Networking problems

  • Thread starter Thread starter Opusita
  • Start date Start date
O

Opusita

Hello,

I have 2 relatively new computers, both running Windows XP (SP1). Computer A
is a Pent 4, 2.53 Ghz with 1GB RAM, Computer B is a Celeon 2.7 Ghz with 512
mb RAM. Using the onboard LAN 10/100 on each.

The problem is that I cannot get them to network with each other. No other
computers involved........just a 2 machine network. When I go through the
PING procedure each machine is successful unto itself but between machines
there are always dropped packets.......sometimes 1, sometimes 2, sometimes
3, and sometimes 4. In any case it's never consistent except that I can't
complete the network.

Any suggestions will be appreciated.

Marian
 
This one has been beat to death by most everyone with XP it seems.

1. Make sure that you disable the XP firewall on each system if enabled.
It will allow "pings" but not much else.
2. Are you using fix IP's or DHCP from a router ?? are they correct ??
3. Do you have a "real firewall" software program on your systems
(Norton, or such)?
if so set up both of the systems to "TRUST" the other ones ip
address.
4. Ensure that you have enabled file / print sharing on both.
5. Ensure that you have shared a disk or file folder on each system.

6. If your on the internet DSL or dialup you will want to make sure that
you get a
"software" firewall that you can configure to allow your local
system to see each other


reply only to the group as my e-mail is not..

Supertech
 
Supertech,

Boy are you right.....this one sure has been beat to death....but it keeps
coming back. I'm not a techspert but I'm not a novice either and it
shouldn't be this difficult.....there must be a tree in here somewhere.

In response to your suggestions:
1. XP firewalls disabled
2. No router
3. "Real firewalls" disabled
4. Enabled file/printsharing on both
5. designated a shared folder on both
6. No softwear firewalls installed

What's else can I try?

Marian
 
Hello Again,

1. Your IP address ? 192.168.1.100 ,, 192.168.1.101 , fixed ip's ?
net mask ok ? 255.255.255.0
1a. if not sure just click , start , run , (type in) cmd.exe , gets
"DOS" window,
type in, ipconfig , it will tell you everything.

2. How are the two boxes connected ? Hub ? , Switch? , cross-over
cable(hope not).

3. Both of your cables good. . I have a pile of bad ends where just one
wire
will kill traffic but pass a short ping.

4. Allow several minutes after the systems are up I have two boxes here
that
when they are first booted up it takes up to 5 minutes for them to
"discover"
each other.

5. Your right it should not be this hard. My kid had his working before
I got mine figured out. I missed my own software firewall set up even
after
looking at it several times.

Regards,
Supertech
 
Hello Again,

You can buy a "hub" for cheap. Found one here. But if you plan on
highspeed DSL or
cable down the road the $40 for a LinkSys 4 port router is a good
product.


http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00000J4M9/104-8220876-9274305?v=glance

Amazon seems to do everything. You may be able to find one locally at a
"used" computer store or a local CompUSA or BestBuy or whatever is near
by.
Lots of these were 10mb but it would work for testing. (check with your
friends
or network folks in your office if they have one that could be borrowed
over night)

Your PATCH cable MUST BE a "cross-over" for your direct connection PC -
PC
It can NOT be a straight cat-5 cable.
To support this direct connection I believe your network cards (nic's)
must support full-duplex. That is, be able to both transmit and receive
at the same time.
Check your system specs.

Later

Supertech
 
Good Morning Supertech,

Right, I meant cross over cable not patch. The second cable I bought, to
check for a cable problem was a patch so I'm going to go out and get another
cross over cable to try.

I don't mean to be a nit but what function does a hub provide other than to
allow distribution of signal between different devices. I'm confused on how
it would help my situation where my boxes actually do partially recognize
each other unless this is indicative of a weak signal. Will a hub correct
this by improving the signal?

If the onboard LAN or it's LAN port is bad then the hub can't fix it....? In
that case might a PCI LAN card be the answer?

Thanks for all of your thoughts and efforts.

