Registry cleaning.

  • Thread starter Thread starter aitch
  • Start date Start date
A

aitch

A friend has recommended that I clean up my registry. He admits he is no
expert so I would appreciate other comments before I commit myself.
The software I would use would be C Cleaner.

All views would be welcomed
 
aitch said:
A friend has recommended that I clean up my registry. He admits he is no
expert so I would appreciate other comments before I commit myself.
The software I would use would be C Cleaner.

All views would be welcomed
Click to expand...

I see he has already admitted to being "no expert" so why recommend this
pointless and dangerous course of action ?
 
A friend has recommended that I clean up my registry. He admits he is no
expert so I would appreciate other comments before I commit myself.
The software I would use would be C Cleaner.

All views would be welcomed
Click to expand...


I disagree with your friend, very strongly, and recommend against
using *any* registry cleaner.

Registry cleaning programs are *all* snake oil. Cleaning of the
registry isn't needed and is dangerous. Leave the registry alone and
don't use any registry cleaner. Despite what many people think, and
what vendors of registry cleaning software try to convince you of,
having unused registry entries doesn't really hurt you.

The risk of a serious problem caused by a registry cleaner erroneously
removing an entry you need is far greater than any potential benefit
it may have.

Read http://www.edbott.com/weblog/archives/000643.html
 
Personally, CCleaner is the only program that I apply to any computer I
repair. I have never had any undesired results from using this program. It
is on the shy side of what it attempts to do and is not very aggressive at
all in it's changes. It also allows you to backup the changes and reapply
them if you have any dire consequences by allowing the changes.

That being said - I can't say as how I have ever realized any improvement
after cleaning the registry!
 
aitch said:
A friend has recommended that I clean up my registry. He admits he is no
expert so I would appreciate other comments before I commit myself.
The software I would use would be C Cleaner.

All views would be welcomed
Click to expand...


It's not ony desirable to clean up the registry with Vista, it's essential.

Otherwise your experience of the OS will be greatly reduced within a few
months. You'll have certain applications mysteriously slowing, and your
overall experience of the OS will be greatly reduced. Often imperceptibly,
since the changes are generally incremental.

A regular and targetted cleanout will keep the system speeding along.
 
Richard said:
Personally, CCleaner is the only program that I apply to any computer I
repair. I have never had any undesired results from using this program.
It is on the shy side of what it attempts to do and is not very
aggressive at all in it's changes. It also allows you to backup the
changes and reapply them if you have any dire consequences by allowing
the changes.

That being said - I can't say as how I have ever realized any
improvement after cleaning the registry!
Click to expand...

That's because you're a clueless computer user, of course! Registry
cleaners should be used to clear up a problem, not basic maintenance.

Alias
 
It's not ony desirable to clean up the registry with Vista, it's essential.

Otherwise your experience of the OS will be greatly reduced within a few
months. You'll have certain applications mysteriously slowing, and your
overall experience of the OS will be greatly reduced. Often imperceptibly,
since the changes are generally incremental.

A regular and targetted cleanout will keep the system speeding along.
Click to expand...

Cite please.

One that has measured improved performance.
 
Absolute nonsense!

Chris


Jon said:
It's not ony desirable to clean up the registry with Vista, it's
essential.

Otherwise your experience of the OS will be greatly reduced within a few
months. You'll have certain applications mysteriously slowing, and your
overall experience of the OS will be greatly reduced. Often imperceptibly,
since the changes are generally incremental.

A regular and targetted cleanout will keep the system speeding along.
Click to expand...
 
Richard Urban said:
HOGWASH AND BULL***t!
Click to expand...


You're entitled to your opinion / expletives but you're wrong.

I could cite specific examples of in-built Vista programs that progressively
build up superfluous entries in the registry over time, and cause a slowdown
, but I'll refrain. I'll leave it as a homework exercise for you to
discover, should your humility ever get the better of you.

