i945PM laptop chipset, Dual Channel Mode, and unmatched pairs

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert Pendell
  • Start date Start date
R

Robert Pendell

Before we start... Technical Data Sheet for i945-based chipsets -->
http://www.intel.com/design/mobile/datashts/309219.htm. Specifically
reference section 1.1.2 System Memory support for i945GM chipsets (the
i945PM supports all i945GM features but without the integrated graphics).

I just wanted to let you guys know that this chipset does indeed support
dual channel even with unmatched pairs. I know most boards will only do
dual channel mode if the voltage, speed, and capacities match however
this one will do it even if the capacities don't match. I will assume
that the other factors should still match. I used the following memory
sticks...

Slot 1:
G.Skill
F2-5300CL5D-4GBSA
DDRII2GB PC2-5300
CL5-5-5-15

Slot 2:
G.Skill
F2-5300PHU2-2GBSA
DDRII1GB PC2-5300
CL5-5-5-15

Slot one is a stick of 2GB from a 2x2GB matched set
Slot two is a stick of 1GB from a 2x1GB matched set

Therefore they are not meant to go together. They are spec for spec
compatible however. They both run at 1.8v.

Memtest86+ 2.01 passed and reported Dual Channel (Asynchronous). CpuZ
is reporting Dual Channel mode.

Information below is from a CpuZ register dump file.

Chipset
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Northbridge Intel i945PM rev. 03
Southbridge Intel 82801GHM (ICH7-M/U) rev. A1
Graphic Interface PCI-Express
PCI-E Link Width x16
PCI-E Max Link Width x16
Memory Type DDR2
Memory Size 3072 MBytes
Channels Dual
Memory Frequency 332.9 MHz (1:2)
CAS# 5.0
RAS# to CAS# 5
RAS# Precharge 5
Cycle Time (tRAS) 15
Bank Cycle Time (tRC) 21

Memory SPD
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DIMM #1

General
Memory type DDR2
Module format SO-DIMM
Manufacturer (ID) G.Skill (7F7F7F7FCD000000)
Size 2048 MBytes
Max bandwidth PC2-5300 (333 MHz)
Part number F2-5300CL5-2GBSA

Attributes
Number of banks 2
Data width 64 bits
Correction None
Nominal Voltage 1.80 Volts
EPP no
XMP no

Timings table
Frequency (MHz) 200 266 333
CAS# 3.0 4.0 5.0
RAS# to CAS# delay 3 4 5
RAS# Precharge 3 4 5
TRAS 9 12 15
TRC 12 16 20

DIMM #2

General
Memory type DDR2
Module format SO-DIMM
Manufacturer (ID) G.Skill (7F7F7F7FCD000000)
Size 1024 MBytes
Max bandwidth PC2-5300 (333 MHz)
Part number F2-5300PHU1-1GBSA

Attributes
Number of banks 2
Data width 64 bits
Correction None
Nominal Voltage 1.80 Volts
EPP no
XMP no

Timings table
Frequency (MHz) 266 333
CAS# 4.0 5.0
RAS# to CAS# delay 4 5
RAS# Precharge 4 5
TRAS 12 15
TRC 16 20


So umm... yea. Sometimes the boards do not need matched pairs to do
dual-channel mode. I know some people around here have stated that you
require matched pairs for Dual Channel mode to work.

--
Robert Pendell
(e-mail address removed)

"A perfect world is one of chaos."

Thawte Web of Trust Notary
CAcert Assurer
 
I'm one of them as I tried unmatched pairs and it worked for a few days and
then would not no matter what slot combinations I tried.

JS
 
Before we start... Technical Data Sheet for i945-based chipsets -->
http://www.intel.com/design/mobile/datashts/309219.htm. Specifically
reference section 1.1.2 System Memory support for i945GM chipsets (the
i945PM supports all i945GM features but without the integrated graphics).