Marian
 
There are powered hubs that will amplify signals. A hubs
performs the function of allowing standard straight through
wire cables to swap pin connections as needed which is why
you don't need a cross-over cable if you have a hub. A hub
is basically a connection of all port to all other ports. A
switch only connects the ports that are needed at the time.
A router looks at the packets of information and sends it to
the correct device only.


| Good Morning Supertech,
|
| Right, I meant cross over cable not patch. The second
cable I bought, to
| check for a cable problem was a patch so I'm going to go
out and get another
| cross over cable to try.
|
| I don't mean to be a nit but what function does a hub
provide other than to
| allow distribution of signal between different devices.
I'm confused on how
| it would help my situation where my boxes actually do
partially recognize
| each other unless this is indicative of a weak signal.
Will a hub correct
| this by improving the signal?
|
| If the onboard LAN or it's LAN port is bad then the hub
can't fix it....? In
| that case might a PCI LAN card be the answer?
|
| Thanks for all of your thoughts and efforts.
|
| Marian
|
| | > Hello Again,
| >
| > You can buy a "hub" for cheap. Found one here. But
if you plan on
| > highspeed DSL or
| > cable down the road the $40 for a LinkSys 4 port
router is a good
| > product.
| >
| >
| >
|
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00000J4M9/104-8220876-9274305?v=glance
| >
| > Amazon seems to do everything. You may be able to
find one locally at
| a
| > "used" computer store or a local CompUSA or BestBuy
or whatever is
| near
| > by.
| > Lots of these were 10mb but it would work for
testing. (check with
| your
| > friends
| > or network folks in your office if they have one
that could be
| borrowed
| > over night)
| >
| > Your PATCH cable MUST BE a "cross-over" for your
direct connection
| PC -
| > PC
| > It can NOT be a straight cat-5 cable.
| > To support this direct connection I believe your
network cards (nic's)
| > must support full-duplex. That is, be able to both
transmit and
| receive
| > at the same time.
| > Check your system specs.
| >
| > Later
| >
| > Supertech
| >
| >
| > | > > Dear Supertech,
| > >
| > > I haven't gone away yet. Yes I'm trying to network
directly with patch
| > > cable. Your "I hope not" did not encourage me to buy a
router but I did
| go
| > > out and buy a new cable just in case the connectors
were bad.
| > >
| > > What boggles my simple mind is that the boxes in fact
do recognize each
| > > other....if partial pings count....but not a 100% so I
opted for the
| cheap
| > > way first....if $8 for a dime piece of wire is cheap.
| > >
| > > Is there anyway I can verify that it's not a mainboard
problem before I
| go
| > > out and buy a router? I hate to throw good money after
bad.
| > >
| > > Since I'm not up for disappointment tonight I plan on
trying it in the
| > > morning.
| > >
| > > Thanks,
| > >
| > > Marian
| > >
| > >
| > >
| > >
message
| > > | > > > Hello Again,
| > > >
| > > > 1. Your IP address ? 192.168.1.100 ,,
192.168.1.101 , fixed
| > ip's
| > > ?
| > > > net mask ok ? 255.255.255.0
| > > > 1a. if not sure just click , start , run , (type
in) cmd.exe ,
| gets
| > > > "DOS" window,
| > > > type in, ipconfig , it will tell you
everything.
| > > >
| > > > 2. How are the two boxes connected ? Hub ? ,
Switch? ,
| cross-over
| > > > cable(hope not).
| > > >
| > > > 3. Both of your cables good. . I have a pile of
bad ends where
| just
| > > one
| > > > wire
| > > > will kill traffic but pass a short ping.
| > > >
| > > > 4. Allow several minutes after the systems are
up I have two boxes
| > > here
| > > > that
| > > > when they are first booted up it takes up to
5 minutes for
| them
| > to
| > > > "discover"
| > > > each other.
| > > >
| > > > 5. Your right it should not be this hard. My kid
had his working
| > > before
| > > > I got mine figured out. I missed my own
software firewall set
| up
| > > even
| > > > after
| > > > looking at it several times.
| > > >
| > > > Regards,
| > > > Supertech
| > > >
| > > >
| > > > | > > > > Supertech,
| > > > >
| > > > > Boy are you right.....this one sure has been beat
to death....but it
| > > keeps
| > > > > coming back. I'm not a techspert but I'm not a
novice either and it
| > > > > shouldn't be this difficult.....there must be a
tree in here
| > somewhere.
| > > > >
| > > > > In response to your suggestions:
| > > > > 1. XP firewalls disabled
| > > > > 2. No router
| > > > > 3. "Real firewalls" disabled
| > > > > 4. Enabled file/printsharing on both
| > > > > 5. designated a shared folder on both
| > > > > 6. No softwear firewalls installed
| > > > >
| > > > > What's else can I try?
| > > > >
| > > > > Marian
| > > > >
| > > > >
| > > > >
| > > > >
| > > > >
message
| > > > > | > > > > > This one has been beat to death by most everyone
with XP it seems.
| > > > > >
| > > > > > 1. Make sure that you disable the XP
firewall on each system
| if
| > > > > enabled.
| > > > > > It will allow "pings" but not much
else.
| > > > > > 2. Are you using fix IP's or DHCP from a
router ?? are they
| > > correct
| > > > > ??
| > > > > > 3. Do you have a "real firewall" software
program on your
| > systems
| > > > > > (Norton, or such)?
| > > > > > if so set up both of the systems to
"TRUST" the other ones
| > ip
| > > > > > address.
| > > > > > 4. Ensure that you have enabled file / print
sharing on both.
| > > > > > 5. Ensure that you have shared a disk or
file folder on each
| > > system.
| > > > > >
| > > > > > 6. If your on the internet DSL or dialup you
will want to make
| > > sure
| > > > > that
| > > > > > you get a
| > > > > > "software" firewall that you can
configure to allow your
| > local
| > > > > > system to see each other
| > > > > >
| > > > > >
| > > > > > reply only to the group as my e-mail is
not..
| > > > > >
| > > > > > Supertech
| > > > > >
| > > > > >
| > > > > >
| > > > > > | > > > > > > Hello,
| > > > > > >
| > > > > > > I have 2 relatively new computers, both
running Windows XP
| (SP1).
| > > > > Computer
| > > > > > A
| > > > > > > is a Pent 4, 2.53 Ghz with 1GB RAM, Computer B
is a Celeon 2.7
| Ghz
| > > > with
| > > > > > 512
| > > > > > > mb RAM. Using the onboard LAN 10/100 on each.
| > > > > > >
| > > > > > > The problem is that I cannot get them to
network with each
| other.
| > No
| > > > > other
| > > > > > > computers involved........just a 2 machine
network. When I go
| > > through
| > > > > the
| > > > > > > PING procedure each machine is successful unto
itself but
| between
| > > > > machines
| > > > > > > there are always dropped
packets.......sometimes 1, sometimes 2,
| > > > > sometimes
| > > > > > > 3, and sometimes 4. In any case it's never
consistent except
| that
| > I
| > > > > can't
| > > > > > > complete the network.
| > > > > > >
| > > > > > > Any suggestions will be appreciated.
| > > > > > >
| > > > > > > Marian
| > > > > > >
| > > > > > >
| > > > > >
| > > > > >
| > > > >
| > > > >
| > > >
| > > >
| > >
| > >
| >
| >
|
|
 
