Baby fried my MB

  • Thread starter Thread starter The Amateur
  • Start date Start date
T

The Amateur

It was Veteran's day and I had the day off from work. My 1 1/2 year
old son was harmlessly fiddling with the buttons on our printer while
I was on the computer doing a quick check of email and what-not, when
all of a sudden the computer went off. I look down and see my son's
hands had moved from the printer to the power button of the surge
protector. He turned it off. No big deal, I thought. Turned the surge
protector back on. Attempted to turn the computer back on and nothing.
Tried different outlets, nothing. Held the PC's power button in for a
few, nothing.

I went to the local PC shop and bought a new PSU, swapped the new for
the one in my PC, nothing. No power. No lights. Nothing. Returned the
new PSU to the shop.

Replaced my old PSU, took the battery out of the motherboard to reset
the CMOS, still nothing.

Now maybe I should have reset the CMOS with the new PSU in place,
because my old PSU could be fried too. Oh well.

So does anyone think my MB is dead?

Also, why would simply turning the surge protector off fry the MB?

Finally, could the shortage have spread and killed my RAM and HDD ?
 
The said:
It was Veteran's day and I had the day off from work. My 1 1/2 year
old son was harmlessly fiddling with the buttons on our printer while
I was on the computer doing a quick check of email and what-not, when
all of a sudden the computer went off. I look down and see my son's
hands had moved from the printer to the power button of the surge
protector. He turned it off. No big deal, I thought. Turned the surge
protector back on. Attempted to turn the computer back on and nothing.
Tried different outlets, nothing. Held the PC's power button in for a
few, nothing.

I went to the local PC shop and bought a new PSU, swapped the new for
the one in my PC, nothing. No power. No lights. Nothing. Returned the
new PSU to the shop.

Replaced my old PSU, took the battery out of the motherboard to reset
the CMOS, still nothing.

Now maybe I should have reset the CMOS with the new PSU in place,
because my old PSU could be fried too. Oh well.

So does anyone think my MB is dead?

Also, why would simply turning the surge protector off fry the MB?

Finally, could the shortage have spread and killed my RAM and HDD ?

Have you been doing all of the tests, using that surge protector ?

Maybe the surge protector is bad. Try plugging directly into
some other outlet.

Paul
 
And this is what my system basically consists of:

E6420
Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3R
2 GB's Crucial 800 RAM
Corsair 520HX PSU
Evga 7600GT
150gb Seagate Barracuda 7200.10
DVD R/W
 
Have you been doing all of the tests, using that surge protector ?

Maybe the surge protector is bad. Try plugging directly into
some other outlet.

    Paul- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Yeah I've moved the PC to different outlets without using the surge
protector.
 
pull a stick of memory out..and / or reseat all your hardware back in their respective
slots.

Use the old 1st thing to do:
Strip it down to a 'POST'- minimum and try to POST..if it will, then try and boot from
the hard drive
 
Have you been doing all of the tests, using that surge protector ?

Maybe the surge protector is bad. Try plugging directly into
some other outlet.

Paul- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Yeah I've moved the PC to different outlets without using the surge
protector.

I would try this:
Remove the power supply, plug it in, jumper the pins to power it on
http://www.hardwarebook.info/ATX_Power_Supply
If the PS fan spins I would then shut it off with the rocker switch, connect
the molex to the hard drive, power it back on to see if the hard drive
works. (you could also test the PS with a multimeter at this point).
If the hard drive spins then I would put it back into the box and make all
the connections, then jumper the case switch leads on the mainboard. You
want to eliminate the case switch as a problem.
If the case switch does not seem to be a problem, then I would disconnect
everything from the motherboard including the video card, remove the memory,
and with only the processor in, turn the system on. See if the motherboard
power light comes on. You should get a bios beep code saying memory failure.
If the system starts (power light on, bios beeping) then start to add the
components back one at a time (one stick of memory, then the other). After
memory add the video card and see if the bios screen shows up. Then the hard
drive.
If all fails at the beginning then the motherboard is very possibly gone. If
not you will eventually get to the fried component.
 
Depands on what the surge protector does... and what happens when its turned
off...

Does electricity still flow when it's off ?

Then if yes... the surge protector would function as a water-dam holding the
water in the river and only letting a little bit through...

Then when it's turned off it is like a dam-break... all the water comes
rushing down and kills anything in it's path ;)

At least that's my theory ! :)

Love your baby ! =D

Lessons learned for you and me and all of us: Never let babies play near
buttons or electrical devices ! ;) :)

Bye,
Skybuck.
 