I just wanted to let you guys know that this chipset does indeed support
dual channel even with unmatched pairs. I know most boards will only do
dual channel mode if the voltage, speed, and capacities match however
this one will do it even if the capacities don't match. I will assume
that the other factors should still match. I used the following memory
sticks...

Slot 1:
G.Skill
F2-5300CL5D-4GBSA
DDRII2GB PC2-5300
CL5-5-5-15

Slot 2:
G.Skill
F2-5300PHU2-2GBSA
DDRII1GB PC2-5300
CL5-5-5-15

Slot one is a stick of 2GB from a 2x2GB matched set
Slot two is a stick of 1GB from a 2x1GB matched set

Therefore they are not meant to go together. They are spec for spec
compatible however. They both run at 1.8v.

Memtest86+ 2.01 passed and reported Dual Channel (Asynchronous). CpuZ
is reporting Dual Channel mode.

Information below is from a CpuZ register dump file.

Chipset
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Northbridge Intel i945PM rev. 03
Southbridge Intel 82801GHM (ICH7-M/U) rev. A1
Graphic Interface PCI-Express
PCI-E Link Width x16
PCI-E Max Link Width x16
Memory Type DDR2
Memory Size 3072 MBytes
Channels Dual
Memory Frequency 332.9 MHz (1:2)
CAS# 5.0
RAS# to CAS# 5
RAS# Precharge 5
Cycle Time (tRAS) 15
Bank Cycle Time (tRC) 21

Memory SPD
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DIMM #1

General
Memory type DDR2
Module format SO-DIMM
Manufacturer (ID) G.Skill (7F7F7F7FCD000000)
Size 2048 MBytes
Max bandwidth PC2-5300 (333 MHz)
Part number F2-5300CL5-2GBSA

Attributes
Number of banks 2
Data width 64 bits
Correction None
Nominal Voltage 1.80 Volts
EPP no
XMP no

Timings table
Frequency (MHz) 200 266 333
CAS# 3.0 4.0 5.0
RAS# to CAS# delay 3 4 5
RAS# Precharge 3 4 5
TRAS 9 12 15
TRC 12 16 20

DIMM #2

General
Memory type DDR2
Module format SO-DIMM
Manufacturer (ID) G.Skill (7F7F7F7FCD000000)
Size 1024 MBytes
Max bandwidth PC2-5300 (333 MHz)
Part number F2-5300PHU1-1GBSA

Attributes
Number of banks 2
Data width 64 bits
Correction None
Nominal Voltage 1.80 Volts
EPP no
XMP no

Timings table
Frequency (MHz) 266 333
CAS# 4.0 5.0
RAS# to CAS# delay 4 5
RAS# Precharge 4 5
TRAS 12 15
TRC 16 20


So umm... yea. Sometimes the boards do not need matched pairs to do
dual-channel mode. I know some people around here have stated that you
require matched pairs for Dual Channel mode to work.
Click to expand...
And what does ANY of this have to do with the XP OS? Oh right,
NOTHING.
 
Robert Pendell said:
Before we start... Technical Data Sheet for i945-based chipsets -->
http://www.intel.com/design/mobile/datashts/309219.htm. Specifically
reference section 1.1.2 System Memory support for i945GM chipsets (the
i945PM supports all i945GM features but without the integrated graphics).

I just wanted to let you guys know that this chipset does indeed support
dual channel even with unmatched pairs. I know most boards will only do
dual channel mode if the voltage, speed, and capacities match however this
one will do it even if the capacities don't match. I will assume that the
other factors should still match. I used the following memory sticks...

Slot 1:
G.Skill
F2-5300CL5D-4GBSA
DDRII2GB PC2-5300
CL5-5-5-15

Slot 2:
G.Skill
F2-5300PHU2-2GBSA
DDRII1GB PC2-5300
CL5-5-5-15

Slot one is a stick of 2GB from a 2x2GB matched set
Slot two is a stick of 1GB from a 2x1GB matched set

Therefore they are not meant to go together. They are spec for spec
compatible however. They both run at 1.8v.

