AMD Duron 1800 to Core2 E4550 ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Don
  • Start date Start date
D

Don

Can you specialists giveme some advice please. I'm in the UK.

Is the advice I've been given any good? Suggested I go from my old
slow system to a new system based on Intel. Proposed system seems
overkill. Opinions please.


REQUIREMENT:
I use my system for home use with a lot of personal office-like
activity (I'm retired).

I want to have reasonably good audio editing for good quality voice
recording of meetings. Want low system noise where possible.

Would like FEATURES (like lots of USB and on-board functions to save
buying plugins) but I don't need tons of outright POWER.


PRICE:
I can't fund expensive equipment so I try and buy for value rather
than leading edge technology. My current system was bought as middle
to trailing edge technology and has got more out of date since then!


CURRENT SYSTEM:
(a) AMD Duron cpu at 1800 MHz. Real 1800 MHz (approx sub-Athlon 2100+)
(b) Syntax mobo based on Via 266a chipset with 768 MB SD-RAM.
(c) 17 inch CRT which I will keep and re-use.
(d) four to seven hard drives (mix of SATA/PATA) using PCI adapters


PROPOSED SYSTEM (PC shop suggestion: total £450 inc VAT)
(1) Intel Core 2 Duo E4500 processor (£77)
(2) very recent Asus mobo (£89)
3 PCI, 6 SATA, 10 USB, 2 Fwire, 8ch sound, 4D chII-1066 memory
(3) 4 GB memory Crucial/Kingston (£60)
(4) graphics card (£30)
(5) sound blaster X-Fi Xtreme PCI 8ch (£33)
(6) hard drive for booting only (£30)
(7) DVD-RW £22
(8) decent case/PSU = Antec Sonata (£92)
(9) usual ancillary things: fan, webcam, KVM switch, mouse/keybd

------------

Bit fast isn't it? And probably a huge jump.

It's too expensive. Any ideas where I can trim the cost back a bit.

Was told Intel cpu's have currently stolen a lead on AMD. Also that
Intel mobos were no longer significantly more costly than AMD mobos.
True enough?

Decent mobo can provide integrated function which is more costly to
add later so I don't want to pare this back to a "skeleton" mobo.

Decent case and PSU save endless trouble but is the Antec Sonata with
PSU good value? I don't like it's glossy front flap (remove), only 2
front USB and no front fan.
 
Don said:
Can you specialists giveme some advice please. I'm in the UK.

Is the advice I've been given any good? Suggested I go from my old
slow system to a new system based on Intel. Proposed system seems
overkill. Opinions please.


REQUIREMENT:
I use my system for home use with a lot of personal office-like
activity (I'm retired).

I want to have reasonably good audio editing for good quality voice
recording of meetings. Want low system noise where possible.

Would like FEATURES (like lots of USB and on-board functions to save
buying plugins) but I don't need tons of outright POWER.


PRICE:
I can't fund expensive equipment so I try and buy for value rather
than leading edge technology. My current system was bought as middle
to trailing edge technology and has got more out of date since then!


CURRENT SYSTEM:
(a) AMD Duron cpu at 1800 MHz. Real 1800 MHz (approx sub-Athlon 2100+)
(b) Syntax mobo based on Via 266a chipset with 768 MB SD-RAM.
(c) 17 inch CRT which I will keep and re-use.
(d) four to seven hard drives (mix of SATA/PATA) using PCI adapters


PROPOSED SYSTEM (PC shop suggestion: total £450 inc VAT)
(1) Intel Core 2 Duo E4500 processor (£77)
(2) very recent Asus mobo (£89)
3 PCI, 6 SATA, 10 USB, 2 Fwire, 8ch sound, 4D chII-1066 memory
(3) 4 GB memory Crucial/Kingston (£60)
(4) graphics card (£30)
(5) sound blaster X-Fi Xtreme PCI 8ch (£33)
(6) hard drive for booting only (£30)
(7) DVD-RW £22
(8) decent case/PSU = Antec Sonata (£92)
(9) usual ancillary things: fan, webcam, KVM switch, mouse/keybd

------------

Bit fast isn't it? And probably a huge jump.

It's too expensive. Any ideas where I can trim the cost back a bit.

Was told Intel cpu's have currently stolen a lead on AMD. Also that
Intel mobos were no longer significantly more costly than AMD mobos.
True enough?

Decent mobo can provide integrated function which is more costly to
add later so I don't want to pare this back to a "skeleton" mobo.

Decent case and PSU save endless trouble but is the Antec Sonata with
PSU good value? I don't like it's glossy front flap (remove), only 2
front USB and no front fan.
Click to expand...

