Most reliable drives in peoples experience??

  • Thread starter Thread starter Smurfinaus
  • Start date Start date
S

Smurfinaus

Hi All,
I suspect its time for me to get a new HD. The IBM 40Gb ive had last two
years has been great but some bad sectors have been cropping up so im
looking for a new drive. Previously i had Fujitsu 6.4 and 4.3 and both
worked fine. Havent kept up with drive technology lately (nor CPU or
Motherboards - gee i need new ones soon too..) so may i ask, in peoples
experience what brand drives are reliable ?. Ive heard bad things about
certain IBM ones, but Seagates are good?.
thanks in advance for any advice
Nijuu.
 
Smurfinaus said:
Hi All,
I suspect its time for me to get a new HD. The IBM 40Gb ive had last two
years has been great but some bad sectors have been cropping up so im
looking for a new drive. Previously i had Fujitsu 6.4 and 4.3 and both
worked fine. Havent kept up with drive technology lately (nor CPU or
Motherboards - gee i need new ones soon too..) so may i ask, in peoples
experience what brand drives are reliable ?. Ive heard bad things about
certain IBM ones, but Seagates are good?.
thanks in advance for any advice
Click to expand...


I like Seagate. I don't like Maxtor.
Just a personal opinion, and that's all.


-WD
 
Smurfinaus said:
I suspect its time for me to get a new HD. The IBM 40Gb ive had
last two years has been great but some bad sectors have been
cropping up so im looking for a new drive. Previously i had Fujitsu
6.4 and 4.3 and both worked fine. Havent kept up with drive technology
lately (nor CPU or Motherboards - gee i need new ones soon too..)
Click to expand...

I like Intel cpus and Asus motherboards with Intel chipsets myself.
so may i ask, in peoples experience what brand drives are
reliable ?. Ive heard bad things about certain IBM ones,
Click to expand...

And the Fujitsu MPG drives too. Not relevant
now tho, Fujitsu has given up on 3.5" IDE drives.
but Seagates are good?.
Click to expand...

Not necessarily. Nothing like as bad as the
IBM GXP drives, but I avoid them myself.

I like the Samsung P80 drives currently and they are the
last of the drive manufacturers to have full 3 year warrantys
on all their drives. Beautifully quiet too which is a real bonus.
 
Rod Speed said:
I like the Samsung P80 drives currently and they are the
last of the drive manufacturers to have full 3 year warrantys
on all their drives. Beautifully quiet too which is a real bonus.
Click to expand...

While I would be happy to try their 160GB drives, I was wishing they had
something in the 300GB range, but they don't have anything bigger, not even
in 5400rpm.

160GB drives have been out for ages, almost a year, it sure seems to take a
long time for bigger sizes in the drive industry.
 
I just got one of those Samsungs. It is very thin and very quiet. It does
seem to run hot. Could be bad for long term durability. We'll see, I
guess.

Dave
 
You will probably get as many opinions as responses, and that is all they
are - opinions. My preference is Western Digital, for the simple reason that
I've never had a failure with them.
 
If you've got a good backup system in place, try using the IBM drive fitness
test to reformat that whole drive, then run the "thorough surface test"
option on it to make sure there are no longer any bad sectors. It'll
probably be right again for a couple of years.
 
Hi All,
I suspect its time for me to get a new HD. The IBM 40Gb ive had last two
years has been great but some bad sectors have been cropping up so im
looking for a new drive. Previously i had Fujitsu 6.4 and 4.3 and both
worked fine. Havent kept up with drive technology lately (nor CPU or
Motherboards - gee i need new ones soon too..) so may i ask, in peoples
experience what brand drives are reliable ?. Ive heard bad things about
certain IBM ones, but Seagates are good?.
thanks in advance for any advice
Nijuu.
Click to expand...