Also since it wouldn't allow to learn the more general and important lesson,
which is that Registry Cleaners are NOT inherently evil. The name of a
program doesn't make it good or evil. A program can be written well or
badly. It can address and solve particular bugs or issues, or not

Which should really be a self-evident platitude. Anyone who has ever strung
together a simple script, program or batch file, will be well aware of this.
 
Jon said:
It's not ony desirable to clean up the registry with Vista, it's
essential.

Otherwise your experience of the OS will be greatly reduced within a few
months. You'll have certain applications mysteriously slowing, and your
overall experience of the OS will be greatly reduced. Often imperceptibly,
since the changes are generally incremental.

A regular and targetted cleanout will keep the system speeding along.
Click to expand...
 
It's not ony desirable to clean up the registry with Vista, it's essential.

Otherwise your experience of the OS will be greatly reduced within a few
months. You'll have certain applications mysteriously slowing, and your
overall experience of the OS will be greatly reduced. Often imperceptibly,
since the changes are generally incremental.
Click to expand...


I have run Vista on two machines, and on others for friends and
relatives. I have never experienced or seen anything like what you
describe. I completely disagree with what you say.
 
Well, it's quite apparent I won't be following any of your advice, Jon.

C.B.


--
It is the responsibility and duty of everyone to help the underprivileged
and less fortunate among us.

Jon said:
It's not ony desirable to clean up the registry with Vista, it's
essential.

Otherwise your experience of the OS will be greatly reduced within a few
months. You'll have certain applications mysteriously slowing, and your
overall experience of the OS will be greatly reduced. Often imperceptibly,
since the changes are generally incremental.

A regular and targetted cleanout will keep the system speeding along.

--
Jon


__________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus
signature database 4197 (20090629) __________

The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.

http://www.eset.com
Click to expand...

__________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus signature database 4197 (20090629) __________

The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.

http://www.eset.com
 
HOGWASH AND BULL***t!
Click to expand...

Well, there is a simple way to prove it,
just download and install say 20 apps, of various sorts,
use all of them for a couple of days,
then use windows to un-install them... and continue using your computer
as you normal would...

Windows, does not watch the applications, of what software gets
installed, into which folders... and Windows, does not watch the
applications of what they take out, AND/OR leave behind.

Hmm, there was a application on Macintosh, that would encode a new
application, with a tag header of every part of the software that got
installed, so, you would launch the app first, the launch the the new
application that you wanted to install... and your done..

un-install was easy... too
just launch the first application, it pick from the list, and click
un-install ( all ) would be un-install, not even ONE trace left behind.

I wish I could say the same for Windows, But I can't..
Even, Microsoft offered One-Care on line, for fix registry problems...

As you know the registry does have a size limit.


Rick
 
As you know the registry does have a size limit.
Click to expand...

In Vista??! XP Pro allowed one to change the registry size.

"To change the maximum size of the computer's registry"

1.
Open Computer Management (Local)

2.
In the console tree, right-click Computer Management (Local), and
then select Properties.

3.
On the Advanced tab, click Performance Options, and under Virtual
memory, click Change.

4.
Under Registry size, type a new registry size in megabytes in the
Maximum Registry Size (MB) box.

5.
You must restart your computer to apply any changes.


Note

• To open Computer Management, click Start, and then click Control
Panel. Click Performance and Maintenance, click Administrative Tools,
and then double-click Computer Management.

• You must be recognized as an administrator or a member of the
Administrators group on your computer and on the computer you are
managing to perform this task.

• You can view or change system properties on a remote computer or a
local computer To access a remote computer, right-click Computer
Management (Local), click Connect to another computer, and then select
the computer you want to connect to in the list.

• Setting a maximum size for the registry sets an upper limit on how
large the area designated for registry data can become. You might need
to increase the maximum registry size if the amount of registry data
produced by programs exceeds the limit you set under Registry size.


http://www.microsoft.com/resources/...size_of_the_computer_s_registry.mspx?mfr=true
 
Back
Top