[PL] Slogan Vote Results

  • Thread starter Thread starter Garrett
  • Start date Start date
G

Garrett

The following are the results of a thread requesting votes on changing
the Pricelessware slogan.

Originally, two slogans were set to be voted on, but a third was cast
in by people wishing to vote on it. I personally have no problem with
this, but I can't say whether this will be acceptable with others.

In this group, not everyone will ever agree 100% on anything.


1. "The best of the best in Windows© Freeware as determined by the
readers of alt.comp.freeware."

14 Votes


2. "The best of the best in Freeware for Windows© (and other OS) as
determined by the readers of alt.comp.freeware."

3 Votes


3. "The best of the best of Freeware as determined by the readers of
alt.comp.freeware"

26 Votes




----------------------------------------------------------------




1. "The best of the best in Windows© Freeware as determined by the
readers of alt.comp.freeware."

From: "Garrett" <[email protected]>
From: John Corliss <[email protected]#>
From: Iain Cheyne <[email protected]>
From: Nicolaas Hawkins <[email protected]>
From: GoodTime Barnie <[email protected]>
From: "Susan" <[email protected]>
From: "norry" <[email protected]>
From: "Phil" <[email protected]>
From: "badgolferman" <[email protected]>
From: "Jack D. Russell, Sr." <[email protected]>
From: Eric <[email protected]>
From: Peggy <[email protected]>
From: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?=BBQ=AB?= <[email protected]>
From: Klaatu <[email protected]>


2. "The best of the best in Freeware for Windows© (and other OS) as
determined by the readers of alt.comp.freeware."

From: Dan Goodman <[email protected]>
From: Semolina Pilchard <[email protected]>
From: Roger Johansson <[email protected]>


3. "The best of the best of Freeware as determined by the readers of
alt.comp.freeware"

From: "FadedGlory" <[email protected]>
From: wald <arnout.standaert@n*o_s-p%
From: dszady <[email protected]>
From: MLC <[email protected]>
From: bambam <[email protected]>
From: burnr <[email protected]>
From: Henk de Jong <[email protected]>
From: Jim Daniel <[email protected]>
From: "LPV" <[email protected]>
From: "H.M.A. (Dick) Hazeleger" <dick@post_it_in_the_newsgroup.invalid>
From: miskairal <[email protected]>
From: Buzzy <[email protected]>
From: Susan Bugher <[email protected]>
From: Lenny Nero <[email protected]>
From: Trevor Frew <[email protected]>
From: Colin <[email protected]>
From: Marko <[email protected]>
From: Jaime Littlebeaver <[email protected]>
From: Cousin Stanley <[email protected]>
From: (e-mail address removed)
From: "OhnO the Clown" <[email protected]>
From: =?iso-8859-1?Q?Omar=A9?= <[email protected]>
From: Soren Hedeby Sorensen <[email protected]>
From: (e-mail address removed) (ubaB ilagnaB)
From: "James" <[email protected]>
From: Harvey Van Sickle <[email protected]>
 
Garrett said:
The following are the results of a thread requesting votes on changing
the Pricelessware slogan.

Originally, two slogans were set to be voted on, but a third was cast
in by people wishing to vote on it. I personally have no problem with
this, but I can't say whether this will be acceptable with others.

In this group, not everyone will ever agree 100% on anything.

1. "The best of the best in Windows© Freeware as determined by the
readers of alt.comp.freeware."

14 Votes

2. "The best of the best in Freeware for Windows© (and other OS) as
determined by the readers of alt.comp.freeware."

3 Votes

3. "The best of the best of Freeware as determined by the readers of
alt.comp.freeware"

26 Votes

----------------------------------------------------------------

1. "The best of the best in Windows© Freeware as determined by the
readers of alt.comp.freeware."

