On Tue, 03 Apr 2007 12:51:21 -0500, NickySantoro
Many thanks to all who responded. After evaluating all my
alternatives, I think my best option is to just bite the bullet and
reinstall XP on a new HD. The one I was going to use is a Maxtor but
since I've had a couple of those quit over the years, I am reluctant
to use it as a boot drive.
"Over the years"? There is no drive that won't fail if you
use it (Until it fails). Be very cautious about trusting
those who quickly point out every Maxtor failure as evidence
of a problem, but then don't take the same attitude about
any other drive make failing. Some of us have no horror
stores about Maxtor with quite a few drives working fine. j
Even so, it is also not a reason to try to push the brand,
when there are others at similar prices.
Is Seagate still the leader in reliability/durability? I know they
merged with Maxtor which bodes ill.
Not at all "ill", you can even buy current generation
"Maxtor" packaged drives that are Seagate made now... which
makes it a bit funny when some quickly bash Maxtor products
and suggest buying a Seagate, _today_.
Is there any Seagate that is
better than the others in terms of durability? All factors such as
speed, noise, etc are secondary to reliability. The 80 gig drives seem
ubiquitous and priced well, FWIW.
Any guidance in this area would be most appreciated.
The key is not to consider any of them particularly durable,
nor particularly fragile. Selection, implementation is not
changed by brand. If the data is important you want an
easily restorable backup. That is far more important than
which drive you select. If realtime data availability is
important too, use RAID (not raid 0 of course).
You could buy a Seagate tomorrow and have it fail in a
month's time. Odds are against it but there are no
guarantees against this, only that the drive will be
replaced under warranty. If there is one thing we can be
sure of, it is that if/when any past generation drive has
shown to be problematic enough that we can look back in
retrospect and make a fair claim it was bad, to be avoided,
the manufacturer has also noticed at that point and has made
corrections to the (then) contemporary replacement in their
product line.