Power Supply

  • Thread starter Thread starter Eric Scofield
  • Start date Start date
E

Eric Scofield

What is the best way to determine if your system is coming close to taxing
the resources of the power supply?

Thanks in advance,

Eric Scofield
 
What is the best way to determine if your system is coming close to taxing
the resources of the power supply?

Thanks in advance,

Eric Scofield

Start with known-quality, name-brand power supply, measure the
voltages on the connectors (while system is running as close to
maximal load as possible) with a voltage meter. Also take 12V
reading when the system is first turned on, while the HDD(s) are
spinning up. This is less effective at testing a cheap/junk power
supply because there may be a LOT of ripple when the power supply is
near it's limit.

An alternate method might be to add up the power consumption of the
parts, but generally this isn't successfull in telling you anything
except the absolute max it would theoretically be possible to need if
it were possible to fully load everything at once, not the other way
around, what the system is actually using.

Is there a specific problem prompting this question? It's often
easier to work the other-way-around, diagnose a problem rather than
looking for one where it might not exist.


Dave
 
Is there a specific problem prompting this question? It's often
easier to work the other-way-around, diagnose a problem rather than
looking for one where it might not exist.

I have been upgrading my Gateway system little by little as of lately, and
frankly this is my first time tinkering with computer upgrading. I know
that the power supply that came with the computer is a 200 W PSU. I was
planning on adding a second hard drive and a new sound card and was worried
that the available power may not be sufficient.

- Eric
 
I have been upgrading my Gateway system little by little as of lately, and
frankly this is my first time tinkering with computer upgrading. I know
that the power supply that came with the computer is a 200 W PSU. I was
planning on adding a second hard drive and a new sound card and was worried
that the available power may not be sufficient.

- Eric

Daft as it is that depends on the quality of the power supply and not
the wattage however with more modern CPUs and graphics card the
current draw on the PS is more and that's when the quality of the
components shows.
There are cheap 300/400w 450w etc PS that I wouldn't use to power my
night light<grin>.
I used to make my own years ago.Showing my age a bit :O




--
Free Windows/PC help,
http://www.geocities.com/sheppola/trouble.html
email shepATpartyheld.de
Free songs download,
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/8/nomessiahsmusic.htm
 
I have been upgrading my Gateway system little by little as of lately, and
frankly this is my first time tinkering with computer upgrading. I know
that the power supply that came with the computer is a 200 W PSU. I was
planning on adding a second hard drive and a new sound card and was worried
that the available power may not be sufficient.

- Eric

I have about 5 old Gateway systems here that started out with 200W PSU
in them. Those 200W PSU were ok for up to a 1GHz P3 with a couple of
HDD and a moderate video card, but not much more. If the rest of the
system is original, adding a second HDD and a sound card shouldn't
require a PSU replacement, but a significant video card,
motherboard/CPU upgrade, would. Of course this is assuming a PSU
operating properly, if it's at end-of-life it may be necessary to
replace it regardless.

Many of the older, mid-tower Gateway cases used a proprietary PSU
form-factor, that is narrower and has a rectangluar exhaust with the
only fan underneith the PSU... these chassis require a lot more work
to replace the PSU with one that's standard-ATX, including drilling
new mounting holes, cutting out a larger rear hole for the fan and AC
plug, and the measurements for these must be pretty accurate because
most of their cases had very little margin for error, the interior
width was barely more than the width of a standard PSU.


Dave
 
I have been upgrading my Gateway system little by little as of lately, and
frankly this is my first time tinkering with computer upgrading. I know
that the power supply that came with the computer is a 200 W PSU. I was
planning on adding a second hard drive and a new sound card and was worried
that the available power may not be sufficient.

- Eric

I have about 5 old Gateway systems here that started out with 200W PSU
in them. Those 200W PSU were ok for up to a 1GHz P3 with a couple of
HDD and a moderate video card, but not much more. If the rest of the
system is original, adding a second HDD and a sound card shouldn't
require a PSU replacement, but a significant video card,
motherboard/CPU upgrade, would. Of course this is assuming a PSU
operating properly, if it's at end-of-life it may be necessary to
replace it regardless.

Many of the older, mid-tower Gateway cases used a proprietary PSU
form-factor, that is narrower and has a rectangluar exhaust with the
only fan underneith the PSU... these chassis require a lot more work
to replace the PSU with one that's standard-ATX, including drilling
new mounting holes, cutting out a larger rear hole for the fan and AC
plug, and the measurements for these must be pretty accurate because
most of their cases had very little margin for error, the interior
width was barely more than the width of a standard PSU.


