AV Software That Does Not Run in Background (On-Command Only)?

  • Thread starter Thread starter frank
  • Start date Start date
F

frank

Hi,

Well, I'm sick of AV software that continously runs in the background:
always seems to end up giving me a problem eventually (PC-Cillin and Bit
Defender). I've decided that I all I need is AV software that will check a
file for viral code when I tell it to, and maybe scan on command. Can
anyoe reccommend such an application?

Thanks,
 
frank said:
Hi,

Well, I'm sick of AV software that continously runs in the background:
always seems to end up giving me a problem eventually (PC-Cillin and
Bit Defender). I've decided that I all I need is AV software that
will check a file for viral code when I tell it to, and maybe scan on
command. Can anyoe reccommend such an application?

Thanks,


er.. yes and no: I cannot recommand this manner of virus protection. But
since I guess you are as stubborn as I am, I think I will do better
recommending a Freeware AV that does this tings:


Numerous online scanners such as:

BitDefender
by Softwin
http://www.bitdefender.com/scan/Msie/index.php

McAfee VirusScan Online
by Network Associates
http://clinic.mcafee.com/clinic/avdownload/fsdownload.asp

Panda ActiveScan
http://www.pandasoftware.com/activescan/com/default.asp

PCPitstop
(Panda based?)
http://pcpitstop.com/antivirus/default.asp

Rav
by GeCAD (now MS owned?)
http://www.ravantivirus.com/scan/

Symantec Security Check
(Norton AntiVirus related)
http://security.norton.com/default.asp?langid=us&venid=sym

Trend Micro Housecall
(Pc-Cillin related)
http://housecall.antivirus.com/

or install based ones:

Fprot
http://www.f-prot.com/products/
go to http://home.epix.net/~artnpeg/ for an GUi and an updater for Fprot

You can also rip the registy entries from avg, rendering the onaccess
service useless, so you remain with an on access scanner (with some
antivirus applications you can change it in the options dialog)

MightyKitten
 
Well, I'm sick of AV software that continously runs in the background:
always seems to end up giving me a problem eventually (PC-Cillin and
Bit Defender). I've decided that I all I need is AV software that
will check a file for viral code when I tell it to, and maybe scan on
command. Can anyoe reccommend such an application?

F-Prot For DOS is what you need. It's free, and you run it in DOS.

Aside from the update problems (which I personally haven't had a problem
with) AVG has never caused me any problems.
 
MightyKitten said:
er.. yes and no: I cannot recommand this manner of virus protection. But
since I guess you are as stubborn as I am, I think I will do better
recommending a Freeware AV that does this tings:

You can also rip the registy entries from avg, rendering the onaccess
service useless, so you remain with an on access scanner (with some
antivirus applications you can change it in the options dialog)

MightyKitten

I use(d) avast!, AntiVir, AVG, BitDefender, Trend($), VirusScan($),
one that CA owns now, and others for on-demand scanning of downloads
and sometimes partitions without using their on-access/always on
feature. Most (all?) of these do require services (for Win2k), but
resource loads are small since they are just waiting to be invoked
from my context menu.

I particularly like BitDefender Free for this because signature
updates are very quick (even better than avast!), execution is quick
(second? to AVG), and BD is better than average at finding zipped
malware (especially important to me). I just hide the tray icon
because closing it stops two services: I haven't tried to analyze in
detail and remove it.

To use avast!, just disable (not delete) the startup registry entry
via direct surgery (why bother/risk?) or WinPatrol, WinSonar, Spybot,
StartRight, Codestuff's Starter, etc.). The avast! basic UI does not
provide for disabling on-access/always on scanning (nor later
enabling, so _disable_).

The AntiVir UI makes selective disabling easy, but I don't recommend
AntiVir for this role because the standard context menu install does
not handle multi-file selects, just individual files or directories.

I don't remember what I did to install/setup AVG, nor do I remember
sufficient details to evaluate Panda (free in US if you qualify) or a
couple of others. Antidote is a free on-demand scanner (KAV based?),
but it is only updated weekly, installs and uninstalls each time it is
run, and has some other quirk.

Note, more and more anti-viruses are picky about cohabitating. That's
partially why I haven't bothered with VirusScan, Panda, Freedom, or
(CA's 1 year free) recently even though I have (or had) legal copies.
You may have to disable scanning (recommended!), disable a registry
entry, shutdown service(s), or even remove registry entires to do the
initial install of another package. I've forgotten whether the other
applications conflicted. Some conflicts also may depend upon the
order various packages are installed, your OS, and the wind direction
and intensity when you were born -- or was that conceived.

You have lots of choices. There are few good reasons -- and even
fewer sufficient ones -- not to use both an always on scanner and one
or two other on-demand applications that complement each other plus
other security software as needed. (PestScan, PestPatrol scanner
online, is _very_ quick and catches almost everything Ad-aware and
Spybot have found when I periodically compare.).

BillR
 
frank said:
I've decided that I all I need is AV software that will check a
file for viral code when I tell it to, and maybe scan on command.
That's how I use free AVG 6 (windows 98). Do you have a problem
with it? Run it against selected files/folders from the explorer context
menu and against newly-downloaded files from your download manager. The
latter requires the /quit directive. If AVG ever had any autostarting
stuff, it is gone, long gone from my system, all of that crap in the GUI
is turned off, too, and it works quite well on-demand.
 
I've decided that I all I need is AV software that will check a
file for viral code when I tell it to, and maybe scan on command. Can
anyoe reccommend such an application?

Bitdefender free edition
 
Onno wrote in said:
Bitdefender free edition

While BitDefender free edition offers on-demand scanner only, notice
that if you install it on NT/XP plattform, it will install two service
modules (Bitdefender Communicator and BitDefender Scan Server) that
will load and run from startup even if the free program offer no
resident shield option. What I do, since I use it as backup scanner my
self, is disabled the two services via the Windows Service Manger
(startup type: manual)... then only start them via the same manager
manually for the current session only (right click service and chose
start) when I need to run Bitdefener on-demand scan (either for
scanning or for updates, or both). I think the scanner will not work
unless at least the Scan Server service is running.

Else, all or most of the free AV scanners can be used as "on-demand
scanners" only. For those that offer resident shield and a
configuration interface/program launcher that "sits" in the windows
tray, you will have to turn these features off of course. (sometimes
the only way to do this might be to use a third party utility such a
Winpatrol <http://www.winpatrol.com> - or similar to control and
configure what loads as startup)

All the best
Bjorn Simonsen
 
Back
Top