Please Advice: ATI 9600 Pro Vs MX5600 (not Ultra)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Little Farm
  • Start date Start date
L

Little Farm

ATI 9600 Pro 128Mb RAM Vs MX5600 256Mb RAM(not Ultra)
ATI 9600 Pro is $10 more

Judging on overall gaming performance, which one is better?
 
ATI 9600 Pro 128Mb RAM Vs MX5600 256Mb RAM(not Ultra)
ATI 9600 Pro is $10 more

Judging on overall gaming performance, which one is better?

Im wondering about this myself.

ATI prices arent falling drastically like I hoped , before christmas.
In fact they seemed to have firmed and gone a bit up a little.

On the otherhand they did supposedly improved the drivers for the 5600
and the price has fallen drastically at a few places. The problem is
there are so many models out now and changes that its hard to get a
clear review comparing the latest versions with other cards.

My goal was to skip the 9600 though I havent read up on the other
weird variations theyve come up with the ultra and go for the 9700/pro
but its price hasnt budged at all.
 
Thanks! Price is indeed my major consideration against 9700 now as well.
 
Im wondering about this myself.

ATI prices arent falling drastically like I hoped , before christmas.
In fact they seemed to have firmed and gone a bit up a little.

On the otherhand they did supposedly improved the drivers for the 5600
and the price has fallen drastically at a few places. The problem is
there are so many models out now and changes that its hard to get a
clear review comparing the latest versions with other cards.

My goal was to skip the 9600 though I havent read up on the other
weird variations theyve come up with the ultra and go for the 9700/pro
but its price hasnt budged at all.

Driver improvements? Take a look at
http://www.tomshardware.com/graphic/20030918/index.html.

Basicly, it's saying that, even it's only circumstantial evidence, that
NVidia is cheating with it's drivers. If you look at the screenshots of a
couple of driver versions, you can see that the newest drivers don't render
everything, resulting in a higher score. The 45.23 drivers offers almost
100% performance increase compared to 43.03 with the FX5900Ultra card! The
FX5600 Ultra has similair "optimilalisations".

And in this particulair benchmark, the 9600Pro even outperforms the 5900 FX
Ultra. And take a look at
http://www.tomshardware.com/graphic/20030912/index.html. That's a half-life
2 benchmark. Take a look at the graphs and see for yourself...

Like (e-mail address removed), I think you should wait a while because the arrival of
the ATi TX cards will trigger pricedrops, but if you do eventually get a
new card, I would go for an ATi, and definitely not for an NVidia card.

Halfgaar
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Back
Top