From: "Garrett" <[email protected]>
From: John Corliss <[email protected]#>
From: Iain Cheyne <[email protected]>
From: Nicolaas Hawkins <[email protected]>
From: GoodTime Barnie <[email protected]>
From: "Susan" <[email protected]>
From: "norry" <[email protected]>
From: "Phil" <[email protected]>
From: "badgolferman" <[email protected]>
From: "Jack D. Russell, Sr." <[email protected]>
From: Eric <[email protected]>
From: Peggy <[email protected]>
From: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?=BBQ=AB?= <[email protected]>
From: Klaatu <[email protected]>

2. "The best of the best in Freeware for Windows© (and other OS) as
determined by the readers of alt.comp.freeware."

From: Dan Goodman <[email protected]>
From: Semolina Pilchard <[email protected]>
From: Roger Johansson <[email protected]>

3. "The best of the best of Freeware as determined by the readers of
alt.comp.freeware"

From: "FadedGlory" <[email protected]>
From: wald <arnout.standaert@n*o_s-p%
From: dszady <[email protected]>
From: MLC <[email protected]>
From: bambam <[email protected]>
From: burnr <[email protected]>
From: Henk de Jong <[email protected]>
From: Jim Daniel <[email protected]>
From: "LPV" <[email protected]>
From: "H.M.A. (Dick) Hazeleger" <dick@post_it_in_the_newsgroup.invalid>
From: miskairal <[email protected]>
From: Buzzy <[email protected]>
From: Susan Bugher <[email protected]>
From: Lenny Nero <[email protected]>
From: Trevor Frew <[email protected]>
From: Colin <[email protected]>
From: Marko <[email protected]>
From: Jaime Littlebeaver <[email protected]>
From: Cousin Stanley <[email protected]>
From: (e-mail address removed)
From: "OhnO the Clown" <[email protected]>
From: =?iso-8859-1?Q?Omar=A9?= <[email protected]>
From: Soren Hedeby Sorensen <[email protected]>
From: (e-mail address removed) (ubaB ilagnaB)
From: "James" <[email protected]>
From: Harvey Van Sickle <[email protected]>
Click to expand...

Err I think 27, see below
<[email protected]>
Where I voted.
Thanks
Omar
--
"When I am right, No one remembers
When I am wrong, No one forgets"

The Home of Pricelessware 2004
http://www.pricelesswarehome.org/
 
|1. "The best of the best in Windows=3F Freeware as determined by the
|readers of alt.comp.freeware."
|
|From: "Garrett" <[email protected]>
|From: John Corliss <[email protected]#>
|From: Iain Cheyne <[email protected]>
|From: Nicolaas Hawkins <[email protected]>
|From: GoodTime Barnie <[email protected]>
|From: "Susan" <[email protected]>
|From: "norry" <[email protected]>
|From: "Phil" <[email protected]>
|From: "badgolferman" <[email protected]>
|From: "Jack D. Russell, Sr." <[email protected]>
|From: Eric <[email protected]>
|From: Peggy <[email protected]>
|From: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?=BBQ=AB?= <[email protected]>
|From: Klaatu <[email protected]>

And don't forget to count mine which was cast here
<[email protected]>
 
Tramp said:
|1. "The best of the best in Windows=3F Freeware as determined by the
|readers of alt.comp.freeware."
|
|From: "Garrett" <[email protected]>
|From: John Corliss <[email protected]#>
|From: Iain Cheyne <[email protected]>
|From: Nicolaas Hawkins <[email protected]>
|From: GoodTime Barnie <[email protected]>
|From: "Susan" <[email protected]>
|From: "norry" <[email protected]>
|From: "Phil" <[email protected]>
|From: "badgolferman" <[email protected]>
|From: "Jack D. Russell, Sr." <[email protected]>
|From: Eric <[email protected]>
|From: Peggy <[email protected]>
|From: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?=BBQ=AB?= <[email protected]>
|From: Klaatu <[email protected]>

And don't forget to count mine which was cast here
<[email protected]>
Click to expand...

