Michael C said:
What I'm interested to know is why do some usb devices have them while
others survive quite well without.
The tendency of an electronic device to radiate unwanted
radio-frequency energy depends on a number of things, including the
frequency of the internal clock circuitry, the power consumption, the
PC board layout, the type of case (metal or plastic) and case
shielding, the presence or absence of internal RF-blocking components
(e.g. small ferrite beads or bypass capacitors), and probably at least
a dozen other factors.
Here in the US, the FCC sets limits for how much energy an incidental
radiator (e.g. a computer or component thereof) is allowed to emit.
In principle, each USB device design is supposed to be tested in a
third-party lab, and "certificated" (i.e. shown via testing) to comply
with the limits.
So... some USB devices might not need any extra RF blocking on their
cables, because their design is inherently a low-speed, low-RF-
emitting one. Or, they might not need it becauset the manufacturer
put the necessary RF blocking/shielding into the USB device design
itself (e.g. a metal case, ferrite beads on the PC board wiring, use
of a spread-spectrum oscillator to reduce individual emission spurs,
etc.). Or, the manufacturer might be cheating... i.e. certificated
one version of the device (with a ferrite-bead cable) and then
switched to a less expensive cable design for actual production and
sale.
If you're curious, take a look at the bottom/back of your USB device,
and find the FCC Part 15 information. You can plug this information
into the form at
https://gullfoss2.fcc.gov/prod/oet/cf/eas/reports/GenericSearch.cfm
and access the reports which were filed when the device was
certificated.
If you've got a USB device which has no Part 15 certification label,
it may be an untested/unauthorized device, and thus potentially
illegal to sell here in the U.S.