dual channel ram

  • Thread starter Thread starter philip.chadwick1
  • Start date Start date
P

philip.chadwick1

hi all
can anyone shed any light on which dual channel ddr kit to use on a msi
865PE-NEO2-F1S2R i865 p4 motherboard/with P4 800fb CPU?
I've looked at all the websites I can find including MSI's and various
manufacturers (kingston/geil/corsair) but have not found the exact info I
require - though I do have a bad headache!
all I want is a list of 3 or 4 kits to compare prices on
thnx phil
 
hi all
can anyone shed any light on which dual channel ddr kit to use on a msi
865PE-NEO2-F1S2R i865 p4 motherboard/with P4 800fb CPU?
I've looked at all the websites I can find including MSI's and various
manufacturers (kingston/geil/corsair) but have not found the exact info I
require - though I do have a bad headache!
all I want is a list of 3 or 4 kits to compare prices on
thnx phil
Click to expand...
Have a look at this link (bottom of page) it gives all compatible memory
types for your mobo

http://www.msi.com.tw/program/products/mainboard/mbd/pro_mbd_detail.php?
UID=433


Jim
 
philip.chadwick1 said:
hi all
can anyone shed any light on which dual channel ddr kit to use on a msi
865PE-NEO2-F1S2R i865 p4 motherboard/with P4 800fb CPU?
I've looked at all the websites I can find including MSI's and various
manufacturers (kingston/geil/corsair) but have not found the exact info I
require - though I do have a bad headache!
all I want is a list of 3 or 4 kits to compare prices on
thnx phil
Click to expand...

Corsair memory is the best, DDR500 baby!
 
mmmmmmmmmm??
thnx so far
1) I got as far as the testreport - that was one of the things that gave me
a headache! don't these ppl speak english?
2) tried the link - got no html?
3) was looking at corsair but saw a report saying there were conflict
problems with dual channel!
is there a site out there that just tells you what to get?
I must confess this is giving me more problems than picking the rest of the
system so far
oh well I'll take some panadol and look at those test reports again - now
where did I leave the bottle?
bi phil
 
mmmmmmmmmm??
thnx so far
1) I got as far as the testreport - that was one of the things that gave me
a headache! don't these ppl speak english?
2) tried the link - got no html?
3) was looking at corsair but saw a report saying there were conflict
problems with dual channel!
is there a site out there that just tells you what to get?
I must confess this is giving me more problems than picking the rest of the
system so far
oh well I'll take some panadol and look at those test reports again - now
where did I leave the bottle?
bi phil
Click to expand...
OK, the bottom line is you can use PC2100, PC2700 or PC3200 modules
either 256Mb or 512Mb. It appears all the major manufacturers memory is
supported. The most recommended ones tend to be:

Corsair
TwinMOS
Samsung
Crucial

Obviously there are others.
Another interesting thing I came across was in most cases 1 module is ok
but when installing 2 modules it is preferable to install them in
alternate slots ie 1 & 3 or 2 & 4. I don't know the logic behind this
but I have come across problems on my own MSI mobo when installing
memory in slots 1 & 2.

HTH

Jim
 
-
Jim Stevenson stood up at show-n-tell, in
(e-mail address removed), and said:

OK, the bottom line is you can use PC2100, PC2700 or PC3200 modules
either 256Mb or 512Mb. It appears all the major manufacturers memory
is supported. The most recommended ones tend to be:

Corsair
TwinMOS
Samsung
Crucial

Obviously there are others.
Another interesting thing I came across was in most cases 1 module is
ok
but when installing 2 modules it is preferable to install them in
alternate slots ie 1 & 3 or 2 & 4. I don't know the logic behind this
but I have come across problems on my own MSI mobo when installing
memory in slots 1 & 2.
Click to expand...

What you are referring to are actually Bank A, slot 0...Bank A, slot 1 and
Bank B, slot 0...Bank B, slot 1. For dual channel operation, you populate
either Bank A0 and Bank B0 or Bank A1 and Bank B1, with identical DIMMS
(each bank consists of two channels, ie slots, 0 and 1). If you populate
Bank A0 and Bank A1, with identical DIMMS, your memory is in single channel
mode. However, it's still running at it's stated speed. I've been
wondering about the difference, performance-wise, between the two modes.
And, have not seen any difference personally. I would imagine it would have
something to do with multitasking applications. But, I've yet to read any
articles. Might do that, later today.
 
| What you are referring to are actually Bank A, slot 0...Bank A, slot 1 and
| Bank B, slot 0...Bank B, slot 1. For dual channel operation, you populate
| either Bank A0 and Bank B0 or Bank A1 and Bank B1, with identical DIMMS
| (each bank consists of two channels, ie slots, 0 and 1). If you populate
| Bank A0 and Bank A1, with identical DIMMS, your memory is in single channel
| mode. However, it's still running at it's stated speed. I've been
| wondering about the difference, performance-wise, between the two modes.
| And, have not seen any difference personally. I would imagine it would have
| something to do with multitasking applications. But, I've yet to read any
| articles. Might do that, later today.