Memtest86+ 2.01 passed and reported Dual Channel (Asynchronous). CpuZ is
reporting Dual Channel mode.

Information below is from a CpuZ register dump file.

Chipset
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Northbridge Intel i945PM rev. 03
Southbridge Intel 82801GHM (ICH7-M/U) rev. A1
Graphic Interface PCI-Express
PCI-E Link Width x16
PCI-E Max Link Width x16
Memory Type DDR2
Memory Size 3072 MBytes
Channels Dual
Memory Frequency 332.9 MHz (1:2)
CAS# 5.0
RAS# to CAS# 5
RAS# Precharge 5
Cycle Time (tRAS) 15
Bank Cycle Time (tRC) 21

Memory SPD
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DIMM #1

General
Memory type DDR2
Module format SO-DIMM
Manufacturer (ID) G.Skill (7F7F7F7FCD000000)
Size 2048 MBytes
Max bandwidth PC2-5300 (333 MHz)
Part number F2-5300CL5-2GBSA

Attributes
Number of banks 2
Data width 64 bits
Correction None
Nominal Voltage 1.80 Volts
EPP no
XMP no

Timings table
Frequency (MHz) 200 266 333 CAS# 3.0 4.0 5.0 RAS# to CAS# delay 3 4 5 RAS#
Precharge 3 4 5 TRAS 9 12 15 TRC 12 16 20
DIMM #2

General
Memory type DDR2
Module format SO-DIMM
Manufacturer (ID) G.Skill (7F7F7F7FCD000000)
Size 1024 MBytes
Max bandwidth PC2-5300 (333 MHz)
Part number F2-5300PHU1-1GBSA

Attributes
Number of banks 2
Data width 64 bits
Correction None
Nominal Voltage 1.80 Volts
EPP no
XMP no

Timings table
Frequency (MHz) 266 333 CAS# 4.0 5.0 RAS# to CAS# delay 4 5 RAS# Precharge
4 5 TRAS 12 15 TRC 16 20

So umm... yea. Sometimes the boards do not need matched pairs to do
dual-channel mode. I know some people around here have stated that you
require matched pairs for Dual Channel mode to work.

--
Robert Pendell
(e-mail address removed)

"A perfect world is one of chaos."

Thawte Web of Trust Notary
CAcert Assurer
Click to expand...

Yes, that's the case with the more recent Intel chipsets. My MB
uses the i965P chipset and the manual states that if you install
different sized DIMMs they will run in dual channel mode for
the size of the smallest DIMM, then in single channel mode for
the excess. If you install 1 GB and 2 GB DIMMs the first 2 GB
will run in dual channel mode, and the 3rd GB will run in single
channel mode. The latter is obvious since there's nothing to pair
the 3rd GB with. The DIMMs must otherwise still be matched as
to speed, and voltage.
 
OldDuke said:
And what does ANY of this have to do with the XP OS? Oh right,
NOTHING.
Click to expand...

This is a hardware group. It is on topic here I believe. All of the
tests are done on Windows XP and I run it daily so I think it applies here.

--
Robert Pendell
(e-mail address removed)

"A perfect world is one of chaos."

Thawte Web of Trust Notary
CAcert Assurer
 
Robert said:
Before we start... Technical Data Sheet for i945-based chipsets -->
http://www.intel.com/design/mobile/datashts/309219.htm. Specifically
reference section 1.1.2 System Memory support for i945GM chipsets (the
i945PM supports all i945GM features but without the integrated graphics).

I just wanted to let you guys know that this chipset does indeed support
dual channel even with unmatched pairs. I know most boards will only do
dual channel mode if the voltage, speed, and capacities match however
this one will do it even if the capacities don't match. I will assume
that the other factors should still match. I used the following memory
sticks...