You must be from Florida? (GG)
 
The following are the results of a thread requesting votes on changing
the Pricelessware slogan.
Click to expand...
In this group, not everyone will ever agree 100% on anything.
Click to expand...
<Snip results>

I think a few of us (i.e., at least me) who were not counted were aligned
with maintaining a Windows reference. For future reference, a count of this
type should include spoiled/other/etc. as one or more categories.

"Windows" is a REGISTERED TRADEMARK when used as in the slogan. This is a
simple correction that should follow from a brief discussion. A vote is not
only not required, it is inappropriate. It is a fact in the U.S. and many
other countries. We got it wrong and just didn't notice before. Go to the
Microsoft site and look. While some feel that this is an inappropriate
trademark, until someone wins in court or the USPTO grows a spine, we are
stuck with it.

While I and others will quibble with the exact count and even object to the
vote altogether as premature, I think it is clear that approximately 60% of
those expressing an opinion prefer a pared down slogan. Adding,
subtracting, or moving 5 or so votes won't change the final results. Can we
please just move on to _substantive__discussions__of__freeware_ without 10
more additions and corrections?


Garrett said:
The following are the results of a thread requesting votes on changing
the Pricelessware slogan.

Originally, two slogans were set to be voted on, but a third was cast
in by people wishing to vote on it. I personally have no problem with
this, but I can't say whether this will be acceptable with others.

In this group, not everyone will ever agree 100% on anything.


1. "The best of the best in Windows© Freeware as determined by the
readers of alt.comp.freeware."

14 Votes


2. "The best of the best in Freeware for Windows© (and other OS) as
determined by the readers of alt.comp.freeware."

3 Votes


3. "The best of the best of Freeware as determined by the readers of
alt.comp.freeware"

26 Votes
Click to expand...
<Snip detailed results.>
 
Omar© said:
Err I think 27, see below
<[email protected]>
Where I voted.
Thanks
Omar
Click to expand...

And actually, I would like to change my vote to the third option. This
group was never intended (from what I've read by Googling) to be a
Windows only newsgroup. Also, this would remove the "Windows is a
Registered Trademark" concern from the slogan.

*JMHO*
 
The following are the results of a thread requesting votes on changing
the Pricelessware slogan.

Originally, two slogans were set to be voted on, but a third was cast
in by people wishing to vote on it. I personally have no problem with
this, but I can't say whether this will be acceptable with others.

In this group, not everyone will ever agree 100% on anything.


1. "The best of the best in Windows© Freeware as determined by the
readers of alt.comp.freeware."

14 Votes


2. "The best of the best in Freeware for Windows© (and other OS) as
determined by the readers of alt.comp.freeware."

3 Votes


3. "The best of the best of Freeware as determined by the readers of
alt.comp.freeware"

26 Votes
Click to expand...

Wow ..... less than 50 votes. And around 200-300 posts per day in this
group. Shows how much interest there really is in all the POLITICS that
goes on here. I hope this is a truely democratic site and that the
MAJORITY aren't ruled by a MINORITY.
 
Reg said:
Wow ..... less than 50 votes. And around 200-300 posts per day in this
group. Shows how much interest there really is in all the POLITICS that
goes on here. I hope this is a truely democratic site and that the
MAJORITY aren't ruled by a MINORITY.
Click to expand...

But of course, lots of people in this group post more than one message
a day.
 
Reg said:
Wow ..... less than 50 votes. And around 200-300 posts per day in this
group. Shows how much interest there really is in all the POLITICS
that goes on here. I hope this is a truely democratic site and that
the MAJORITY aren't ruled by a MINORITY.
Click to expand...

Voting in an unmoderated group seems a bit strange to me, like voting in a
anarchy. But on the other hand there doesn't seem a better way to solve
issues for the side-dishes that come with the meal, at least for the people
that are interested. I guess for a lot of people the appetite has gone after
the battle of the menus.

Rod
 
John said:
But of course, lots of people in this group post more than one message
a day.
Click to expand...