Also another good reason to place your PC on a desk instead of on the ground
?!?

I reckon the baby was crawling over the ground ! ;)

Dusty there too ! ;)

Next time it might be a rat ! :)

Or a cat !

Or a dog ! :)

Bye,
Skybuck.
 
Depands on what the surge protector does... and what happens when its turned
off...
Does electricity still flow when it's off ?
Then if yes... the surge protector would function as a water-dam holdingthe
water in the river and only letting a little bit through...
Then when it's turned off it is like a dam-break... all the water comes
rushing down and kills anything in it's path ;)
At least that's my theory ! :)
Love your baby ! =D
Lessons learned for you and me and all of us: Never let babies play near
buttons or electrical devices ! ;) :)
Bye,
 Skybuck.

Skybuck is damn right!!!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -[/QUOTE]

haha he sure is!

He was next to me, like I said, where I could see him, and a split
second, like they always say, he was near the wall pushing on the
button. And I'm very good with watching him - we have all those
plastic outlet covers so he can't stick his fingers in and the outlets
not used on the surge protector are also covered.

Just one of those freak things.
 
Yeah I've moved the PC to different outlets without using the surge
protector.

I would try this:
Remove the power supply, plug it in, jumper the pins to power it onhttp://www.hardwarebook.info/ATX_Power_Supply
If the PS fan spins I would then shut it off with the rocker switch, connect
the molex to the hard drive, power it back on to see if the hard drive
works. (you could also test the PS with a multimeter at this point).
If the hard drive spins then I would put it back into the box and make all
the connections, then jumper the case switch leads on the mainboard. You
want to eliminate the case switch as a problem.
If the case switch does not seem to be a problem, then I would disconnect
everything from the motherboard including the video card, remove the memory,
and with only the processor in, turn the system on. See if the motherboard
power light comes on. You should get a bios beep code saying memory failure.
If the system starts (power light on, bios beeping) then start to add the
components back one at a time (one stick of memory, then the other). After
memory add the video card and see if the bios screen shows up. Then the hard
drive.
If all fails at the beginning then the motherboard is very possibly gone.If
not you will eventually get to the fried component.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Great, thanks for the info! Much appreciated! I will try these steps
tonight.
 
Skybuck Flying said:
Depands on what the surge protector does... and what happens when its
turned off...

Does electricity still flow when it's off ?

Then if yes... the surge protector would function as a water-dam holding
the water in the river and only letting a little bit through...

Then when it's turned off it is like a dam-break... all the water comes
rushing down and kills anything in it's path ;)
Damn those drugs must be good!
 
And this is what my system basically consists of:

Plenty of answers say it could be this or could be that. How to get
a definitive answer? Simply use a multimeter and maybe 30 seconds.
Get VDC numbers from the purple, gray, and green wires from power
supply both before and as the power switch is pressed. Post those
numbers here. Have a useful answer that either identified a solution
or isolates the problem immediately to but a few items. IOW have a
definitive answer without all those shotgun speculations.

Swapping parts has already proven to throw money, gasoline, and time
futilely. All that could have been avoided immediately. What the
above 30 seconds does is also summarized in "When your computer dies
without warning....." starting 6 Feb 2007 in the newsgroup
alt.windows-xp at:
http://tinyurl.com/yvf9vh
Connector chart to locate each color:
http://www.hardwarebook.net/connector/power/atxpower.html
 
s.com>, (e-mail address removed) writes

[nothing of any use, as usual]

So where's your reply to Paul's question in the thread "PSU Replacement
Problem"? I'll repost it here for your benefit:

"Yes, maybe we should go back and examine the threads you've
contributed to. For example, where you asked an original poster
to make a measurement for you. The OP complied. What kind of an
answer did he get from you in turn, based on the measurements ?
A "plate of waffles". He was no further ahead than he started."
 
The said:
And this is what my system basically consists of:

E6420
Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3R
2 GB's Crucial 800 RAM
Corsair 520HX PSU
Evga 7600GT
150gb Seagate Barracuda 7200.10
DVD R/W

So looking over the thread, where we're at right now, is
you press the power button on the front of the computer,
and the power supply fan does not turn. There is no
response from the power supply.

The necessary ingredients -

1) When you switch on the supply, the +5VSB part of the
supply works immediately. On an Asus motherboard, the
green LED on the motherboard, glows in response. I'm not
sure the Gigabyte has a LED for that. If there is no
LED, then a multimeter can be used to check it.

