a drive of that size. You can do this by finding the make and model
written on the motherboard and going to the manufacturers website. There may
be a BIOS upgrade for your motherboard to allow larger sized hard drives to
be used. If you're unsure about how to do the "flash" upgrade though, I
suggest you get someone in the know to perform this because a mistake can
trash your motherboard (depending on the make/model). Seagate have just
increased their warranty period to 5 years and Samsung have a very
respectable 3 year warranty (both are very quiet drives - speed won't be a
limiting factor so 5400 RPM drives would be sufficiently fast - and likely
cheaper than other models if you can find any still).

Paul
 
I have an old (reliable) celeron 400, 98SE, with ATA33 disk.
Since disks are getting so cheap, I thought it might be a good
idea to purchase a 160GB disk (ATA100). And, I believe that
all the ATA100 disks are backward compatable with ATA33.
It is not clear if the disk will properly switch from ATA100
to ATA33 automatically. I kinda got that idea because seagate
has a tool utility that will toggle disks from ATA100 to ATA33:
http://www.seagate.com/support/kb/disc/ultra_ata100.html
So, my concern is that if I cannot write to the disk, I would
not be able to use that toggle utility, catch22.
I have 40 conductor cable, which is supposed to be used only
up to and including ATA33. Maybe the disk will detect that, and
automatically set its speed to ATA33, regardless?

Are seagate or western digital good brands?

regards,
bill
Click to expand...

Given the limitation Paul Murphy mentioned, that your board can't
support a 160GB drive even after a bios update (at most a bios
update for a board that age will generally support up to 128GB),
and that running ATA33 mode on a modern ATA100 or ATA133 drive
will be a significant performance hit (though it should work
fine), best option is to buy a PCI IDE (ata100 or ata133)
controller card.

Here's one cheap,
http://www.shopampm.com/product_info.php?cPath=56_215_253&products_id=253
 
kony said:
Given the limitation Paul Murphy mentioned, that your board can't
support a 160GB drive even after a bios update (at most a bios
update for a board that age will generally support up to 128GB),
and that running ATA33 mode on a modern ATA100 or ATA133 drive
will be a significant performance hit (though it should work
fine), best option is to buy a PCI IDE (ata100 or ata133)
controller card.

Here's one cheap,
http://www.shopampm.com/product_info.php?cPath=56_215_253&products_id=253
Click to expand...
Although that would get around the 137 GB (128 GB Windows formatted size)
limitation (assuming that's what
the mobo is limited to), it won't get around the Windows 98 problems
associated with drives larger than what 28 bit LBA can handle. For more info
this is an excellent site to reference these issues - here's the Windows 98
related page: http://www.48bitlba.com/win98.htm
The OP would be well advised to read up on this!

Paul
 
The motherboard's BIOS on your older computer undoubtedly CANNOT recognize a
harddrive a newer harddrive as large as 160 GB.
 
DaveW said:
.... snip ...

The motherboard's BIOS on your older computer undoubtedly CANNOT
recognize a harddrive a newer harddrive as large as 160 GB.
Click to expand...

There are available ISA and PCI cards (very small) that contain
only a replacement disk driver rom, which the boot process
installs. They go for 40 or 50 dollars. This avoids disturbing
the existing bios, but provides the function. I have one in a 486
system, but forget where I got it. I can choose what drives to
enable it on. Without that I am limited to under 8G drives.
 
Although that would get around the 137 GB (128 GB Windows formatted size)
limitation (assuming that's what
the mobo is limited to), it won't get around the Windows 98 problems
associated with drives larger than what 28 bit LBA can handle. For more info
this is an excellent site to reference these issues - here's the Windows 98
related page: http://www.48bitlba.com/win98.htm
The OP would be well advised to read up on this!

Paul
Click to expand...


One thing the 'site seems to overlook (at least on that page,
didn't reread whole 'site, is that the newer FDISK MS offers for
Win98 that supports over 64GB can be used to partition a drive,
but size needs be specified as a percentage.
 