Hi Jim,

So for 2 machines 8' from each other a hub would be overkill unless I need
to amplify the signal.....correct? I'm not trying to save a buck but I'm
concerned that inability to network is something other than a signal
problem.

My latest attempt was to install a LAN PCI card on machine A to eliminate
the onboard LAN controller and its port as the source of the problem. Now A
successfully pings B 100% of the time I get a message that I don't have
permission to access the network.....and machine B will not ping A the but B
shows both computers at "View workgroup computers".

This thing has me whupped....to me this is the most convoluted thing MS has
come up.

Anyway, please let's go back and start over. I have 2 boxes both with
onboard LAN and less than 8'-0" from each other. Sharing an internet
connection is not a concern as I only use a DUN connection. My main concern
is that I be able to back up important apps and data to both machines in
case one goes down. What would you recommend?

Marian
 
Are the workgroup names for both the same?

I found that even tho you can change it
from MSHOME to whatever, it always
seems to change!

And is simple file sharing ticked for both
in My Computer/Tools/Folder Options/View?

And if you want net access from the networked
PC, you can click on its LAN icon/Properties
TCP/IP/Properties Use the following ip address
192.xxx.x.x, subnet mask 255.255.255.0
Default gateway (ip for the main PC). And
Preferred DNS (ip for the main PC)?

That should get the connected PC onto
the net. On the main PC under the LAN
icon/Properties/TCP/IP/Properties, you just
select Use the following IP 192.xxx.x.x
And subnet 255.255.255.0. And enable
ICS (so the connected one can get on the
net).

If either is set to Obtain a IP automatically,
they'll change everytime you reboot both
PC's.
 
Back
Top