Dave
 
I have about 5 old Gateway systems here that started out with 200W PSU
in them. Those 200W PSU were ok for up to a 1GHz P3 with a couple of
HDD and a moderate video card, but not much more. If the rest of the
system is original, adding a second HDD and a sound card shouldn't
require a PSU replacement, but a significant video card,
motherboard/CPU upgrade, would. Of course this is assuming a PSU
operating properly, if it's at end-of-life it may be necessary to
replace it regardless.

Many of the older, mid-tower Gateway cases used a proprietary PSU
form-factor, that is narrower and has a rectangluar exhaust with the
only fan underneith the PSU... these chassis require a lot more work
to replace the PSU with one that's standard-ATX, including drilling
new mounting holes, cutting out a larger rear hole for the fan and AC
plug, and the measurements for these must be pretty accurate because
most of their cases had very little margin for error, the interior
width was barely more than the width of a standard PSU.


Dave

You've got 10 now ;-)



--
Free Windows/PC help,
http://www.geocities.com/sheppola/trouble.html
email shepATpartyheld.de
Free songs download,
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/8/nomessiahsmusic.htm
 
Eric Scofield said:
What is the best way to determine if your system is coming close to taxing
the resources of the power supply?
Eric Scofield

If you have a bad power supply one of the symptoms will be higher heat,
crashing, shutdown, and another would be interference of the video signal.
The problem is many other devices in the computer can cause these same
symptoms including software. How to narrow it down to just the PSU can be a
daunting task even for a trained technician.

Most techs if they suspect a bad power supply will simply swap one out
and see if the problem disappears, barring that some software (sandra) can
detect voltage drops which can be deadly to a computer. Unfortunately the
software might not be accurate so you need a voltage tester to double check.

http://www.formfactors.org/developer/specs/ATX12V_1_3dg.pdf

Here you will find the connectors used in a computer with the proper
voltages. While the computer is on and under various types of load such as
calculating, copying, burning etc check that the voltages are correct, if
they drop any more than 10 percent then that's a good indication that
something is wrong. Ignore the -12 signal as it's not used anymore.

Note that this is not for beginners as it can be quite dangerous.

Lane
 
I have about 5 old Gateway systems here that started out with 200W PSU
in them. Those 200W PSU were ok for up to a 1GHz P3 with a couple of
HDD and a moderate video card, but not much more. If the rest of the
system is original, adding a second HDD and a sound card shouldn't
require a PSU replacement, but a significant video card,
motherboard/CPU upgrade, would. Of course this is assuming a PSU
operating properly, if it's at end-of-life it may be necessary to
replace it regardless.

Many of the older, mid-tower Gateway cases used a proprietary PSU
form-factor, that is narrower and has a rectangluar exhaust with the
only fan underneith the PSU... these chassis require a lot more work
to replace the PSU with one that's standard-ATX, including drilling
new mounting holes, cutting out a larger rear hole for the fan and AC
plug, and the measurements for these must be pretty accurate because
most of their cases had very little margin for error, the interior
width was barely more than the width of a standard PSU.

Yeah, I have a Gateway from 1999. It has a PIII 450 MHz processor in it.
I'm assuming that I can get several more years from the power supply.
Besides, if I were to get a new motherboard and CPU, then I would never
reuse an older Gateway case. I'd go more top-of-the-line as far as cases go
so that my newer computer would be easier to upgrade in the future.

- Eric
 
Yeah, I have a Gateway from 1999. It has a PIII 450 MHz processor in it.
I'm assuming that I can get several more years from the power supply.
Besides, if I were to get a new motherboard and CPU, then I would never
reuse an older Gateway case. I'd go more top-of-the-line as far as cases go
so that my newer computer would be easier to upgrade in the future.

- Eric

They aren't bad power supplies, well-made compared to Compaq's of the
same era, but are really worth around 200W. In the past I've had to
pull them for upgrades that worked fine with 300W Antec and Sparkle
PSU.

It's really not that bad to reuse a midtower Gateway case if you're
willing to put in the work, most new cases aren't as sturdy or quiet
as those were. After roughly 2nd quater of '97 they started putting
rear 80mm fan mounts in, which can be cut out to aid aiflow, and
around mid '98 the front bezels were redesigned to have more air
intake, but they then went with a metal left-side cover instead of the
all plastic clad metal of the previous design... otherwise they were
the same internally. The original, top CDROM drives on the older ones
had a brand-specific tray faceplate though, which couldn't be expected
to fit on other brands, maybe even newer models of optical drives, but
a bit of Super Glue or tiny screws will fix that.