Header-statistics for: From:
(based on msgs with bodies within last 10 days)

alt.comp.freeware

2154 100.00% (probe count)

62 2.88% Susan Bugher <[email protected]>
43 2.00% jo <[email protected]>
42 1.95% John Corliss <[email protected]#>
31 1.44% MLC <[email protected]>
30 1.39% "Steven Burn" <[email protected]>
28 1.30% "PuppyKatt" <[email protected]>
27 1.25% "ArjanDotOrg" <[email protected]>
27 1.25% Mark Carter <[email protected]>
26 1.21% "H.M.A. (Dick) Hazeleger"
<dick@post_it_in_the_newsgroup.invalid>
26 1.21% "MightyKitten" <[email protected]>
25 1.16% Roger Johansson <[email protected]>
24 1.11% Henk de Jong <[email protected]>
24 1.11% J44xm <[email protected]_g>
23 1.07% dszady <[email protected]>
22 1.02% "dadiOH" <[email protected]>
22 1.02% (e-mail address removed) (xtort)
21 0.97% JanC <[email protected]>
19 0.88% "*ProteanThread*" <[email protected]>
19 0.88% "Uncle Buck" <[email protected]>
18 0.84% Vic Dura <[email protected]>
18 0.84% Chrissy Cruiser <[email protected]>
17 0.79% Mark Carter <[email protected]>
17 0.79% (e-mail address removed) (ozzy)
17 0.79% Chaos Master <[email protected]>
17 0.79% (e-mail address removed) (Jonathan Aquino)
16 0.74% Martin DeMello <[email protected]>
15 0.70% Gordon Darling <[email protected]>
15 0.70% 512/udp <biff.mullins @ gmail.com>
15 0.70% bambam <[email protected]>
15 0.70% "Garrett" <[email protected]>
14 0.65% "Rahman" <[email protected]>
14 0.65% "scootgirl.com" <[email protected]>
14 0.65% Vrodok the Troll <[email protected]>
14 0.65% "James" <[email protected]>
13 0.60% "Frank Bohan" <[email protected]>
13 0.60% "Invader Zim" <[email protected]>
13 0.60% 512/udp <[email protected]>
12 0.56% INspire <[email protected]>
12 0.56% POKO <[email protected]>
12 0.56% Nicolaas Hawkins <[email protected]>
12 0.56% (e-mail address removed) (BillR)
12 0.56% Derald <[email protected]>
11 0.51% Bob Adkins <[email protected]>
11 0.51% REM <[email protected]>
11 0.51% Anti_Freak_Machine <[email protected]>
10 0.46% (e-mail address removed) (Achim Nolcken Lohse)
10 0.46% CoMa <[email protected]>
10 0.46% mike ring <[email protected]>
10 0.46% "BillR" <[email protected]>
10 0.46% Aaron <[email protected]>
10 0.46% wald <arnout.standaert@n*o_s-p%a|m.cit.kuleuven.ac.be>
10 0.46% Peter Seiler <[email protected]>
10 0.46% "Phoenix" <[email protected]>
10 0.46% »Q« <[email protected]>
9 0.42% Tom McDonald <[email protected]>
9 0.42% Conor <[email protected]>
9 0.42% (e-mail address removed) (Phred)
9 0.42% bassbag <[email protected]>
9 0.42% Christopher Jahn <[email protected]>
9 0.42% (e-mail address removed) (BillR)
9 0.42% (e-mail address removed)
9 0.42% "ceg" <[email protected]>
8 0.37% "Glenn" <[email protected]>
8 0.37% Semolina Pilchard <[email protected]>
8 0.37% scroob <[email protected]>
8 0.37% "Mister Charlie" <[email protected]>
7 0.32% El Gee <[email protected]>
7 0.32% klagol <[email protected]>
7 0.32% buzz Light Beer <[email protected]>
7 0.32% Cousin Stanley <[email protected]>
7 0.32% burnr <[email protected]>
7 0.32% "Jeff Needle" <[email protected]>
7 0.32% Randy Bard <[email protected]>
7 0.32% DD <[email protected]>
7 0.32% "fjghdhg" <[email protected]>
7 0.32% John Fitzsimons <[email protected]>
7 0.32% "MAMEngineer" <[email protected]>
7 0.32% Wayne D <[email protected]>
6 0.28% "JP Loken" <[email protected]>
6 0.28% "Donald Lessau" <[email protected]>
6 0.28% "kline" <[email protected]>
6 0.28% zektor <[email protected]>
6 0.28% (e-mail address removed) (howard schwartz)
6 0.28% "FYIS.org/estore" <FYIS.org/[email protected]>
6 0.28% "Gary R. Schmidt" <[email protected]>
6 0.28% harsha godavari <[email protected]>
6 0.28% "GRL" <[email protected]>
6 0.28% (e-mail address removed) (mike555)
6 0.28% Duddits <[email protected]>
6 0.28% Onno Tasler <[email protected]>
6 0.28% (e-mail address removed) (Dave Arbok)
6 0.28% "Mark Warner" <[email protected]>
6 0.28% Bill Turner <[email protected]>
6 0.28% Alastair Smeaton <[email protected]>
6 0.28% "Ionizer" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% Anonymous <[email protected]>
5 0.23% derek / nul <[email protected]>
5 0.23% Doc <postmaster@[127.0.0.1]>
5 0.23% "Ed Chait" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% "Dugie" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% JoeA <[email protected]>
5 0.23% jason <[email protected]>
5 0.23% Jack Purvis <[email protected]>
5 0.23% Antoine <[email protected]>
5 0.23% "Ben Cooper" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% "Dancer" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% "norry" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% Reg Edit <RegEdit@[127.0.0.1]>
5 0.23% "sase" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% (e-mail address removed) (Mike Henley)
5 0.23% "Rod" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% "Jim @ UsableFreeware.com" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% Ron May <[email protected]>
5 0.23% "Henry The Mole" <[email protected]>
5 0.23% KeithS <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Franklin <[email protected]>
4 0.19% "PeterH" <reply to (e-mail address removed)>
4 0.19% ALPI <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Eric <[email protected]>
4 0.19% fitwell <[email protected]>
4 0.19% 7palmtree <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Frank Hahn <[email protected]>
