Q: Columbus or sqlDESKTOP or Optimal Desktop Experience? Also HSQLDB.

  • Thread starter Thread starter BillR
  • Start date Start date
B

BillR

Hi,

Do any of you have experience with Columbus, sqlDESKTOP or Optimal
Desktop?

HSQL Database Engine (HSQLDB) found.

=========================
Columbus
http://www.oasys-software.com/product/dm/columbus/
=========================
Personal Edition is registerware (key). "Intended for private use,
where access to network resources and other professional features are
not required." Pro "supports the latest file formats [and] operates
in a network environment".

How current is are the Stellent and ???? engines? What version of
Quick View Plus (Stellent) is equivalent?

Has anyone tried combining the Stellent engine in Columbus with
PowerDesk (free)?

Personal individual user? Pro networked user? Multiple personal
users on a network (e.g., home network)?

What are the disadvantages, problems, and limitations?

How does it compare to other products you have used or evaluated?
Better alternatives?

=========================
sqlDESKTOP
http://www.sqldesktop.com
=========================
Registerware (key). Network server edition is $50 - $100.

Single user? Network server? Multiple single users on a network?

Are you using the default HSQL Database Engine (HSQLDB) or another DB?

In the personal edition are the files actually stored within dbms
files or just pointers/shortcuts?

What hardware is required for this to be practical?

What are the disadvantages, problems, and limitations?

How does it compare to other products you have used?
Better alternatives?

----------
BTW, someone might be interested in HSQLDB in its own right. I don't
think it has ever been mentioned on ACF.

HSQLDB "is a completely functional object-relational [DBMS] that is
completely free free...." This small (< 160k) Java based product is
used by production open source and commercial products.

http://hsqldb.sourceforge.net

=========================
Optimal Desktop
http://www.optimalaccess.com/en/product_overview.htm
=========================
Hmmm, looks like they are no longer providing a free single user
license (with key). Is anyone still using it for free?

I had initial and susequent problems with their license key. I
stopped using it but was initially impressed although it seemed a bit
"expansive".

I am still curious how it compares with the above.

TIA,
BillR
 
....
BTW, someone might be interested in HSQLDB in its own right. I don't
think it has ever been mentioned on ACF.

HSQLDB "is a completely functional object-relational [DBMS] that is
completely free free...." This small (< 160k) Java based product is
used by production open source and commercial products.

http://hsqldb.sourceforge.net

=========================

Cousin BillR ....

I spent a short bit of time with hsqldb about 3 years ago,
but didn't actually get very far with it beyond basic setup
and test ....

To use hsqldb effectively the user probably should be VERY fluent
in programming Java and I wasn't ....
 
BillR said:

Hey - that's a NEW version of the Columbus Personal Edition - thanks
BillR. :)

http://www.oasys-software.com/product/downloads/dm/columbus/

Columbus 'Personal Edition' download
Installation Requirements

* Microsoft Windows XP, 2000, ME or 98
* 50MB of free disk space
* A Recommended screen resolution of 1024x768 pixels or greater.

19 July 2004
Columbus 3.0
Columbus-Personal-30b.exe 36Mb

To obtain a free licence number for Columbus 'Personal Edition', please
fill in this form

Susan
 
Hi,

Do any of you have experience with Columbus, sqlDESKTOP or Optimal
Desktop?

HSQL Database Engine (HSQLDB) found.

=========================
Columbus
http://www.oasys-software.com/product/dm/columbus/
=========================
Personal Edition is registerware (key). "Intended for private use,
where access to network resources and other professional features are
not required." Pro "supports the latest file formats [and] operates
in a network environment".

How current is are the Stellent and ???? engines? What version of
Quick View Plus (Stellent) is equivalent?

Has anyone tried combining the Stellent engine in Columbus with
PowerDesk (free)?

Personal individual user? Pro networked user? Multiple personal
users on a network (e.g., home network)?

What are the disadvantages, problems, and limitations?

How does it compare to other products you have used or evaluated?
Better alternatives?

The new Free Columbus has been crippled to cull sales for the
Professional version. Several functions have been omitted from the
previous version.

There is no accessing any sort of network or shared drives which makes
it a serious non-starter.

I installed it, used it for a few minutes, couldn't access files on
shared drives. I uninstalled it and installed a previous version.

I don't know of any other alternatives for CAD file management.
===========================================================================
Chris
 
Back
Top