are Seagate drives over 200G reliable ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DEMAINE Benoit-Pierre
  • Start date Start date
D

DEMAINE Benoit-Pierre

I got 3 barracudas in use, twice 120 and one 200. I was planing buying a
400GB P-IDE soon, but some friend told me that new Seagate drives are
not as good as before, and mentionned stories similar to what I lived
with IBM 30GB, 40GB and 60GB: dead after 1 month use !

Troll ?
FUD ?
truth ?

if true, what are the alternative for P-IDE at least 300GB ?
 
Not according to storagereview.

DEMAINE Benoit-Pierre said:
I got 3 barracudas in use, twice 120 and one 200. I was planing
buying a 400GB P-IDE soon, but some friend told me that new Seagate
drives are not as good as before, and mentionned stories similar to
what I lived with IBM 30GB, 40GB and 60GB: dead after 1 month use !
Click to expand...
Troll ?
FUD ?
truth ?
Click to expand...

It is true, have a look at the storagereview stats.
if true, what are the alternative for P-IDE at least 300GB ?
Click to expand...

Have a look at the storagereview stats.
 
Have a look at the storagereview stats.

I do not understand where the site mentions, or even could let
understand BArracudas over 200G are not so good.

I dont either find any reliability grid comparing manifacturers.
 
Back
Top