4 0.19% "Sweet Andy Licious" <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Frank Selvaggio <fselvaggio@**InsightBB.com>
4 0.19% futureworlds <[email protected]>
4 0.19% "Renato" <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Gabriele Neukam (e-mail address removed)>
4 0.19% (e-mail address removed) (ben)
4 0.19% (e-mail address removed) (Calm n Collected)
4 0.19% Simone Murdock <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Trythat <don'(e-mail address removed)>
4 0.19% Omar© <[email protected]>
4 0.19% BOOGIEMAN <[email protected]>
4 0.19% peter online <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Stan Weiss <[email protected]>
4 0.19% (e-mail address removed) (richk)
4 0.19% rj65 <[email protected]>
4 0.19% (e-mail address removed)
4 0.19% Sue Doo Nym <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Daniel Prince <[email protected]>
4 0.19% "EDEB" <[email protected]>
4 0.19% "A.A. Fussy" <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Scott <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Chakolate <[email protected]>
4 0.19% Wald <arnout.standaert@n-o_s-p-a-m.cit.kuleuven.ac.be>
4 0.19% Dan Rather <[email protected]>
4 0.19% ms <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "dfrog" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% (e-mail address removed) (Eficium.com)
3 0.14% "zmartha" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "FadedGlory" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% J. S. Pack <[email protected]>
3 0.14% ArjanDotOrg <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Dick Kistler" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Jes <[email protected]>
3 0.14% /* frank */ <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Wayne <[email protected]>
3 0.14% (e-mail address removed) (wylbur37)
3 0.14% Vegard Krog Petersen <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Andreas Perfora’tus" (e-mail address removed)>
3 0.14% Fred <knorAThccnetDOTnlANDREMOVETHIS>
3 0.14% Zo <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "~~~MadGal~~~" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Chuck <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Claudiu Spulber" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% 512/udp <insane.tech @ gmail.com>
3 0.14% Frank Delamarre <[email protected]>
3 0.14% SST <[email protected]>
3 0.14% ubab ilagnab <don'(e-mail address removed)>
3 0.14% Alan Ford <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Charles D. Bohne <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Bebop & Rocksteady" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Scotty <[email protected]>
3 0.14% EA <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Bernd Schmitt <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Dewey Edwards <[email protected]>
3 0.14% (e-mail address removed) (nospam256K)
3 0.14% Pedro Martinez <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Baron Of Hell <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Rose Weir" <wdmn@NS hurontel-on.ca>
3 0.14% Podz <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Jupiter Jones [MVP]" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% (e-mail address removed) (matt cook)
3 0.14% Michael Forsythe <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "NoMoreMrNiceGuy" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% (e-mail address removed)
3 0.14% "Peter" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Mike" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "michael andrews" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Mike Andrade <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Moonlit" <news moonlit xs4all nl>
3 0.14% Justin C <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Steveproj" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Some Guy" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% David <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "TINY" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "Fran" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "The Six Million Dollar Man" <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Klaatu <[email protected]>
3 0.14% "John H." <[email protected]>
3 0.14% burris <[email protected]>
3 0.14% default <[email protected]>
3 0.14% Larry Sabo <[email protected]>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed) (Support)
2 0.09% Dave S <[email protected]>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed) (Overself Research)
2 0.09% Deer in the Headlights <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Dan Goodman <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Dreamspinner3 <[email protected]>
2 0.09% D.G. <[email protected]>
2 0.09% DCK <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Roy <[email protected]>
2 0.09% rondkopf nospamrondkopfschnecke@N_O_S_P_A_M_hotmail.com>
2 0.09% rm <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Scotty <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Scott <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Sagittaria <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Riggs <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Paul Blarmy <[email protected]>
2 0.09% ovationfan88 <[email protected]>
2 0.09% optikl <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Rick O <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Rick Blackthorn <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Plankje <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Walt <[email protected]>