Pull straws and you'll get just as accurate an answer as you will find
here. I don't like Maxtor because I had two fail on me and one of the
replacement drives came with a bad block and is very noisy. I will be
buying either Seagate or Samsung next, and that's purely because I
want the quietest drives available. I like my Western Digital 80gb JB
drive though and would be happy with another one of those, but one
with 120-160gb. Lots of people here seem to like Maxtor though so what
do I know?
 
| > Seagates are good?.

I know 1 Seagate hdd bought in 4-95, & it still works. I'd avoid
Quantum ; their ICs fail with any slight voltage spikes, I have 3
dead Quantum hdds.
Mitsubishi makes very good & small surge absorbers, hdd
makers should fit these onto their PCBs to block voltage
spikes.
 
I know 1 Seagate hdd bought in 4-95, & it still works. I'd avoid
Quantum ; their ICs fail with any slight voltage spikes, I have 3
dead Quantum hdds.
Click to expand...

Quantum no longer exists. Get this: I believe they were bought out
by...drum roll...Seagate.
 
A longer warranty is incentive for the drive manufacturer to not make
shit.
Click to expand...

Nope, it is incentive for the drive manufacturer to charge a higher
price. Or do you really think that the cost of warranty repairs comes
out of the manufacturer's pocket?
 
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Quantum no longer exists. Get this: I believe they were bought out
by...drum roll...Seagate.
Click to expand...

It's worse than that...Quantum was bought out by Maxtor. :-P

(FWIW, I never had significantly more problems with Quantum hard drives than
with most others. I stay away from Maxtor (three dead 5.1GB drives in
almost as many months, plus numerous other problems since), and some of my
IBM drives have started acting up (only 75GXP & 60GXP models; the others
have been OK). Everything else has usually held up well enough. These
days, I'm mainly buying Western Digital xxxxJB drives. The 3-year warranty
is a Good Thing to have.

_/_ Scott Alfter (address in header doesn't receive mail)
/ v \ send mail to $firstname@$lastname.us
(IIGS( http://alfter.us/ Top-posting!
\_^_/ rm -rf /bin/laden >What's the most annoying thing on Usenet?

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.3 (Linux)

iD8DBQE/1qDOVgTKos01OwkRAuVrAJ4ssnRuHuTNhrAuMgot8kAJjuP27ACfbl3u
BTf3/KWAozSEFnSCEYM2Lhg=
=bzq8
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
 
These
days, I'm mainly buying Western Digital xxxxJB drives. The 3-year warranty
is a Good Thing to have.
Click to expand...

Bah. Drives are so cheap now that the value of a long warrantee is
almost zilch. So your drive goes belly-up after 2 years? Well, then,
spend $70 and get a new one that's bigger and faster than the one you
had before. It'll be a nice upgrade.
 
| I'm mainly buying Western Digital xxxxJB drives. The 3-year warranty
| is a Good Thing to have.

Agree. I've just bought a WD 400JB, I like its heat dissipation design
: interior ICs' heat are conducted to hdd's exterior, to travel into PC
casing. My Seagate ata66 & 33 hdd's ICs' heat just accumulate ( has
nowhere to go ).
 
Bah. Drives are so cheap now that the value of a long warrantee is
almost zilch. So your drive goes belly-up after 2 years? Well, then,
spend $70 and get a new one that's bigger and faster than the one you
had before. It'll be a nice upgrade.
Click to expand...

A longer warranty is incentive for the drive manufacturer to not make
shit.
 
Maybe. It depends on the premium you pay for that.
A longer warranty is incentive for the
drive manufacturer to not make shit.
Click to expand...

In theory, yes. In practice it isnt possible to design a modern drive
so it will survive the 1 year warranty period fine and not the 3 years.
 
I don't know about the MOST reliable but I've had some pretty frightening
experiences recently with Western Digital 40GB and 80GB drives.

They died utterly WITHOUT WARNING, and one died when it was less than 1 week old
after initially passing all diagnostics.
 
Back
Top