Dave
 
They aren't bad power supplies, well-made compared to Compaq's of the
same era, but are really worth around 200W. In the past I've had to
pull them for upgrades that worked fine with 300W Antec and Sparkle
PSU.

So you DID replace the PSU successfully. That's good information to know in
case I am in need of replacing mine. It wouldn't really hurt if I replaced
the PSU with a 300 W or 330 W Antec PSU even if the existing PSU is still
adequate, would it? I could use the practice anyways. I want to keep this
computer for my family and build my own from scratch. It's over four years
old, but it's more than fast enough for everything they have to do. I've
already added two more 128 MB PC100 SDRAM from Crucial, replaced the
CD-ROM/DVD-ROM with a faster CD-RW/DVD drive from SONY (CRX300A) and added
an Antec rear case fan. My next mission is to replace the PSU with at least
a 300 W one and add a bigger, faster hard drive (possibly an 80 GB) and make
it my system drive with the old as slave.

Antec is a good reccomendation for a PSU? How about a hard drive? The one
I have is 5400 RPM; should I go with 7200 RPM or faster? Would you
reccomend added a case fan in front of the hard drive? I haven't really
looked at the front of the case too much. I wonder if it even has holes to
screw a fan into?

- Eric
 
So you DID replace the PSU successfully.

I did, but as i mentioned previously, it isn't a "drop-in" replacement
if yours has the proprietary form-factor PSU. If it has that narrow
PSU with fan on the underside only, then you would have to disassemble
the system and cut out the back some and drill holes. It's
worthwhile to also cut out the stamped-in fan grill on the rear too.
That's good information to know in
case I am in need of replacing mine. It wouldn't really hurt if I replaced
the PSU with a 300 W or 330 W Antec PSU even if the existing PSU is still
adequate, would it?

Considering the modifications needed to replace the PSU, I would only
do so when it's necessary, which it probably isn't for the
aforementioned HDD and sound card upgrade.


I could use the practice anyways. I want to keep this
computer for my family and build my own from scratch. It's over four years
old, but it's more than fast enough for everything they have to do. I've
already added two more 128 MB PC100 SDRAM from Crucial, replaced the
CD-ROM/DVD-ROM with a faster CD-RW/DVD drive from SONY (CRX300A) and added
an Antec rear case fan. My next mission is to replace the PSU with at least
a 300 W one and add a bigger, faster hard drive (possibly an 80 GB) and make
it my system drive with the old as slave.

Antec is a good reccomendation for a PSU? How about a hard drive? The one
I have is 5400 RPM; should I go with 7200 RPM or faster? Would you
reccomend added a case fan in front of the hard drive? I haven't really
looked at the front of the case too much. I wonder if it even has holes to
screw a fan into?

Antec would be fine. You'll need to check the motherboard BIOS
updates to see the max capacity HDD it'll support, or install a PCI
IDE controller. I suspect you need a BIOS update for larger than
32GB, but that's right around the time when the original BIOS started
supporting higher, you'll have to check on that.

Western Digital or Maxtor are two good values, often with rebates for
the best $ per GB price. The WD is a little faster but a lot louder,
and the speed difference would be negligable on that board, since
either drive would only operate at the ATA33 speed supported by the
motherboard, unless you install a PCI IDE controller.

Assuming yours is the common mid-tower case, the HDDs should be
mounted in a unique OEM-style vertical mounting, with vent holes in
front of the drives but no way to easily mount a fan. With a strong
PSU and 2nd, rear fan (with the stamped-in fan grills cut out) there
should be enough airflow through the HDD rack to keep a modern 7200RPM
drive cool enough, providing the case isn't sitting on carpeting that
blocks the air inlet on the underside of the bezel, AND providing the
original interior metal EMF shields (or other method of sealing off
that) are installed in the unused 5 1/4" bays, so all the airflow
comes in through the bottom instead of up through the bezel all the
way to an uncovered 5 1/4" bay.


Dave
 
On Fri, 31 Oct 2003 10:11:08 -0500, "Eric Scofield"

So you DID replace the PSU successfully.

I got out another of the cases and marked it for cutting later...

Here's what the proprietary Gateway PSUs I've referred to, look like:
http://69.36.189.159/usr_1034/gw_psu.jpg

To convert the case to using a standard ATX PSU, you'd need to cut out
similarly to how I've marked this case:
http://69.36.189.159/usr_1034/gw_rear_psu.jpg

Except, some PSU vary on exactly where the AC plug is located, you
might need to cut the left side top slightly higher, but the
straight-across marking I made fits most of the PSU I have here.

