:: No Power?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guest
  • Start date Start date
G

Guest

Uh oh.
I'm on the laptop now, because the desktop won't turn on. It was working
fine, then a piece of ice from our winter weather jiggled the electrical
lines. The house-lights flickered and the computer quit. All the
peripherals and all the house lights are working fine. I cannot get the
desktop computer to turn on. No indicator lights, either. Yes, everything
was plugged into a surge protector.

Is there some kind of a power connector inside the computer itself that may
have gone out? Or have I lost my motherboard? How do I figure out what's
broken and how to fix it?

Thanks.
 
open the case, turn the pc on, does any fan start turning? if not it's the
power supply, if it does then you fried something on the MB.
When I say any fan I also mean the fan on the powersupply.
 
No. The fan does not start running.
So I need to order a new power supply?
Are there two fans? One on the power supply and another somewhere else?
What should I order?
 
Lots of fans. Keep in mind that this desktop ATX case was put together in
2001. So however many fans would have been used then.

I've been looking at power supplies at NewEgg -- they range from $11 to $22.
Some have two fans, some one. Some fans are 80 mm and some are 120. Some
advertise ball bearings, others say "low noise, low ripple, super quiet"
etc. Most says 20+4 pin, and a couple say 24 pin. A few are "top mount."

This is an ordinary desktop--no gaming or video. Does it matter much what
kind of a power supply I buy?

<*(((><
 
Lots of fans. Keep in mind that this desktop ATX case was put together in
2001. So however many fans would have been used then.

I've been looking at power supplies at NewEgg -- they range from $11 to
$22. Some have two fans, some one. Some fans are 80 mm and some are 120.
Some advertise ball bearings, others say "low noise, low ripple, super
quiet" etc. Most says 20+4 pin, and a couple say 24 pin. A few are "top
mount."

This is an ordinary desktop--no gaming or video. Does it matter much what
kind of a power supply I buy?

<*(((><


<*(((etc. etc...
Well, before you start going out buying a power supply (PSU), let's discuss
your situation for a moment, OK?

While it *could* be a defective PSU that's the culprit re your problem,
there's a strong possibility that it's not. Power surges ordinarily do not
take out one's PSU, although it *is* a possibility.

As a general proposition the more likely "culprit" is a blown motherboard.
That component usually bears the brunt of a power surge.

Obviously as an end-user you have a problem diagnosing the cause of your
problem (let alone a decision as to how to remedy the situation given that
you're dealing with a very old PC measured in "computer time" of course).

The most accurate way for you to determine if the problem results from a
defective PSU is to substitute a known good one for the present one.
Obviously that's not available to you since I take it you would have to
purchase a new PSU to do so.

Another diagnostic tool is a power tester but I guess you don't have that
device available either. They cost about $15 to $20 (incl. shipping) from
the online vendors, but not much cheaper than the cost of the PSU's you
mentioned in your last post. Those cheapo PSUs that you quoted can be quite
unreliable but on the other hand we've encountered some that surprisingly
worked reliably for many years. But it's a crapshoot at best and I really
can't give you any recommendation since those inexpensive PSUs seem to be
continuously manufactured by different sources. In any event I don't imagine
you would like to spend a fair amount of money for a higher-end PSU given
the age of your PC (unless, of course, you're planning to build a more
"modern" machine in the near future).

Anyway, I have my doubts as to whether the PSU is the cause of your problem
although *again* it's quite possible. If you do conclude it's a defective
PSU and you decide to purchase a new PSU, keep in mind that your PC has a
20-pin power connector - not the newer 24-pin connectors. (I'm assuming your
motherboard dates back to 2001, right?). Most PSUs will be compatible with
either type connector since an adapter device of one sort or another is
generally available with the PSU. But keep this in mind.

I'm still leaning toward a blown motherboard as the cause of your problem.
Have you been able to visually inspect the motherboard? Any indications of
blackened components there? If so, that would be just about definitive it's
the motherboard. Absent that, again the only way for you to determine if it
is the motherboard is (once again) via the substitution route. Needless to
say that becomes difficult, if not impossible, for most users.

It could even be your processor, what is generally known as the CPU.
Doubtful, but possible.

Or even a combination of defective components.

While you could have a computer shop look it over, I really think the costs
involved there (diagnosis & possible repair) just would be too much to bear
given this is a 8-year-old machine.

I realize I probably haven't been too helpful to you but this is a
difficult situation given the age of your machine and the limited ways you
can diagnose the problem let alone correct it. Just think hard & long before
you go out purchasing this or that component. I see brand-new off-the-shelf
desktop PCs selling in the mass-merchandise stores in the $300 to $400
range. Needless to say their performance will be substantially better than
your present machine (even if you have to swallow Vista). And since you
already have a monitor & printer (right?), it's something to think about,
no?
Anna
 
Uh oh.
I'm on the laptop now, because the desktop won't turn on. It was working
fine, then a piece of ice from our winter weather jiggled the electrical
lines. The house-lights flickered and the computer quit. All the
peripherals and all the house lights are working fine. I cannot get the
desktop computer to turn on. No indicator lights, either. Yes,
everything was plugged into a surge protector.