2 0.09% VH <>
2 0.09% uncle zero <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Zo <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Zenobia <[email protected]>
2 0.09% xmp <[email protected]>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed)
2 0.09% Shane <[email protected]>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed) (Semi Head)
2 0.09% seabat <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Tramp <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Suzanne <[email protected]>
2 0.09% sno <[email protected]>
2 0.09% JW <[email protected]>
2 0.09% john p. <[email protected]>
2 0.09% John Latter <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Larry Sabo <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Kurt <[email protected]>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed) (Google's friend)
2 0.09% Jan <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Helium <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Harvey Van Sickle <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Fuzzy Logic <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Hubert Taler <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Henry K <abuse@[127.0.0.1]>
2 0.09% Hello <[email protected]>
2 0.09% n e a d <[email protected]>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed) (Moozer)
2 0.09% Morgan <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Onno Voors <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Norman Cohen <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Night2000 <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Martin P Matthews <[email protected]>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed) (J Lee)
2 0.09% Livewire <[email protected]>
2 0.09% litefoot <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Martin Cleaver <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Marko <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Mario Alvares <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "ubaB ilagnaB" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Heather" <scotgirlREMOVE@SPAMMERS BEWAREo2.co.uk>
2 0.09% "Veign" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "vanrinsg" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Thump" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Stuart" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "James A. Smith" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "tgilb" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Jackson" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Fr@nk" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Bill Jones" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Bill Rucker" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed) (tednat)
2 0.09% Anonymous via the Cypherpunks Tonga Remailer
(e-mail address removed)>
2 0.09% Anne Carle <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Dick Kistler" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Fontzie" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Daze N. Knights" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "DH" <[email protected](axe the x's)>
2 0.09% "spoon2001" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "LPV" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "(e-mail address removed)" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Klaus Meinhard" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "LOA" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "MAMEngineer" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Michael Rainey" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Martin Roth" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Marc" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Mark R. Blain" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Papageno" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "John Rampling" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "JunkMonkey" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "So It's Come To This?" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "seaside" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Rolf Barbakken" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Kevin Moore" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "privacy.at Anonymous Remailer"
(e-mail address removed)>
2 0.09% "k" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "RemzyJ" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Bart van der Wolf" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% cathair <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Atomhrt <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Buzzy <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Allen" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "BEN RITCHEY" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "AAH" <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "B. R. 'BeAr' Ederson"
(e-mail address removed)>
2 0.09% (e-mail address removed) (Charles Jones)
2 0.09% Clive Savage <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Ash <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Bjorn Simonsen <[email protected]>
2 0.09% Bill Yerkes <[email protected]>
2 0.09% "Andy100" <[email protected]>
243 11.28% (others)
 