One thing I'd forgotten about these is that this one has a
stamped-in-metal rear I/O shield for the motherboard ports, while the
next-older style has the snap-in shield plate. It's the semi-standard
arrangement, would fit many boards but some new boards with multiple
rear USB ports or differing sound jacks, particularly when there's no
gameport, are incompatible with the existing holes, making it unusable
without cutting out more holes, or what I'll end up doing to this one,
just cutting out the whole rectangular area to accept a standard
snap-in rear I/O plate, as usually comes with those motherboards
having the non-standard rear ports.

Even those boards with the standard ports, may have a network adapter
port that isn't provided for with this case's cutouts.

If you only wanted to drill the PSU screw-mounting holes you could
probably get away with using a Sparkle/Fortron 300-350W with the 120mm
fan underneith, like this:
http://images10.newegg.com/productimage/17-104-966-02.JPG
That is assuming you'd use the fan under it too, to ensure enough
ventilation.


Dave
 
Here's what the proprietary Gateway PSUs I've referred to, look like:
http://69.36.189.159/usr_1034/gw_psu.jpg

To convert the case to using a standard ATX PSU, you'd need to cut out
similarly to how I've marked this case:
http://69.36.189.159/usr_1034/gw_rear_psu.jpg

Except, some PSU vary on exactly where the AC plug is located, you
might need to cut the left side top slightly higher, but the
straight-across marking I made fits most of the PSU I have here.

One thing I'd forgotten about these is that this one has a
stamped-in-metal rear I/O shield for the motherboard ports, while the
next-older style has the snap-in shield plate. It's the semi-standard
arrangement, would fit many boards but some new boards with multiple
rear USB ports or differing sound jacks, particularly when there's no
gameport, are incompatible with the existing holes, making it unusable
without cutting out more holes, or what I'll end up doing to this one,
just cutting out the whole rectangular area to accept a standard
snap-in rear I/O plate, as usually comes with those motherboards
having the non-standard rear ports.

Even those boards with the standard ports, may have a network adapter
port that isn't provided for with this case's cutouts.

If you only wanted to drill the PSU screw-mounting holes you could
probably get away with using a Sparkle/Fortron 300-350W with the 120mm
fan underneith, like this:
http://images10.newegg.com/productimage/17-104-966-02.JPG
That is assuming you'd use the fan under it too, to ensure enough
ventilation.


That's great information. Thank you very much. What exactly is your tool
of choice when making these adjustments to the case, and more importantly
what precautions should I take when attemping a case adjustment? Having
never done one before, I don't want to ruin anything.

Sincerely,

Eric Scofield
 
That's great information. Thank you very much. What exactly is your tool
of choice when making these adjustments to the case, and more importantly
what precautions should I take when attemping a case adjustment? Having
never done one before, I don't want to ruin anything.

Sincerely,

Eric Scofield

I use a sabre saw with a fine-toothed blade, I forget the pitch. I
tape off the border of the case metal with masking tape to prevent
scratches and set it on cardboard to keep the rest from scratching up.

Next I briefly file it and sand it just enough to be rid of any
roughness and burrs, overdoing the sanding results in discoloration of
the outside wall of the case, it'd be shiney instead of the factory
finish, which is a coated metal then thinly clearcoated... it would've
been nice if the clearcoat was a bit thicker, it does tend to
deteriorate somewhat after a few years, but at least the rest of the
colored paint is thicker than average.

As for the recessed I/O ports, I could probably do a rough job of it
with a sabre saw then a lot more filing out the roughness, but it's
easier to just drill out the rivets, cut it from the back-side on a
bench, then pick up a $1 pack of screws/bolts at the hardware store to
reattach it through the rivet holes.

I also forgot to mention that the left-side cover needs a slight
notch or bend in it to clear the lower-right PSU mounting screw, or if
you are daring, the PSU should be secure enough without that screw
because of how thick the metal is... it's really much nicer to work
on and use these thick-walled cases compared to some of the
alternatives... modern cases are great but only if you know how thick
the metal is before purchase, and most cases with metal this thick
cost more, usually >$60 even without the plastic overcoat.

I'm not suggesting that the case is THAT good, but after adapted to a
standard PSU and better rear air exhaust it's perfectly fine for a
modern system.

One other thing I forgot to mention is that many if not all of thse
have pressed-in motherboard standoffs... There is a standoff on the
left-side, 2nd from the bottom, that isn't used on many full-ATX
motherboards, may need pulled out with pliers. mATX boards do use
this standoff though.