I've not had much luck finding anything that completely explains the differences
between using 1GB of RAM in one channel vs 512MB in each channel. Which is
better and why? I can't help thinking you'd need to double your RAM to get the
full benefit of hyperthreading.

When you learn the answer, please come back and educate us!

Larc



§§§ - Please raise temperature of mail to reply by e-mail - §§§
 
-
Larc stood up at show-n-tell, in (e-mail address removed),
and said:
I've not had much luck finding anything that completely explains the
differences between using 1GB of RAM in one channel vs 512MB in each
channel. Which is better and why? I can't help thinking you'd need
to double your RAM to get the full benefit of hyperthreading.

When you learn the answer, please come back and educate us!
Click to expand...

From what I have gleened, I'm thinking the whole 'dual mode' vs. 'single
mode' is a lot like AGP 4X vs AGP 8X. It's a bandwidth issue. While the
speed of the memory does not change, the transfer rate between the CPU and
the memory increases going to dual channel mode. I could be wrong. But, I
think that's the gist of it. I've been googling, around, and have not
really found anything either on it but hype.

I started out with 512MB DDR400, running in dual mode on my new
board/processor. For gaming reasons (very memory hungry games), I upped to
1GB. However, I did the initial 512 with 2x256. So, I was torn.... Do I
spend another $200+???? (as money is a bit tight, atm). Or, do I buy 2x256
more at $100 and suffer any degredation in performance (by populating all 4
channels). Instead, I decided on this: Got 1x512, stuck it in first
channel, first bank (first physical memory that is used by winblows). As
soon as I do some other things (9800pro, 21'' Samsung hehe) I can just get
another 1x512 and then have 1.5GB running in dual mode. Right now, all is
running in single, as apparently you can't mix modes (can't have the 1x512
running in single mode, whilst the 2x256 are in dual..it all defaults to
single channel).

But, as I said, I cannot see any difference between the two modes. And, I
have some pretty memory hungry games (postal2, SWG, etc...). I tried both
single and dual, with the 2x256. I could not discern any difference. Maybe
they aren't demanding enough (the games)? I don't know. But, I do know
that going up to a Gig took care of the major lag I had in the system after
exiting such memory hungry games. I had, even, tweaked around with the
pagefile to force winblows to use physical memory before taking the plunge
to a Gig of memory...no joy. Seems the sheer increase in physical memory
did the trick.

Now, back onto the topic :) I think this is a bit like the 4x vs 8x
thing... I doubt there is anything (that us endusers use) that would even
max out the bandwidth of single channel mode (much like AGP 4x).... that's
my current thinking, anyway. Subject to change.
 
hi
seems I started something here and also (encouragingly) seems noone really
understands this - whatever website you look at comes up with something
slightly different and I have yet to have any response from
msi/corsair/geil/kingston
for what it's worth - it seems to be (as strontium says) an increase in
bandwidth as you can only use ddr400 with a fsb of 800 mhz and the advantage
of the various twin packs is they are packed as identical - ohhhhhhh my head
hurts!!
enough already - I think I'll just take a pin and stick it in
thnx phil
 
hi
seems I started something here and also (encouragingly) seems noone really
understands this - whatever website you look at comes up with something
slightly different and I have yet to have any response from
msi/corsair/geil/kingston
for what it's worth - it seems to be (as strontium says) an increase in
bandwidth as you can only use ddr400 with a fsb of 800 mhz and the advantage
of the various twin packs is they are packed as identical - ohhhhhhh my head
hurts!!
enough already - I think I'll just take a pin and stick it in
thnx phil
Click to expand...

This list is from the MSI website and details all the Qualified Vendors
or DDR400 Memory for your particular board (Sorry it's a bit long)