Is there some kind of a power connector inside the computer itself that
may have gone out? Or have I lost my motherboard? How do I figure out
what's broken and how to fix it?

Thanks.

Look at the obvious first. Does the computer work when plugged into the
working wall outlet without the surge protector? Surge protectors are
designed to stop surges into a device. Some give their lives in order to
protect the ones they "love."
 
Lots of fans. Keep in mind that this desktop ATX case was put together in
2001. So however many fans would have been used then.

I've been looking at power supplies at NewEgg -- they range from $11 to $22.
Some have two fans, some one. Some fans are 80 mm and some are 120. Some
advertise ball bearings, others say "low noise, low ripple, super quiet"
etc. Most says 20+4 pin, and a couple say 24 pin. A few are "top mount."

This is an ordinary desktop--no gaming or video. Does it matter much what
kind of a power supply I buy?

<*(((><

The side of the power supply will have a label on it. You want
a supply that matches or exceeds the characteristics. Speaking
in very general terms (without going into what each number means,
and they *are* important), you'd want a 350W or greater supply,
to replace the broken 350W supply.

Buying an $11 to $22 supply is a mistake. Those are "bargoon"
supplies. Read the reviewer comments on Newegg, to see how
many were dead on arrival, how many blew when used, and how long
they last. I remember one bright guy, who bought four of the
same cheap supply sequentially (first one blows, buys a second,
that blows, buys a third...) and never clued into the fact that
he ended up paying a fortune for his supply.

My last replacement supply cost me about $60, runs cool and
behaves well. It is made by Enermax. Even they aren't perfect,
but chances are the supply I got, will last longer than the
$11 one.

To test a supply, you can try this.

1) Disconnect the supply from the computer. We don't know
what defect it has. You didn't say what brand of computer it
is, and you could have an Emachine with a 250W Bestec supply in it.
Those tend to blow, and take out the motherboard when they go.
Many other supplies have defensive circuitry of one sort or
another, reducing to some extent, the odds of that happening.
It is still possible, for the world's best designed supply,
to be damaged by a lightning strike, so there are limits to
what they can defend against.

2) Ideally, you want to place some load on the supply. Some older
supplies, might need a small load to help them maintain regulation.
The ATX supply is not a push pull design - it likes to source
current, but cannot sink current if the voltage rises too high.
I personally haven't had any trouble here with that, and the
supplies I've tried generally seemed to work OK without a load
on them. (Some supplies cheat, and have a dynamic load circuit in
them, that switches on when no external load is present.) I also
have a load box, which draws 100W total or so, distributed over
all the output rails (each rail gets a load resistor, and the
-12V rail has a 50 ohm load and so on). When I buy a new supply,
I leave it simmering with the load box on it for two hours, just
to make sure it isn't a dud. I check the voltages delivered
with a multimeter.

3) So ignoring (2) in the interest of time, you connect PS_ON# to
COM. PS_ON# is usually a green wire, while COM, also known as
ground, is a black wire. When PS_ON# is connected to COM, that
causes the power supply to soft start. The cooling fan should
then start to spin on the supply. See the wiring table with colors
and pin numbers, in these docs. First doc is for 20 pin supplies,
second is for 24 pin supplies.

http://www.formfactors.org/developer/specs/atx/ATX12V_1_3dg.pdf (page 30)

http://www.formfactors.org/developer/specs/ATX12V_PSDG_2_2_public_br2.pdf (page 37)

4) If you had a multimeter, you could measure the voltages on
the main power harness, while the PSU is running with the PS_ON#
pin connected to one of the adjacent COM pins.

A similar technique can be used, to turn on a computer which fails
to assert PS_ON#. The motherboard normally grounds PS_ON# when it
wants the PSU to run. You can safely connect PS_ON# to COM,
with the main connector plugged into the motherboard (shorting the
motherboard driver won't hurt it, because it is supposed to be
open collector). But what that also does, is override motherboard
safety features. For example, if the motherboard detects a problem
(like CPU overheat), it needs to be able to turn off the PS_ON# signal.
If you still have your shorting wire present, the power stays on and
the CPU eventually gets cooked. So while the "paper clip trick" can be
used to solve a situation where the PS_ON# driver on the motherboard
is broken, there can be resulting collateral damage if something
else goes wrong.