2) The +5VSB powers motherboard standby circuitry, and also
powers the logic that interfaces to the front power button.
It is also part of the interface on the power supply side
(the pullup resistor on PS_ON#).

3) If the motherboard is receiving +5VSB, then it can
"listen" to the front panel power switch. The front switch
is momentary contact, and closes when you press it. That
gives a short pulse to a logic chip on the motherboard.
(The front switch does *not* go directly to the mobo.)
The motherboard latches that pulse, and sends a steady
"on" signal in the form of PS_ON#, a signal on the main
power supply cable.

4) The signal on the cable is open collector. If the power
supply is sitting all by itself on a table top, it won't
run, because there is nothing connected to PS_ON#. That
logic signal has a pullup resistor, to +5VSB. So sitting
on the bench, the power supply by itself, has a 5 volt level
on PS_ON#. When the motherboard wishes to start the supply,
a motherboard driver grounds PS_ON#. That tells the supply
to start, and the fan in the supply starts to spin.

Based on that description, is why someone suggested testing
the power supply, basically testing the PS_ON# response. You
can use a paper clip, between PS_ON# and COM, to ground
PS_ON# and fake the same set of conditions the motherboard
uses.

In a pinch, you can even short PS_ON# to COM, while the
main power supply harness is connected to the motherboard.
(The metal pins are exposed enough to touch with probes or
a paper clip, where the wires go into the connector.)
Since the signal driving PS_ON# is open collector (or should
be), it should be safe to ground it. (Open collector is also
known as wired-OR logic, meaning one device OR another can
ground it at any one time. You can connect multiple open
collector outputs together, and the shorting strap between
PS_ON# and COM counts as just another such driver.)

The downside of manually overriding the motherboard, is you
disable motherboard protections. For example, say the heatsink
fell off the processor. The motherboard detects this as THERMTRIP
and attempts to turn off the power. If a shorting strap was
present between PS_ON# and COM, the power supply continues to
run. So in theory, in that particular situation, the processor
could overheat. So the trick of connecting PS_ON# to COM
is not something I would feel comfortable with, for long
term usage (some users who have motherboard logic failures
on PS_ON#, sometimes use that technique). It also affects
your shutdown sequence, in the sense that, at the end of
the present session, when you select shutdown in Windows,
the computer thinks it has powered off, but is still receiving
power. Maybe it'll have that "it is safe to turn off your
computer" on the screen, but I don't know that for a fact.

You can also test the power supply, by removing it from the
computer and testing it by itself. That would tell you
whether the supply is listening to PS_ON#, but not whether
the motherboard PS_ON# driver is able to drive the
signal to ground. (You should have a small bit of loading
on the supply, to help the supply maintain regulation.
I have my own home made load box for that purpose. Costs
about $50 for a handful of power resistors and an ATX
connector.)

If you used a multimeter, and measured the PS_ON# signal
level, with respect to chassis ground, you'd see +5 volts
(coming from the +5VSB on the supply) sitting on the line.
When you press the front panel button, the level should
drop to pretty close to zero volts. That means the motherboard
logic is doing the right thing. But if the power supply
doesn't start, it may be because the driver is weak and
cannot make it all the way to ground. Or the pullup on
the power supply side has become stronger than normal
(unlikely), and the poor driver cannot possibly pull it
down.

If for any reason, the +5VSB rail gets shorted out, inside
the supply is internal protection against overcurrent.
So checking the power supply harness for +5VSB, gives
some idea whether that is happening. In the case of
Asus boards, the comforting sight of the green LED
on the motherboard, saves you that step, as the green
LED is powered by +5VSB.

Ref: Power supply specs, from oldest to newest. The last
link is suitable for a 24 pin power supply. The wire
colors and pin numbers are in the spec.

http://web.archive.org/web/20030424...org/developer/specs/atx/ATX_ATX12V_PS_1_1.pdf

http://www.formfactors.org/developer/specs/atx/ATX12V_1_3dg.pdf

http://www.formfactors.org/developer/specs/ATX12V_PSDG_2_2_public_br2.pdf

Hope that gives you a few ideas,

Paul
 
The said:
It was Veteran's day and I had the day off from work. My 1 1/2 year
old son was harmlessly fiddling with the buttons on our printer while
I was on the computer doing a quick check of email and what-not, when
all of a sudden the computer went off. I look down and see my son's
hands had moved from the printer to the power button of the surge
protector. He turned it off. No big deal, I thought. Turned the surge
protector back on. Attempted to turn the computer back on and nothing.
Tried different outlets, nothing. Held the PC's power button in for a
few, nothing.

