<snipped>
Entire post - including my initial response...
http://groups.google.com/group/micr...59d95dad522/35fdc9a2c7ab5ccd#35fdc9a2c7ab5ccd
It sounds like you have partitioned your hard disk and created a
small C drive. This works well in theory, but theory goes out the
window if you install bloat like .NET, and/or allow Windows Update
to continue to update your computer without slipstreaming and
re-installing every year or so.
Unlike the others here who have parroted the Microsoft line, I
would suggest that you clean out your C drive as much as possible
and then defragment it. You should first determine whether you use
any programs that require .NET (I avoid such programs like the
plague). If you do not, uninstall .NET. Second, you should visit
the following site:
http://www.bold-fortune.com/forums/index.php
The is the best site on the internet for descriptions of what is
contained in the WINDOWS folder. After reading the descriptions, it
is up to you to decide whether to remove any of the files. To get
you started, if you slipstream and re-install, none of the "blue"
folders will be needed.
Have fun, and remember, it is YOUR hard disk, not Microsoft's! You
have the right to ask "Why is this file on MY hard disk?"!
Shenan said:
mhc,
Explain to me how I 'parroted the Microsoft line' with my advice...
Yes - I point out the logic that if you are starting to worry over
a small amount of space just to keep your machine going - and it is
causing you issues - it's likely time to buy a new hard drive
instead of patching it with bubble gum and duct tape... As far as
I know that is *my* opinion, not Microsoft's - and it is based of
years of experience with machines and the way people utilize them. How is
that giving anything but logical advice on the matter?
I did that AFTER pointing out how to clean up the machine in a safe
and complete manner - freeing up all sorts of space.
You make a good point. That sentence should have read:
"Unlike most of the others here who have parroted the Microsoft
line, I would suggest that you clean out your C drive as much as
possible and then defragment it."
However, telling the person to buy new hardware IS parroting the
Microsoft line: leave everything alone and buy more, more, more to
let us bloat your system more and more and more.
The solution to this person's problem is to slipstream and
re-install Windows, and remove .NET if possible. That will solve
his space problem. I prefer to solve problems, with telling the
person to buy something as a last resort. For all we know, the
person may not have $80 to buy a new hard disk. And as I said
above, it's also quite possible the person created a small C
partition for performance reasons. Telling someone to spend money
for something they may very well not need is foolish at best and
unscrupulous at worst.
I appreciate the change - but I still see the advice of 'just clean it up
and you'll be fine' as short-sighted, at best. (That is my opinion.)
It will __temporarily__ solve the space problems if the hard drive is small
enough that 8.3GB is making a difference and you must know this - even in
your stubborn resolve. That is exactly what I told them and I cannot see
how that is wrong. If they used up the space once - they are likely to use
it up again. It may not be Microsoft that is using the space up - it may
very well be other things - and my advice will uncover what that is.
As for buying the new drive and your assumption... They may not have the
money now - but they have a computer and thus they had enough money at some
point to get that and to pay the electricity bill to continue using it. If
they save a few dollars each month - by the time they need to get the
drive - they can. Even my $100 may be an over-estimate - as that would give
them a 300+GB HDD. They are worried over 8.3GB now - I think even a 20GB
drive would be an improvement - but let's go with a 60GB... $35-$45,
shipped.
http://www.pricewatch.com/hard_removable_drives/
There is negligable (if any) performance benefit to having a small C drive
PARTITION. If that is what they did - then I would point out they could use
something like BootItNG to combine the partitions - but that they should
first backup their important data...
It is not 'parroting the Microsoft line'. Every OS since the beginning has
done nothing but grow and grow in size. Not one has shrunk. Yes - there
are particular builds that have been reduced to their bare essentials - but
for all but the geekiest techs - those are all but unused. It is presenting
common sense. That's why I use the end story I do about the cars and garage
and removing the one filing cabinet.
They have to decide what is important - not you decide for them. Everyone
else gave them choices on what they could do... Some suggested the best
suggestion would be to buy a drive, but they ALSO said they could clean it
up some. You then come around and find a chance to attack everyone instead
of just saying - you could just clean it and do a fresh install. Instead
you said everyone else was parroting some Microsoft suggestion - and I am
telling you my suggestion has nothing to do with Microsoft - if Microsoft
goes away today, I'll get over it tomorrow and be making similar common
sense suggestions wherever I can help.
The point is to give them ALL the advice they might need and that you might
be able to provide - not to give them the 'temp' advice and move on.
They may never move from Microsoft Windows XP or that computer - but I bet
they keep getting email, want to visit a web page that uses Flash,
Shockwave, Quicktime, Real Player, Windows Movie Player 11 or even the new
Adobe Media Player that is being introduced... I bet they enjoy listening
to those songs, watching those videos or just keeping their financial
records in OpenOffice. Maybe they like to use Firefox and Opera - so those
are installed. Maybe they want to try out a few things so they install
them. Maybe they have pictures of their children, their grandchildren, etc.
Maybe they needed something to start making DVD movies of those times in
their lives. Perhaps to use their video card or that DVD burning
application - they need .NET X.X (that would be up to whomever wrote said
software - not Microsoft.)
Their storage space usage is UNLIKELY to shrink - denying that would be
foolish.
So my advice stays the same - they can clean it up using all the tips I
gave - and probably clear up a few GB of space. Once that is done - they
need to think about how they use their space and if this is just going to be
a never-ending and losing cycle until they actually do not have enough
space...
Maybe they could archive stuff to CD/DVD/external media and get their space
back.... Maybe not. They will have to weight their OPTIONS and decide
whether or not they can afford the $40-$100 or if they can live with the nag
of losing space and cleaning it up every couple of weeks/months. They may
decide to buy, they may decide to save and get a whole new computer, they
may decide just to cleanup and everything will be good... It's up to them.
;-)