Slot 1:
G.Skill
F2-5300CL5D-4GBSA
DDRII2GB PC2-5300
CL5-5-5-15

Slot 2:
G.Skill
F2-5300PHU2-2GBSA
DDRII1GB PC2-5300
CL5-5-5-15

Slot one is a stick of 2GB from a 2x2GB matched set
Slot two is a stick of 1GB from a 2x1GB matched set

Therefore they are not meant to go together. They are spec for spec
compatible however. They both run at 1.8v.

Memtest86+ 2.01 passed and reported Dual Channel (Asynchronous). CpuZ
is reporting Dual Channel mode.

Information below is from a CpuZ register dump file.

Chipset
------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Northbridge Intel i945PM rev. 03
Southbridge Intel 82801GHM (ICH7-M/U) rev. A1
Graphic Interface PCI-Express
PCI-E Link Width x16
PCI-E Max Link Width x16
Memory Type DDR2
Memory Size 3072 MBytes
Channels Dual
Memory Frequency 332.9 MHz (1:2)
CAS# 5.0
RAS# to CAS# 5
RAS# Precharge 5
Cycle Time (tRAS) 15
Bank Cycle Time (tRC) 21

Memory SPD
------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DIMM #1

General
Memory type DDR2
Module format SO-DIMM
Manufacturer (ID) G.Skill (7F7F7F7FCD000000)
Size 2048 MBytes
Max bandwidth PC2-5300 (333 MHz)
Part number F2-5300CL5-2GBSA

Attributes
Number of banks 2
Data width 64 bits
Correction None
Nominal Voltage 1.80 Volts
EPP no
XMP no

Timings table
Frequency (MHz) 200 266 333
CAS# 3.0 4.0 5.0
RAS# to CAS# delay 3 4 5
RAS# Precharge 3 4 5
TRAS 9 12 15
TRC 12 16 20

DIMM #2

General
Memory type DDR2
Module format SO-DIMM
Manufacturer (ID) G.Skill (7F7F7F7FCD000000)
Size 1024 MBytes
Max bandwidth PC2-5300 (333 MHz)
Part number F2-5300PHU1-1GBSA

Attributes
Number of banks 2
Data width 64 bits
Correction None
Nominal Voltage 1.80 Volts
EPP no
XMP no

Timings table
Frequency (MHz) 266 333
CAS# 4.0 5.0
RAS# to CAS# delay 4 5
RAS# Precharge 4 5
TRAS 12 15
TRC 16 20


So umm... yea. Sometimes the boards do not need matched pairs to do
dual-channel mode. I know some people around here have stated that you
require matched pairs for Dual Channel mode to work.
Click to expand...

My comments -

1) Don't believe everything the BIOS prints on the screen. There
have been a number of motherboard BIOS that got the declaration
of memory mode wrong.

2) Check the datasheet for the chipset, to see what modes are supported.

http://www.intel.com/design/mobile/datashts/309219.htm
http://download.intel.com/design/mobile/datashts/30921905.pdf

Check Fig.15 on PDF page 339 of the 30921905 document. There are three
operating modes. Leftmost, involves only one of the channels having
a DIMM installed. Middle mode is one DIMM per channel, identical size
for each (note that there is no mention in the document, of a Flex memory
mode). The third rightmost diagram is misnamed. In other architectures, it
would be termed virtual single channel, as the two channels are placed
head to toe, and access is single channel with respect to sequential
access attempts.

One other poster mentioned P965, so we can compare to that.

http://download.intel.com/design/chipsets/datashts/31305302.pdf (see page 336)

Check Figure 10-1 on PDF page 336. The leftmost mode uses a single
channel. The middle mode is dual channel, with equal sized DIMMs.
(Memory is interleaved from end to end.) The rightmost column is
the interesting one. Unlike your 945PM chipset, the controller supports
Flex mode. That interleaves as much memory as matches in quantity,
and then the excess of memory is accessed in single channel mode.

