In
jwkh said:
The site has two service providers:
One does the actual Internet connection - DSL.
The other hosts their Web site and email.
There are different DNS for both. If they do not include
the email host DNS in the clients' IP setups, they cannot
resolve the mail site for the email clients.
They have a W2K DC server with AD and DHCP and DNS. The
DNS has forwarders pointing to the DSL DNS sites AND the
email DNS site (DSL is primary and email is secondary).
It STILL does not resolve their email address. Adding to
the DNS server's hosts file does not help.
Still, my point is can I add it manually?
TIA,
jwkh
You could add it manually. Your description is a bit tough to follow, but
from what I see, I'm assuming that no DNS servers on the Internet can
resolve the mail record, is that correct?
Would be really easier if you provided the actual domain name so we can see
if we can resolve it which would help diagsnoe why your different machines
can't resolve it. But that leads me to something else about using multiple
entries, which is highly NOT advised unless both entries have the SAME exact
zone information. Read on...
Little factoid:
If you have more than one DNS lisd in your IP properties, it won't help, but
may confuse the issue. This is due to multiple listings are meant to be a
fault tolerant solution and NOT a load balancing or for mutliple record
access from both listings. This is because the Windows DNS Client Resolver
service will ask the first one. If it ain't got the answer, or doesn't
respond (server maybe down?), it will then query the second one. But it will
NOT go back to the first one at all, unless of course you either restart the
machine OR you restart the DNS Client Service on the machine.
A good way to get the best of both is use your internal one only, and setup
a forwarder to the ISP's DNS. Not knowing if you have AD or not, this is the
"best practice" that many follow and is the consensus in these newsgroups,
especially when using AD, since AD's reliance on DNS is it's lifeline.
How to create a forwarder you ask?
http://support.microsoft.com/?id=300202
If the option is grayed out, delete your Root zone, also shown in that
article.
So, that said, when you list the two, it will confuse and dilute and give
false results. You would need to try using one, then the other and see which
one will resolve it. You can also use nslookup to resolve it.
Example, using the infamous "domain.com" below:
===================================
C:\>nslookup
Default Server: ponyexpress.bandwidthpros.com
Address: 208.47.39.10
(This is my server above)
(Then I changed it to use 4.2.2.2 below)
Default Server: vnsc-bak.sys.gtei.net
Address: 4.2.2.2
Server: vnsc-bak.sys.gtei.net
Address: 4.2.2.2
DNS request timed out.
timeout was 2 seconds.
Non-authoritative answer:
domain.com MX preference = 10, mail exchanger = mail.domain.com
domain.com nameserver = dns2.domainbank.net
domain.com nameserver = dns1.domainbank.net
mail.domain.com internet address = 127.0.0.1
dns1.domainbank.net internet address = 209.92.33.130
dns2.domainbank.net internet address = 209.92.33.150
(Then I changed it back to use my server again below):
Default Server: mail.vbjproductions.com
Address: 208.47.39.10
Server: mail.vbjproductions.com
Address: 208.47.39.10
domain.com MX preference = 10, mail exchanger = mail.domain.com
domain.com nameserver = dns1.domainbank.net
domain.com nameserver = dns2.domainbank.net
mail.domain.com internet address = 127.0.0.1
dns1.domainbank.net internet address = 209.92.33.130
dns2.domainbank.net internet address = 209.92.33.150
===================================
So, yes, you can create a copy of this zone on YOUR DNS server on your own
LAN that you now have ALL your machines soley using and setup a forwarder
on. Then under that zone, create a mail record for that mail server and give
it the actual external IP address. If you don't know the address, use the
nslookup method I showed above and it will give you the actual external IP.
--
Regards,
Ace
Please direct all replies to the newsgroup so all can benefit.
Ace Fekay, MCSE 2000, MCSE+I, MCSA, MCT, MVP
Microsoft Windows MVP - Active Directory