On Tue, 8 Aug 2006 13:23:00 +1000, "Rod Speed"
Like hell I ever did. All I implied is that while ever the replacement
battery from the laptop manufacturer is only say half the cost of
the replacement low end laptop, most have enough of a clue to
go for the laptop with the inevitably considerably better specs
than the one that the battery wore out in.
Well we could "say half the cost", but it isn't really. I
was being overly generous with the $250, in actuality most
low-end laptops are nearer $400 if not slightly higher (else
you end up buying more memory at least, so there's still
slight addt'l cost).
So "IF" the user insists on the manufacturer battery, and
"IF" the manufacturer battery is unusually high priced, say
$160, then whole new laptop still cost 250% as much.
Now back towards reality, batteries are available for half
that, we don't have to go lower, skimming the bottom of the
barrel and risk a shady manufacturer.
The technical term for that is 'pathetically inadequate sample'
Or "real world example", "highly applicable since I have the
old beast". Would you care to go to Dell's site and enter a
different model #? I'll do it for you.........
We did an Inspiron, now a Latitude or two,
100L - $107
C500 - $125
How about a Precision M90? $135
Toshiba's prices look a little higher, average around $150
BUT that's still below the $160 I'd mentioned above.
Irrelevant to those who will only use the manufacturer's batterys.
Relevant if they find the source of the manufacturer's
battery and cut out the middleman.
And plenty have enough of a clue to get a whole new laptop
with much better specs than the one its replacing, when the
whole new laptop is only say twice the price of the new battery.
If they need better specs, sure. That was obvious, and it's
not something someone would typically wait on to get the
last drops of juice out of their old battery.... and of
course, it is't ever "say twice the price" in reality.
Yes, that isnt necessarily the cheapest approach, but we werent
discussing that, we were discussing what most users actually do.
Yes, most users won't replace a working few years old laptop
(can't be TOO old, else the battery would've already been
too low remaining capacity to use before then) with one at
the absolute lowest end to try to reach that $400, not $250,
price-point.
How can we know? Where are all these laptops for sale?
There are some, but certainly not anywhere near the volume
being sold and we cannot assume they all broke and are thus
unsellable.