Rod said:
Voting in an unmoderated group seems a bit strange to me, like voting
in a anarchy.
Click to expand...

The voting is about the Pricelessware list, not about this newsgroup.

People can participate in this newsgroup and ignore everything connected to the pricelessware list.
Some of the participators in acf are involved in the creation of the PL list, others are just participating in the newsgroup.

One single faq for this newsgroup is not good, because it can be used by people who want to control the newsgroup.
Several different faqs are better, no faq at all is probably the best.
 
This group was never intended (from what I've read by Googling) to
be a Windows only newsgroup.
Click to expand...

That's true, but the PL was intended to be for Windows freeware.
Also, this would remove the "Windows is a Registered Trademark"
concern from the slogan.
Click to expand...

That was not a problem; if it had remained in the slogan, it just
needed to be marked with the 'registered trademark' symbol rather than
the 'copyrighted' one.
 
»Q« said:
That's true, but the PL was intended to be for Windows freeware.




That was not a problem; if it had remained in the slogan, it just
needed to be marked with the 'registered trademark' symbol rather than
the 'copyrighted' one.
Click to expand...

Good points.

I still wish that there were separate freeware groups designated by
OS. For instance, alt.comp.freeware.windows.
 
I still wish that there were separate freeware groups designated
by OS. For instance, alt.comp.freeware.windows.
Click to expand...

You could run it through alt.config -- it's never too late. ;)

But I don't think people would stop using alt.comp.freeware for
OS-specific freeware, so Windows users would wind up with at least
two groups to monitor. Also, with the rise of open source software,
there have come a lot of cross-platform freeware apps, and I think
if there were multiple groups, they would become a maze of
crossposting.
 
Garrett said:
Omar© wrote:
Click to expand...
From: =?iso-8859-1?Q?Omar=A9?= <[email protected]>
Click to expand...
Is that not you there? If so, then it's still 26. doesn't make much
of a difference anyway. I think it's pretty obvious. ;-)

-Garrett
Click to expand...

I agree. Your count was 14-3-26 (43 total). My informal count is 18-4-29
(51 total).

In accordance with the results of the vote the Pricelessware List at
http://www.pricelesswarehome.org will display this slogan:

The best of the best in Freeware as determined by the readers of
alt.comp.freeware.

-----------

FWIW this is my informal summary of the voting:

Votes were cast in 3 threads:

PL: Change the PL Slogan or Not - Vote Here
Change the PL Slogan or Not - Vote Here
Simplifying Pricelessware Slogan Vote

---------

Votes were cast for 3 choices (ignoring copyright symbols and other
minor variations):

A. (18) "The best of the best in Windows Freeware as
determined by the readers of alt.comp.freeware."

B. (4) "The best of the best in Freeware for Windows
(and other OS) as determined by the readers of alt.comp.freeware."

C. (29) "The best of the best in Freeware as determined by the readers
of alt.comp.freeware."

Total (51) voters

------------

Voters are listed alphabetically
Voter's names that were not on Garrett's list are preceded by ***