In terms of 20 pin versus 20+4 pin supplies, the 20+4 pin main
connector has a hinged section which can be removed. For example,
oh my new Enermax, I have the +4 pin section disconnected from
the main connector, since the motherboard is a 20 pinner. There
are a very few 24 pin power supplies, where they neglected to
hinge the four pins on one end, and for those, you can still
plug the connector in, as long as no tall components are in the
way. Pin 1 of the 24 pin, goes to Pin 1 of the 20 pin motherboard
connector. The four "left over pins" would hang over one
end. If they're the hinged type, they can be removed.

The extra four pins don't introduce any new voltages, and are
only present to carry extra current if needed. The most typical
situation where the extra pins are needed, is on computers which
have two PCI Express video cards installed. For most other situations,
the extra pins are not needed.

You can see a picture of the "paper clip trick" here. PSU plugged
into the wall, and switched on at the back, then the paper clip
stays in position for as long as you want it to stay on. It looks
like they connected pin 14 (PS_ON#) to pin 16 (COM). There are four
black COM wires in the vicinity. The green wire is on the side
with the plastic latch.

http://www.chirio.com/IMAGES/atx_012_ps_on.jpg

HTH,
Paul
 
I'm on the laptop now, because the desktop won't turn on. It was working
fine, then a piece of ice from our winter weather jiggled the electrical
lines. The house-lights flickered and thecomputerquit. All the
peripherals and all the house lights are working fine.

Posts from Anna and Paul are your useful replies. Others said, it
could be this or could be that or could be the other thing ... so
replace the power supply. That is how the naive fix things.

In but 30 seconds with a multimeter (a tool so complex as to be sold
in Kmart and in stores where hammers are sold), your question is
quickly answered OR numbers result in useful replies from the few who
actually know this stuff.

Anna is right. Your failure could be most any part. However, a
power supply tester, that costs as much as the multimeter, 1) has no
other purpose, and 2) will not provide numbers so that the better
informed can provide answers. Better is to spend about same for a
multimeter.

Paul is also correct about power supply prices. Let's see. How
many other electronics devices also failed? Furnace, dishwasher,
microwave oven, clock radios? A cheap power supply (missing essential
functions) could fail or could contribute to motherboard failure.
All those other electronics devices did not fail - had a sufficient
power supply? Good reasons why responsible manufacturers use
supplies that costs $60 full retail - not $20 power supplies. Those
$20 supplies are marketed to computer assemblers who don't have basic
electrical knowledge.

Using the meter. Set multimeter to 20 VDC range. Connect black
wire to metal chassis. Measure (with red lead) the green, gray and
purple wires (from power supply to motherboard) both before and when
power switch is pressed. Record those numbers and report them here to
understand what you have AND learn how simple the suspect is
identified. Also measure voltages on any one of orange, yellow, and
red wires after power switch is pressed. Those last three wires will
probably report zero. But to get a useful reply, that information is
also provided. Don't short your help of facts and numbers.

First and foremost, you should see 4.87 volts or higher on the
purple wire. If not, disconnect the AC power plug, disconnect the
power supply connector from motherboard, restore AC power plug, and
measure that purple wire again. If voltage is still too low, then
power supply is defective. One example of finding a problem before
fixing anything. Get the meter - that is even sold in Wal-mart and
Lowes for about the same price as a power supply tester.
 
Just so other people that read this post aren't sent astray, this is
entirely incorrect. If the PC has no power at all it does not mean it's the
power supply with 100% certainty, a fried motherboard can also do this
(along with RAM, PCI cards, etc.). Same goes for your second "suggestions",
just because the fans spin up does NOT mean the power supply is good, nor
does it mean the motherboard is bad.
 
Yep, but I shot the crow because he
was making too much noise ;-)

As for the real problem as Anna and others
have indicated it could be any number of one
or more things. When my server power supply died
and took the motherboard and CPU with it.
 
To everybody who responded:

Lots of helpful information for me!
The snow is falling harder and I'm stuck in the house and Christmas is
coming and .... I won't have a chance to work on my desktop NO POWER problem
for at least a week.
I'll keep the responses and reply back next week.

Merry Christmas!
 
Everyone: ever heard of a 'crowbar' circuit?

Crowbar circuit has been standard in power supplies long before PC
even existed. It is one reason why a power supply can never damage a
motherboard. (Other functions explain why a motherboard must never
harm a power supply).

However, since so many computer assemblers have no electrical
knowledge, then a market is ripe for power supplies missing long
standard functions. A computer assemlber selecting a power supply
only on dollars and watts may then install a power supply that takes
out a motherboard and CPU. Crowbar is one reason why this must never
happen.
 
Hey everybody-- Great News!

I tried this suggestion first, because it was the easiest. ;-) It worked! My
desktop computer is back up and running. You folks are fantastic.

What's a Crowbar Circuit? Is that what was broken and did i/O fix it?

<*(((><
Fishy Lives!
 
