DotNetNuke

  • Thread starter Thread starter Peter Morris [Droopy eyes software]
  • Start date Start date
P

Peter Morris [Droopy eyes software]

I'm just about to start evaluating DDN. If anyone here has any experience
of it I would be interested in any Pros/Cons you may wish to share.

Thanks

Pete
 
I recall theres a forum for it at www.asp.net. You'd be better off asking
about this kind of thing there, as the developers for it hang out there.
 
I checked it out and found it unsuitable for anything where you'll be
doing additional development yourself.

Basically, DNN intends you to set it up as the entire web site, and any
additional functionality you want to add needs to be DotNetNuke
Modules. So your Solution will include ALL the DNN source code, along
with your modification. In other words, your project will essentially
need to be an extension of the existing DNN codebase.

The unfortunate thing is that there's no real way to use the Content
Management portions of DNN in your own project and leave out the pieces
you don't use. In fact, there is no native way in DNN to even redirect
to a page outside the CMS, so you couldn't even get to "MyPage.aspx"
from the site navigation without adding a custom component to
DotNetNuke that allows you do so.

As a final straw, DNN is written in VB.NET, and it was the author's
first attempt at writing an ASP.NET app. That should say enough right
there. (Remember your first ASP.NET application? Can you honestly say
you wouldn't wince a bit if you had to go look at the source?)

Sadly, I can't recommend an alternative. I went ahead and built a
standalone CMS component that I've been plugging into client sites.
I'd love to point you at it along with claims of fantasticness, but I
couldn't really say it's ready for public consumption at this point.

Good luck with your search!

Jason Kester
Expat Software Consulting Services
http://www.expatsoftware.com/
 
I'm just about to start evaluating DDN. If anyone here has any experience
of it I would be interested in any Pros/Cons you may wish to share.
Click to expand...

Can't really add much to Jason's reply, save to say that if you go down the
DNN route, you'd better absolutely love DNN, all of DNN and nothing but DNN.

You want to make even the "slightest" modification, forget it.
 
Peter said:
I'm just about to start evaluating DDN. If anyone here has any experience
of it I would be interested in any Pros/Cons you may wish to share.
Click to expand...

I tried it and I would not recommend it. is very close and
restrictive, hard to make it your own way and support community is not
very active neither.


--
Sinceramente,
Josué Maldonado.

.... "Establece tu caracter sin inhibiciones ante los demas, humillate
ante Dios unicamente."
 
Mark Rae said:
Can't really add much to Jason's reply, save to say that if you go down the
DNN route, you'd better absolutely love DNN, all of DNN and nothing but DNN.

You want to make even the "slightest" modification, forget it.
Click to expand...

It's definitely ugly, but also very powerful if you aren't looking to recode.

Has anyone used this product?
http://www.rainbowportal.net/
 
Back
Top