If the disk will not automatically work with ATA33 it will run in PIO mode. You can then run the utility to make ATA33 work. As other posters have said, your big problem will be getting your system to recognize a large hard drive.
I have an old (reliable) celeron 400, 98SE, with ATA33 disk.
Since disks are getting so cheap, I thought it might be a good
idea to purchase a 160GB disk (ATA100). And, I believe that
all the ATA100 disks are backward compatable with ATA33.
It is not clear if the disk will properly switch from ATA100
to ATA33 automatically. I kinda got that idea because seagate
has a tool utility that will toggle disks from ATA100 to ATA33:
http://www.seagate.com/support/kb/disc/ultra_ata100.html
So, my concern is that if I cannot write to the disk, I would
not be able to use that toggle utility, catch22.
I have 40 conductor cable, which is supposed to be used only
up to and including ATA33. Maybe the disk will detect that, and
automatically set its speed to ATA33, regardless?

Are seagate or western digital good brands?

regards,
bill
Click to expand...

--

When replying by Email include NewSGrouP (case sensitive) in Subject

Mike Walsh
West Palm Beach, Florida, U.S.A.
 
One thing the 'site seems to overlook (at least on that page,
didn't reread whole 'site, is that the newer FDISK MS offers for
Win98 that supports over 64GB can be used to partition a drive,
but size needs be specified as a percentage.
Click to expand...

Although the FDISK fix may not have been referred to directly on that page,
it is referred to somewhere on the site - that's how I found out about it.
Its only a cosmetic fix anyway though because if a user wants to partition a
drive to full capacity the "old" version will still do it (automatically),
it just doesn't display the correct value at the time of use. The more
pressing issue is that with drives over ~130 GB the scandisk and defrag disk
utilities built into windows wont work and the OS simply isn't designed for
such a large drive. 120 GB on the other hand, will be acceptable to the OS,
as long as that size is acceptable to the motherboards BIOS - if not a
complete system upgrade would probably be the most cost effective solution
rather than trying to make a silk purse out of what may be considered to be
a sows ear. Feedback on the exact system specs is needed from the OP before
progress can occur.

Paul
 
Here's one cheap,
http://www.shopampm.com/product_info.php?cPath=56_215_253&products_id=253
Click to expand...
The price may be cheap but make sure you call them up or send them
email to see if they respond to you. I ordered product from them. They
shipped the wrong item to me. I kept calling them but no one answer
the phone. Send them email but no one reply. Well, they do have
automated email reply with disconnected number:

=============
THIS MESSAGE IS AN AUTOMATED REPLY, PLEASE DO NOT RESPOND TO THIS
E-MAIL. THANK YOU



You are our most valued customer. Our policy at SHOPAMPM.COM is to
ensure you are satisfied with your purchase. We do our utmost to
ensure safe delivery of your order. For any reason if you are not
satisfied with your purchase, just give us a call and we will do our
best to assist with all your questions and concern.



At SHOPAMPM.COM we offer all customers FREE SHIPPING on all orders
plus 2-3 day priority air on selected item.



All orders will be shipped out within 24 hours (except Saturday and
Sunday). Please ready the following chart:



Orders place before 3:00 pacific time
Same day shipping

Orders place after 3:00 pacific time
Ship on the next following day (within 24 hours)

Orders place on weekends (Sat & Sun)
Ship on the next following Monday




FAQ:



Credit Card Submit problem: if you are having trouble submit your
credit card information or you have experience decline error message
after submit information, please resubmit credit card and billing
information again. Your credit card information should match billing
information.



RMA: Please contact 909 368 3268 and ask to be transfer to RMA
department. Please have your order number ready.



Ship to location: USA ONLY, APO, FPO, Canada, AL, GU, MP and Puerto
Rico are not acceptable



Thank you for giving us the opportunity to serve you. If we can be of
any further assistance, you're welcome to contact us again at any
time. Our contact phone number is 909 368 3268



Sincerely,



Shopampm.com

=================

My only course I have now is going through credit card company.
 
Back
Top