JS -- I read that article -- but I still don't understand what a crowbar circuit is. I'm
afraid it was too technical for me. Apparently my desktop computer has a crowbar circuit.
Is it inside the power supply, then? Does that mean it's a good quality power supply?

If anybody can figure out how to explain crowbar circuit in simple English, I'd be
appreciative.

<*(((><
Fishy Lives!
 
Fishy said:
JS -- I read that article -- but I still don't understand what a crowbar circuit is. I'm
afraid it was too technical for me. Apparently my desktop computer has a crowbar circuit.
Is it inside the power supply, then? Does that mean it's a good quality power supply?

If anybody can figure out how to explain crowbar circuit in simple English, I'd be
appreciative.

<*(((><
Fishy Lives!

We can make up an example. Say your power supply has a 5V output. The
power supply monitors it. Now say something happens, and the voltage
rises to 6V. This isn't good for the computer. It expects the power
to vary by no more than 5%. So the power supply connects an artificial
internal load to the circuit. The load draws a lot of current. The power
supply has a limited output power capability. What happens then, is the
power supply detects it has an overcurrent problem, and shuts off the
switching transistors on the primary side. Now, there is no energy headed
towards the output. And the artificial load is still present, drawing
current, in case the actual source of the power lifting the 5V rail,
happens to be outside the computer. That artificial load is a "crowbar",
and only works as long as it doesn't burn out. (I built one once,
and it blew the first time I tested it :-) Very impressive.
I used an SCR and it was destroyed.)

The power supply remains "strangled" like that, until the main
power switch is turned off and on again. Turning off the power
supply, removes a low power "supervisor voltage", which the
monitoring circuitry is using. Whenever a fault happens in
the supply, they would seek to "latch" or store the fact
that the supply detected a problem, so it doesn't attempt
to start over and over again. If it was allowed to start
over and over again, it could fry something inside the
computer.

I guess my problem is, I didn't bother to suggest turning
the switch on the back of the computer from On to Off to On
again. That would be a natural first reaction to a problem,
but it never occurred to me to suggest it.

Same as checking the power cord, to make sure it is
firmly in place on the back of the power supply. There
have been several people with funny symptoms, where
reseating the cable on the back of the computer,
fixed it.

There are some computers, without a switch on the back
of them, and for those ones, you'd unplug them and
replug them in. That does the same thing as using
the switch on the back, and clears the latched fault.

If you have symptoms that suggest the power supply is damaged,
then following the above advice is a Bad Thing. For example,
if there is a strong burned smell coming from the computer,
then attempting to start it again is a bad thing to do.
I've run into the odd genius, who when faced with a computer
that protected itself, tried fifty times to start it again,
until it eventually did and it died. If the computer is
protecting itself because of an internal fault, the
protection circuits don't necessarily last forever,
or catch every fault. So if you "hammer" the power switch,
or make an ass of yourself, it can cost you $$$.

Paul
 
JS -- I read that article -- but I still don't understand what a crowbar circuit is.  I'm
afraid it was too technical for me.  

From Wikipedia:
A crowbar ... is an electrical circuit used to prevent an overvoltage
condition of a power supply unit from damaging the circuits
attached to the power supply. It operates by putting a short circuit
or low resistance path across the voltage source ...

What is so difficult? If a voltage is too high, its wires are
shorted together. Therefore no voltage exists and no damage results.
Paul describes this is further detail and with numbers.

All power supplies should have crowbar circuits. Its existance -
overvoltage protection - would be noted in the supply's technical
specs that are provided with any minimally sufficient supply.

A supply without overvoltage protection is typical of supplies
marketed to A+ Certified computer techs who need no electrical
konwledge to become certified.
 
Think of a crowbar in terms of a "circuit breaker" in your house.
The circuit breaker in your house "Trips" to the off position is you are
drawing too much current and the room goes dark.
A crowbar "Trips" when the DC voltage to PC is too high, the PC goes dark.
 
Think of a crowbar in terms of a "circuit breaker" in your house.
The circuit breaker in your house "Trips" to the off position is you are
drawing too much current and the room goes dark.
A crowbar "Trips" when the DC voltage to PC is too high, the PC goes dark..

But a circuit breaker does just the opposite. A current breaker is
for excessive current - not excessive voltage. And a circuit breaker
does not short - it opens. The two protection devices - circuit
breaker and crowbar - work differently - only share a common theme -
protection.

Think of a switch that closes (not opens) when voltage (not current)
gets too high. Whereas a circuit breaker opens, a crowbar closes.
Close (short wires together) means increased current and no
overvoltage. Think of a crowbar as flood gates on a dam that open if
reservoir levels gets too high, then never closes again until the
reservoir is completely empty.
It operates by putting a short circuit or low
resistance path across the voltage source ...
.... thereby emptying the reservoir.
 
Back
Top