Memory Brand / Model Size Business Winstone 2001
Infineon (HYS64D16301GU-5-B)
HYB25D256160BT-5
128MB OK
Nanya (NT128D64SH4B1G-5)
NT5DS16M16BT-5
128MB OK
OCZ (PN- OCZ400256EL )
PN- OCZ400256EL
256MB OK
Infineon (HYS64D32300GU-5-B)
HYB25D256800BT-5
256MB OK
Micron (MT8VDDT3264AG-40BC4)
MT46V32M8TG-5B C
256MB OK
Winbond (W9425GCDB-5)
W942508CH-5 256MB OK
Kingston KVR400X64C25/256
W942508BH-5 (Winbond) 256MB OK
SEC (M368L3223DTM-CC4)
K4H560838D-TCC4 256MB OK
SEC (M368L3223ETM-CCC)
K4H560838E-TCCC
256MB OK
CORSAIR (CMX256A-3200LL)
XMS3205 V1.2 256MB OK
Apacer (73.85397.460)
K4H560838D-TCC4 (SEC) 256MB OK
GeIL (GL2563200U)
GL3LC32G88TG-5A 256MB OK
GeIL (GE2563200B) 256MB OK
Hynix (HYMD232646A8J-D43)
HY5DU56822AT-D43 256MB OK
Hynix (HYMD232646B8J-D43)
HY5DU56822BT-D43 256MB OK
PSC (AL5D8A53TK1-5B)
A2S56D30ATP-5 256MB OK
PSC (AL5D8B53T-5B1K)
A2S56D30BTP-5
256MB OK
Nanya (NT256D64S88B1G-5T)
NT5DS32M8BT-5T 256MB OK
A-DATA (MD0M05F3G31JB1EAZ)
V58C2256804SAT5 (Mosel) 256MB OK
A-DATA (MD0WB5F3G31 JD1EZZ)
W942508CH-5 (Winbobd) 256MB OK
ATP (AG32L72T8SQC4S)
K4H560838D-TCC4 (SEC) 256MB OK
Apacer (77.10636.115)
HYB25D256800BT-6 B (Infineon) 256MB OK
Apacer (77.10639.535)
A2S56D30ATP (PSC) 256MB OK
Transcend (TS32MLD64V4F3)
K4H560838D-TCCC (SEC) 256MB OK
TwinMOS (M2S9I08AFAPS9F0811A-T)
A2S56D30ATP3079LA05 (PSC) 256MB OK
TwinMOS (M2G9I08AFATT9F0811DDT)
TwinMOS TMD7608F8E50B 256MB OK
LEGEND (L3264D37-643HDC9B)
HY5DU56822BT-D43 (Hynix) 256MB OK
Siemens (SDU03264B4B31MT-50)
MT46V32M8TG-5B C (Micron) 256MB OK
OCZ (OCZ400256ELDCPE-K) 256MB OK
Infineon (HYS64D32300HU-5-C)
HYB25D256800CE-5 C
256MB OK
GeIL (GE5123200B) 512MB OK
CORSAIR (CMX512-3500C2PT)
XMS3502 V1.1 512MB OK
Micron (MT16VDDT6464AG-40BC4)
MT46V32M8TG-5B C 512MB OK
Nanya (NT512D64S8HB1G-5T)
NT5DS32M8BT-5T 512MB OK
Winbond (W9451GCDB-5)
W942508CH-5 512MB OK
Apacer (77.10736.583)
W942508BH-5 (Winbond) 512MB OK
Apacer (77.10736.554)
HY5DU56822BT-D43 (Hynix) 512MB OK
Apacer (77.10739.534)
A2S56D30ATP (PSC) 512MB OK
Apacer (77.10736.464)
K4H560838D-TCCC (SEC) 512MB OK
Kingston (KVR400X64C25/512)
W942508BH-5 (Winbond) 512MB OK
KingMax (MPXC22D-38KT3R) 512MB OK
SEC (M368L6423DTM-CC4)
K4H560838D-TCC4 512MB OK
SEC (M368L6423ETM-CCC)
K4H560838E-TCCC 512MB OK
Hynix (HYMD264646A8J-D43)
HY5DU56822AT-D43 512MB OK
Hynix (HYMD264646B8J-D43)
HY5DU56822BT-D43 512MB OK
ATP (AG64L64T8SQC4S)
K4H560838D-TCC4 (SEC) 512MB OK
PSC (AL6D8A53TK1-5B)
A2S56D30ATP-5 512MB OK
PSC (AL6D8B53T-5B1K)
A2S56D30BTP-5
512MB OK
Transcend (TS64MLD64V4F3)
K4H560838D-TCCC (SEC) 512MB OK
TwinMOS (M2G9J16AJATT9F0811DDT)
TMD7608F8E50B 512MB OK
Crucial/Micron (BG111DB.FB)
MT46V32M8TG-5B C (Micron) 512MB OK
Siemens (SDU06464H1B22IN-50)
HYB25D256800BT-5 B (Infineon) 512MB OK
Siemens (SDU06464H1B32MT-50)
MT46V32M8TG-5B C (Micron) 512MB OK
elixir (M2U51264DS8HB3G-5T)
N2DS25680BT-5T (elixir) 512MB OK
Infineon (HYS64D64320HU-5-C)
HYB25D256800CE-5 C 512MB


Jim
 
hi
the curious thing about this is, that this list, which is off msi's website
I think, gives for example 5 compatible Kingston dimm's, whereas Kingston's
own site lists 20 as being OK!!
it also states "k2" kit parts as being required for dual channel mode
I think I'll just stick a pin in
bi phil
 
Back
Top