Dave
 
I use a sabre saw with a fine-toothed blade, I forget the pitch. I
tape off the border of the case metal with masking tape to prevent
scratches and set it on cardboard to keep the rest from scratching up.

Next I briefly file it and sand it just enough to be rid of any
roughness and burrs, overdoing the sanding results in discoloration of
the outside wall of the case, it'd be shiney instead of the factory
finish, which is a coated metal then thinly clearcoated... it would've
been nice if the clearcoat was a bit thicker, it does tend to
deteriorate somewhat after a few years, but at least the rest of the
colored paint is thicker than average.

As for the recessed I/O ports, I could probably do a rough job of it
with a sabre saw then a lot more filing out the roughness, but it's
easier to just drill out the rivets, cut it from the back-side on a
bench, then pick up a $1 pack of screws/bolts at the hardware store to
reattach it through the rivet holes.

I also forgot to mention that the left-side cover needs a slight
notch or bend in it to clear the lower-right PSU mounting screw, or if
you are daring, the PSU should be secure enough without that screw
because of how thick the metal is... it's really much nicer to work
on and use these thick-walled cases compared to some of the
alternatives... modern cases are great but only if you know how thick
the metal is before purchase, and most cases with metal this thick
cost more, usually >$60 even without the plastic overcoat.

I'm not suggesting that the case is THAT good, but after adapted to a
standard PSU and better rear air exhaust it's perfectly fine for a
modern system.

One other thing I forgot to mention is that many if not all of thse
have pressed-in motherboard standoffs... There is a standoff on the
left-side, 2nd from the bottom, that isn't used on many full-ATX
motherboards, may need pulled out with pliers. mATX boards do use
this standoff though.

I may try this. What are they exact dimensions of the lines you drew on the
case? I also notices you plan on cutting a new rear case fan slot, but will
you also cut off the grate on the one below it? You seem very adequate with
making case adjustments. Having you been doing them for a long time?
Thanks again.

- Eric Scofield
 
I may try this. What are they exact dimensions of the lines you drew on the
case? I also notices you plan on cutting a new rear case fan slot, but will
you also cut off the grate on the one below it? You seem very adequate with
making case adjustments. Having you been doing them for a long time?
Thanks again.

- Eric Scofield

I'll just link the larger image, if printed at 300DPI it should be at
full scale, is a large, ~ 2.7MB download.
http://69.36.189.159/usr_1034/gw_rear_psu-lg.jpg

Keep in mind what I mentioned before about the power supply AC input
socket, it is possible you'd need to cut higher on the left side, you
can hold the intended PSU up in the case and see how high it is.

I will be cutting out the existing fan grill, I just didn't feel the
need to mark it, as it's fairly obvious where to cut.

I don't really remember when I did my first significant case-mod, I've
been working with metal for a couple decades now but only in the past
half-dozen years did I start accumulating ATX cases. I"m a supplier
for a few local PC shops and they practially (or do) give me the cases
for free or low-value (to me) credit, so it's pretty easy to
experiment with them when they're cheap/free, harder to get the
motivation so I usually do multiple cases at a time... just because I
have that linked case marked, doesn't mean I'll be doing any cutting
on it yet, not untill I have a few more planned out and marked as
well.


Dave



Dave
 
It would be nice to do this. I plan however on keeping this computer for my
family and building my own from scratch. I wish to ensure that it lasts
them many more years so that they don't have to go and spend money on a new
one (money they can't afford right now). What is average shelf life for a
computer like my Gateway in your opinion?

- Eric
 
It would be nice to do this. I plan however on keeping this computer for my
family and building my own from scratch. I wish to ensure that it lasts
them many more years so that they don't have to go and spend money on a new
one (money they can't afford right now). What is average shelf life for a
computer like my Gateway in your opinion?

- Eric

I'd expect the Gateways to last longer than most, partially because
those used Intel motherboards with very few but way overspec'd (huge
for that era) electrolytic capacitors and lower RPM dual ball bearing
fan. Even so, random events like power surges or HDD failures can
cause a machine to cease normal function at any time. I would expect
the HDD to fail first, if not the CDROM drive, and they're both about
that age when they could go (assuming original parts). Beyond that it
can depend on the environment, amount of use, lots of facturs in
addition to unforseeable failures.

In other words, I can't really predict the lifespan of the unit as a
whole, especially when individual parts can be replaced as needed.
The majority of parts (other than HDD or optical drives) I've pulled
from these Gateway systems still work fine but were retired due to
old/slow technology and lesser features.


Dave

Dave
 
Back
Top