Flex memory mode means memory bandwidth changes with memory address.
For example, if one channel had 1GB of memory, and the other channel
had 512MB of memory, then there would be enough memory to interleave
the bottom 2x512MB quantity. The remaining upper 512MB section of the
1GB DIMM would be accessed in single channel mode.

Conclusion ? On 945PM, mismatched memory runs in virtual single channel mode.
On P965, mismatched memory runs in dual channel at the bottom part,
and single channel at the top. Matched memory, on either chipset, runs
in true dual channel mode.

3) Measurements. You can learn a lot from measurements. Here is a test plan -

1) Install just one stick. Boot a copy of Memtest86+. Observe the memory
bandwidth indicator on the upper left of the screen (at least, that is
where the bandwidth number used to be placed). If you don't like
Memtest86+ for this, then try Sisoftware Sandra instead.

2) Install a matched set of DIMMs on your computer. This will be a dual
channel test case. Again, read off the bandwidth indicator for the memory.
The number will not be double, as the channel efficiency is not the same
for the two modes.

3) Install a mismatched set of DIMMs, 1GB in one slot, 2GB in the other slot.
What does the bandwidth indicator say now ? Does it match (1) ? Does
it match (2) ? What is your conclusion ?

Finally, if you really think you have Flex mode in your chipset, I even have
a test case for that.

I got the source for memtest86+ version 1.65, and made a small modification to
it. I did a build in Linux, and the "make" operation preps a floppy with the
new code. The objective of the code, is to make memory bandwidth measurements,
at equally spaced locations throughout the memory map. For example, I could
split a 2GB total memory, into (8) 256MB chunks, and do a transfer speed test
on a 16MB sized chunk at the beginning of each 256MB chunk.

http://groups.google.ca/group/alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus/msg/612b44b94d1b64f4?dmode=source

(When I first presented my results. This is just after I got it working.)
http://groups.google.ca/group/alt.c..._frm/thread/27e23db56f02cbf2/2a1b309b3f3680d0

When I ran the modified memtest86+ 1.65 code, on an Nforce2 motherboard with
3x512MB DIMMs, this is what was printed on the screen. (I used 12 zones, because
I had a weird amount of memory to test.) Location zero is not tested, and it is
dangerous to assume it is available to you (may be in reserved memory section).
(I didn't consult all the code in this program to make this change, and
did not vet my memory against the E820 BIOS reserved map etc.)

08000000 1435 ; (This is address 128MB)
10000000 1435
18000000 1435
20000000 1435
28000000 1435
30000000 1435
38000000 1435
40000000 916 ; (This is address 1GB)
48000000 916
50000000 916
58000000 916

The Nforce2 works similarly to the Intel Flex concept (only Nvidia did it first).
Notice how, when the amount of memory on each channel does not match, the
upper memory is the slowest. The upper part runs in single channel mode
(in this case, at 916MB/sec). The lower part interleaves 2x512MB and the
memory bandwidth is 1435MB/sec instead. The P965 should do something
similar.

By using a modified copy of memtest86+, you can test for Flex mode and see
if it is present, when non-matched memory is used. With 3GB of memory,
I might divide the memory into 12 chunks (and not measure at location zero).
If you got a pattern like the one shown above, then Flex mode is present.
If the measured value is equal for all tested chunks, then Flex mode is
not present (matching the claims in the Intel datasheet).

Good luck,
Paul
 
Robert said:
This is a hardware group. It is on topic here I believe. All of the
tests are done on Windows XP and I run it daily so I think it applies
here.
Click to expand...

Robert, YoungDuke clearly doesn't understand the term "hardware", but trying
to explain it to him is a lost cause, because it's above his paygrade.
 
OldDuke said:
And what does ANY of this have to do with the XP OS? Oh right,
NOTHING.
Click to expand...

OldDuke (aka Farad'n) is our resident ****wit. He is a mentally ill and
dilusional that he somehow has the right to decide what goes in this
newsgroup and what doesn't.

Your hardware question is perfectly welcome in a *hardware* newsgroup.
 
Back
Top