A. Freeware for Windows
1 »Q« <[email protected]>
2 ***Aaron <[email protected]>
3 badgolferman <[email protected]>
4 ***BillR <[email protected]>
5 Eric <[email protected]>
6 Garrett <[email protected]>
7 GoodTime Barnie <[email protected]>
8 Iain Cheyne <[email protected]>
9 Jack D. Russell, Sr." <"jackru$$ell2"@notmail.com>
10 John Corliss <[email protected]#>
11 Klaatu <[email protected]>
12 Nicolaas Hawkins <[email protected]>
13 norry <[email protected]>
14 Peggy <[email protected]>
15 Phil <[email protected]>
16 ***ranrad <[email protected]>
17 Susan <[email protected]>
18 ***Tramp <[email protected]>

B. Freeware for Windows (and other OS)
1 Dan Goodman <[email protected]>
2 Roger Johansson <[email protected]>
3 (e-mail address removed)
4 ***REM <[email protected]>

C. Freeware
1 bambam <[email protected]>
2 burnr <[email protected]>
3 Buzzy <[email protected]>
4 Colin <[email protected]>
5 (e-mail address removed)
6 (e-mail address removed)
7 dszady <[email protected]>
8 FadedGlory <[email protected]>
9 H.M.A. (Dick)Hazeleger<dick@post_it_in_the_newsgroup.invalid>
10 Harvey Van Sickle <[email protected]>
11 Henk de Jong <[email protected]>
12 ***J44xm <[email protected]_g>
13 Jaime Littlebeaver <[email protected]>
14 James <[email protected]>
15 Jim Daniel <[email protected]>
16 (e-mail address removed)
17 LPV <[email protected]>
18 Marko <[email protected]>
19 miskairal<[email protected]>
20 ***Mister Charlie <[email protected]>
21 MLC <[email protected]>
22 ***Night2000 <[email protected]>
23 OhnO the Clown <[email protected]>
24 Omar© <[email protected]>
25 Soren Hedeby Sorensen <[email protected]>
26 Susan Bugher <[email protected]>
27 Trevor Frew <[email protected]>
28 ubaB ilagnaB <[email protected]>
29 wald <arnout.standaert@n*o_s-p%a|m.cit.kuleuven.ac.be>
 
»Q« said:
You could run it through alt.config -- it's never too late. ;)
Click to expand...

Well, actually it is probably too late for the very reasons you list
below. Had the arrangement been mulitiple OS specific groups from the
beginning, then a different method of posting would have evolved.
But I don't think people would stop using alt.comp.freeware for
OS-specific freeware, so Windows users would wind up with at least
two groups to monitor.
Click to expand...

Heh. Harley riders have three groups to monitor
(alt.motorcycles.harley, rec.motorcycle.harley and
alt.binaries.pictures.motorcycles.harley) and nobody complains. That's
simply the way it's been for a long time, so they've gotten past it.
Also, with the rise of open source software,
there have come a lot of cross-platform freeware apps, and I think
if there were multiple groups, they would become a maze of
crossposting.
Click to expand...

Perhaps then, "alt.comp.freeware.opensource". But at any rate, things
are the way they are now and it's probably too late to change them.

They did consider multiple groups originally. Here's a shortlink to
the alt.config discussion back in '95:

http://makeashorterlink.com/?P24151039

I notice that Timo Salmi was involved with ACF from the start.
 
Wow ..... less than 50 votes. And around 200-300 posts per day in this
group. Shows how much interest there really is in all the POLITICS that
goes on here. I hope this is a truely democratic site and that the
MAJORITY aren't ruled by a MINORITY.
Click to expand...

Actually I did vote for option 1, but my vote seems to be missing. Or
perhaps they recalled the vote and did another one on another thread which
i seem to recall seeing they were considering to do. Oh well, never was
interested in that much politics lol.
 
Back
Top