Single-sided DIMMs

  • Thread starter Thread starter DIMMs
  • Start date Start date
D

DIMMs

Are these readily available, because so far I've only been able to find
double-sided DIMMs.
From the dual channel perspective, single-sided DIMMs seem to be the way to
go, yet they appear scarce.

Comments?
 
In comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.misc DIMMs said:
Are these readily available, because so far I've only been able to find
double-sided DIMMs.
From the dual channel perspective, single-sided DIMMs seem to be the way to
go, yet they appear scarce.
Click to expand...

Whatever gave you that idea? Historically that may have been the
case at one time or another but today?

Arno
 
Are these readily available, because so far I've only been able to find
double-sided DIMMs.
From the dual channel perspective, single-sided DIMMs seem to be the way to
go, yet they appear scarce.

Comments?
Click to expand...

It was more important to get single sided with earlier AMD64 CPUs,
especially s939 and if you wanted to get 1T command rate. With more recent
CPUs, AFAIK, the memory controller has been improved and according to
tables in the docs, it's more tolerant of multiple ranks at full speed.

It may still be a better strategy to start with single sided if the
intention is to increase mamory capacity later... and they you can find
them: here's a Crucial part
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820146541 which is
said to be .8T (that is the clue for Crucial DIMMs with Micron parts) but
the pic shows the suffix as .M8FD which I believe is with Samsung parts -
funny thing is that the 2nd pic shows .16FG so who knows?? The .8Ts I got
from NewEgg a while back were indeed .8Ts and work flawlessly at
3-3-3-8(1T). The "scoop" on Web Forums is that the Samsung parts Crucial
is using are not as good as the Micron ones and may only run at 2T.<shrug>
 
Ref DIMMs. Does anybody know if "SIMMS" are still available
somewhere??? I have a device for my Commodore128 called Ram/Link
which uses non parity simms (4 megs storage per simm) and it has
2 of them so totals out to 8 megs of storage.
Joe


**********************************************************
* Ham KH6JF AARS/MARS ABM6JF QCWA WW2 VET WD RADIO SYSTEM*
* Army MARS PRECEDED by AARS (Army Amateur Radio System) *
* Hi State ARMY MARS COORDINATOR *
**********************************************************
 
In comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.misc Joseph Fenn said:
Ref DIMMs. Does anybody know if "SIMMS" are still available
somewhere??? I have a device for my Commodore128 called Ram/Link
which uses non parity simms (4 megs storage per simm) and it has
2 of them so totals out to 8 megs of storage.
Joe
Click to expand...

Try Kingston. Expect to pay a lot.

Arno
 
George Macdonald said:
It was more important to get single sided with earlier AMD64 CPUs,
especially s939 and if you wanted to get 1T command rate. With more
recent
CPUs, AFAIK, the memory controller has been improved and according to
tables in the docs, it's more tolerant of multiple ranks at full speed.

It may still be a better strategy to start with single sided if the
intention is to increase mamory capacity later... and they you can find
them: here's a Crucial part
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820146541 which is
said to be .8T (that is the clue for Crucial DIMMs with Micron parts) but
the pic shows the suffix as .M8FD which I believe is with Samsung parts -
funny thing is that the 2nd pic shows .16FG so who knows?? The .8Ts I got
from NewEgg a while back were indeed .8Ts and work flawlessly at
3-3-3-8(1T). The "scoop" on Web Forums is that the Samsung parts Crucial
is using are not as good as the Micron ones and may only run at 2T.<shrug>
Click to expand...

Well I called the mobo representative in my country and he said my processor
indeed has a limitation of working well with only 4 banks of memory, so that
means I'll have to replace one of my two double-sided 512mb DIMMs with a 1gb
double-sided DIMM to upgrade from 1gb ram to 1.5gb. Typically, the manual
doesn't mention the limitation. Also, single-sided DIMMs cost a lot more
than double-sided ones so I figure might as well go for the 1gb double-sided
DIMM.
 
Well I called the mobo representative in my country and he said my processor
indeed has a limitation of working well with only 4 banks of memory, so that
means I'll have to replace one of my two double-sided 512mb DIMMs with a 1gb
double-sided DIMM to upgrade from 1gb ram to 1.5gb. Typically, the manual
doesn't mention the limitation. Also, single-sided DIMMs cost a lot more
than double-sided ones so I figure might as well go for the 1gb double-sided
DIMM.
Click to expand...

Was a that a mfr rep.? If you told us what processor and core version you
have and current config/speed, you might get a better answer here than from
a vendor.

First, if you have a dual channel setup with 2x512MB, one on each channel,
and you replace one of them with a 1GB DIMM, you will lose dual channel
operation, a bigger performance penalty than a speed drop from DDR400 to
DDR333. In a dual channel setup, more recent versions of the CPU are
spec'd to take 3 ranks of memory per channel without dropping to DDR333.
Even older versions of the CPU have been known to take the 3 ranks without
dropping speed with good quality memory, though you'd likely have to drop
the command rate to 2T.

I don't see a significant price premium for single-sided with 512Mb chips
vs. double sided with 256Mb chips here in the U.S but either way, if you
mix different spec/brand parts on the same system things could get err,
"interesting".
 
Ref DIMMs. Does anybody know if "SIMMS" are still available
somewhere??? I
Ham KH6JF AARS/MARS ABM6JF QCWA WW2 VET WD RADIO SYSTEM*
Click to expand...

Joe ,
Shame on you ,a hamfest is always the answer.
I'm guessing these are 30 pin SIMMs and not 72 pin.
Also check if 3 chip are ok ,or if they have to be 8 chip.
Mark Whitlock
 
Joe ,
Shame on you ,a hamfest is always the answer.
Click to expand...

Good idea, where these things exist. I've trhown away *many* megabytes of
such antique crap. No one wanted it and it was in my face.
I'm guessing these are 30 pin SIMMs and not 72 pin.
Click to expand...

At this size, I think you're right. Crucial has 32MB SIMMs (for big bux),
but they're 72 pin.
Also check if 3 chip are ok ,or if they have to be 8 chip.
Click to expand...

Another good call! Likely the documentation to make this call no longer
exists.
 
Joe ,
Shame on you ,a hamfest is always the answer.
I'm guessing these are 30 pin SIMMs and not 72 pin.
Also check if 3 chip are ok ,or if they have to be 8 chip.
Mark Whitlock
Click to expand...

I only know that the 1st simm has four chips on it and equals 4mb of
storage. The other simm has 8 chips on it, and equals 1 mb of
storage. So both simms are parity since both have equal nr
of chips on board.
(also am not ashamed at all)

Dont go to any hamfests here in Hawaii as they are few and far
between. These simms are for a device called "ramlink" and
used to store up to 16 megs of instant up on Commodore 128
computers.
Unashamed Joe
 
I only know that the 1st simm has four chips on it and equals 4mb of
storage. The other simm has 8 chips on it, and equals 1 mb of
storage. So both simms are parity since both have equal nr
of chips on board.
Click to expand...

Both simms are 8 bits wide - ie: *non-parity* type...
 
Back
Top