I went to the local PC shop and bought a new PSU, swapped the new for
the one in my PC, nothing. No power. No lights. Nothing. Returned the
new PSU to the shop.

Replaced my old PSU, took the battery out of the motherboard to reset
the CMOS, still nothing.

Now maybe I should have reset the CMOS with the new PSU in place,
because my old PSU could be fried too. Oh well.

So does anyone think my MB is dead?

Also, why would simply turning the surge protector off fry the MB?

Finally, could the shortage have spread and killed my RAM and HDD ?

Anything that can kill a motherboard can potentially kill anything
attached to it. I had a PSU kill everything and STILL supply power to
kill the new stuff! I thought it was just the motherboard, and that was
a major catalyst for me to start learning more and more about PCs.

Basically, discard the PSU. Buy a reasonable brand name unit - they may
not last forever like some top of the range PSUs but they're a bit less
likely to let the magic smoke out of everything inside your case when
they go.

Test anything that you want to re-use, such as RAM, HDD, etc. Programs
such as memtest86+ and the manufacturer's diagnostics for the hard drive
are good places to start. CPU might have even survived! However, if it's
an older system you might be better off just replacing the
motherboard/CPU/RAM rather than trying to get a secondhand board
(assuming you're using an older socket, you haven't said) for components
that may or may not work.

You may be able to put in a claim on your home and contents insurance,
just make sure it's not going to up your premiums.

Cheers,

Ari

--
spammage trappage: remove the underscores to reply
Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow transplant. Please
volunteer to be a marrow donor and literally save someone's life:
http://www.abmdr.org.au/
http://www.marrow.org/
 
Thanks again for all the input.

Anything that can kill a motherboard can potentially kill anything
attached to it. I had a PSU kill everything and STILL supply power to
kill the new stuff! I thought it was just the motherboard, and that was
a major catalyst for me to start learning more and more about PCs.

Basically, discard the PSU. Buy a reasonable brand name unit - they may
not last forever like some top of the range PSUs but they're a bit less
likely to let the magic smoke out of everything inside your case when
they go.

Test anything that you want to re-use, such as RAM, HDD, etc. Programs
such as memtest86+ and the manufacturer's diagnostics for the hard drive
are good places to start. CPU might have even survived! However, if it's
an older system you might be better off just replacing the
motherboard/CPU/RAM rather than trying to get a secondhand board
(assuming you're using an older socket, you haven't said) for components
that may or may not work.

You may be able to put in a claim on your home and contents insurance,
just make sure it's not going to up your premiums.

Cheers,

Ari

--
spammage trappage: remove the underscores to reply
Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow transplant. Please
volunteer to be a marrow donor and literally save someone's life:http://www.abmdr.org.au/http://www.marrow.org/- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

It could be the PSU, but it *is* a Corsair 520HX. I heard they are one
of the better ones. Now, of course the PSU could be dead too, but when
I took the PC to the local shop, the guy had one of those
multimeter's. He could say with certainity it was or wasn't the PSU
and/or Motherboard.

LIke is aid, I swapped the PSu for a new one (Thermaltake) and still
nothing. I mean nothing at all. The same nothing when the old PSU was
in.

Reset the CMOS battery the other night, still nothing.

Last night, took out all the ram, video card, unplugged HDD/DVD
drives, put 1 RAM back in, still nothing.

At this point, I really believe it's only 2 things - MB or the case's
power switch. I feel it's the MB, and I hope I'm right. If not,
nothing lost but time.

Find out tonight for sure.
 
At this point, I really believe it's only 2 things - MB or the case's
power switch. I feel it's the MB, and I hope I'm right. If not,
nothing lost but time.

Could still be anything including a power supply. You are
shotgunning which sometimes leads to confusion AND sometimes can even
exponentially complicate a problem. Provided was the only way to get
a reply that says something definitive. That means VDC numbers from a
multimeter.

How long is the list of known good components? None. Still
unknown: what is definitively good or definitively bad? Even a good
supply from one machine can be completely defective in another. A
defective supply can also boot a computer. Just more reasons why
swapping power supplies results in ‘maybe’ answers. Simplest solution
is to first see what exists long before replacing everything. 30
seconds using a meter is the only way you will get a useful and
definitive answer.

Why confusion? No definitive facts. Just shotgunning which is based
in speculation and which only results in 'maybe' answers. At this
point, you should know which components are ‘definitively’ (absolutely
no doubt) good. Meter would have reported that in 30 seconds.
 
Back
Top