Lorena and Inquisition--
Norton from 2005 back through 2003 can be made compatible with SP2. I
tested it many times, installing and uninstalling SP2 and Norton versions.
But the way Norton has chosen to make an update patch available for XP SP2
via only Norton Live Update is consumately stupid--and Norton has done its
best to weasle to people that anything they have older than a 2004 version
is "obsolete" to use their choice of words when they run an "analysis" on
their site. A lot of people at their Cupertino, California Springfield,
Orgegon, and Newport News, Virginia offices must be running around with long
noses like the Disney character Pinocchio.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0736412131/002-0098820-7412843?v=glance
First I'd run Norton Live Update to get the Norton WMI update for SP2
installed so Norton firewall, NIS, NSW, or NAV will be compatible with SP2.
service.symantec.com/xpinfo
http://www.symantec.com/techsupp/sp2/faq.html?src=ivr_na_con
Then I'd run just one software firewall, and Norton's firewall may have more
capability than the Windows Firewall in SP2 depending on the version.
Norton will say things like you are obsolete if you don't have 2004 or that
its patch won't allow the Windows Security Center to recognize any version
older than 2002. They want to sell their 2005 versions that will be
released soon. The last box on a Norton 2005 product tells you to turn off
the Windows Firewall if you are running NPF, NIS, or the small piece of code
that Norton is putting in NAV 2005 as "a worm blocker" from their firewall.
In the first place the Windows Security Center does very little but tells
you your firewall is on and your AV is on. Hardly anyone needs it for that.
It also links you to technet or a MS security page, but your browser will do
that as well:
http://www.microsoft.com/technet/default.mspx
As far as holes, there are many many more in Windows XP RTM (out of the
box) and Windows XP SP1 out of the box. That's one of the driving reasons
for SP2.
As far as Norton compatibility, I tested from 2005 back through 2003 and
they all can work with SP2. There are two common incompatibility issues I
noticed without the WMI patch--Live Update which you don't really need
except that Norton refuses npow to deliver the SP2 patch any other way
(which is dumb of them--they are trying to twist your arm to buy a new
version)--but Beta sites are making it available if you search around, and
that Norton's/Symantec's Integrator or status screen that it puts up can
freeze and the two Norton KBs that fix that some of the time are:
Error: "LU1812: An update failed to install. A program that was part of this
update failed when it ran. This update was not applied."
http://service1.symantec.com/SUPPOR...e=english&module=LU&error=1812&build=Symantec
and this one that applies to any version (Norton has the awkward little
habit of only making a KB available for one version or year that will work
on others, but MSFT has been known to do that with MSKBs as well but not
nearly as often)
Error: "Norton Integrator could not initialize the current frame class . . .
" when opening Norton SystemWorks
http://service1.symantec.com/SUPPOR...882568040070e925?OpenDocument&src=bar_sch_nam
System Status screen displays "Refreshing" after opening Norton AntiVirus
2003
http://service1.symantec.com/SUPPOR...65256c4f000db6b7?OpenDocument&src=bar_sch_nam
For help with Windows Update or another way to download SP2 but it's larger:
What's New on Windows Update
http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/sp2/whatsnewforwu.mspx
How To Get Windows XP SP2
http://www.microsoft.com/athome/security/protect/windowsxp/choose.aspx
If Live Update is giving you too many problems, I'd just go on and get the
Network download here if you have broadband:
http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/...BE-3B8E-4F30-8245-9E368D3CDB5A&displaylang=en
I should note that many other antivirus and software firewall products are
not having SP2 incompatibilities at all, and they are not trying to make it
more difficult to get their updates by only delivering them in a way (Live
Update) that you may not be able to use once you download SP2 unless you get
the WMI from a source other than Symantec. This has caused a number of
people to opt to switch from Norton or Symantec whether they have home,
small business or enterprise accounts.
If there were no Windows Operating System, than Norton and Symantec would
dry up quickly. They do make Norton and Symantec for Apple Mac products,
but those don't have a lot of the world market percentage wise. As it is
now, they are looking over their big lumbering shoulders, because Microsoft
Antivirus is already starting to manufacture its prodcut.
Details of Microsoft antivirus software leak out (CNET News)
http://news.com.com/Details+of+Micr...eak+out/2100-7349_3-5287496.html?tag=nefd.top
Best,
Chad Harris
________________________________________
I have Automatic Updates turned ON, it is set for 03:00. My computer is
never on at this time of night. I still have not received the SP2 download,
but twice today I have received a Norton Alert High Risk ''A remote system
is
trying to access your computer'' Block [recommended] click OK. I have
never seen that alert before, and was wondering if this was Windows trying
to
send the update, but Norton is blocking it. My Norton Firewall is set to
customized default of High: Block everything until you allow it. Would it
be that at 03:00 Norton would allow Windows to access for auto updates but
not at any other time, so is blocking it from coming through during the day
??
Should I switch off my Norton Firewall for the time being and just use the
Windows Firewall [which is off as it conflicts with Norton]. ?
Thanks for any help.