OK, I'll throw one together.

Based on this chart, I'll go from Intel E4500 to AMD 5600+. $117 versus $69

http://www.xbitlabs.com/images/cpu/dualcore-shootout/additional/price-perf-1.png

Motherboard Asus M3A78-EM $66
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131324

HDMI/DVI/VGA/DisplayPort (graphics options)
PS/2 (keyboard)
ESATA (high speed external disk)
RJ-45 (Ethernet)
6 USB (4 on backplate)
8 channel audio (six connectors)
S/PDIF (TOSLink digital audio)
1394 (Firewire - for camcorder ?)

2 PCI slots.
PCI Express x16 (future graphics upgrade)
PCI Express x1 (successor to PCI)

One con for the product - no accessories to speak of.
http://images17.newegg.com/is/image/newegg/13-131-324-S05?$S640W$

You might have to pick up some adapters for USB later, if
you want more rear USB connectors than are provided.

http://estore.asus.com/images/14-000500020.JPG

The case is the other area you could shave off a few pounds.
I'd suggest buying one without power supply. (Mainly, because
for some bargain cases, the power supply is just adding to your
local landfill.) Then, you can select a power supply separately,
picked for what you consider the loading is going to be.

The above should be a pretty low power system. If you don't
install a separate video card, use the integrated video,
even a 350W supply would be enough. The 5600+ processor is
65W, the motherboard plus RAM about 50W, so there really
isn't a lot of power consumption.

HTH,
Paul
 
Paul said:
Don wrote:
Click to expand...

Oh, and you can try the onboard sound first, without buying the
Sound Blaster. If the onboard works well enough, you save another
£33.

Paul
 
REQUIREMENT:
I use my system for home use with a lot of personal office-like
activity (I'm retired).

I want to have reasonably good audio editing for good quality voice
recording of meetings. Want low system noise where possible.

Would like FEATURES (like lots of USB and on-board functions to save
buying plugins) but I don't need tons of outright POWER.
Click to expand...

I appreciate this is a home built group but spec yourself up a Dell Vostro
before you make a final decision, start here:

<http://www1.euro.dell.com/content/products/features.aspx/4x_vostro_220?c=uk&cs=ukbsdt1&l=en&s=bsd>

and work the 220 up, I ended up with this:

<http://configure.euro.dell.com/dell...l=en&m_30=138820&oc=D122209&rbc=D122209&s=bsd>

£199 + VAT and shipping.

I got one as a home server and it hasn't missed a beat.
 
Don said:
Can you specialists giveme some advice please. I'm in the UK.

Is the advice I've been given any good? Suggested I go from my old
slow system to a new system based on Intel. Proposed system seems
overkill. Opinions please.


REQUIREMENT:
I use my system for home use with a lot of personal office-like
activity (I'm retired).

I want to have reasonably good audio editing for good quality voice
recording of meetings. Want low system noise where possible.

Would like FEATURES (like lots of USB and on-board functions to save
buying plugins) but I don't need tons of outright POWER.


PRICE:
I can't fund expensive equipment so I try and buy for value rather
than leading edge technology. My current system was bought as middle
to trailing edge technology and has got more out of date since then!


CURRENT SYSTEM:
(a) AMD Duron cpu at 1800 MHz. Real 1800 MHz (approx sub-Athlon 2100+)
(b) Syntax mobo based on Via 266a chipset with 768 MB SD-RAM.
(c) 17 inch CRT which I will keep and re-use.
(d) four to seven hard drives (mix of SATA/PATA) using PCI adapters


PROPOSED SYSTEM (PC shop suggestion: total £450 inc VAT)
(1) Intel Core 2 Duo E4500 processor (£77)
(2) very recent Asus mobo (£89)
3 PCI, 6 SATA, 10 USB, 2 Fwire, 8ch sound, 4D chII-1066 memory
(3) 4 GB memory Crucial/Kingston (£60)
(4) graphics card (£30)
(5) sound blaster X-Fi Xtreme PCI 8ch (£33)
(6) hard drive for booting only (£30)
(7) DVD-RW £22
(8) decent case/PSU = Antec Sonata (£92)
(9) usual ancillary things: fan, webcam, KVM switch, mouse/keybd

------------

Bit fast isn't it? And probably a huge jump.

It's too expensive. Any ideas where I can trim the cost back a bit.

Was told Intel cpu's have currently stolen a lead on AMD. Also that
Intel mobos were no longer significantly more costly than AMD mobos.
True enough?

Decent mobo can provide integrated function which is more costly to
add later so I don't want to pare this back to a "skeleton" mobo.

Decent case and PSU save endless trouble but is the Antec Sonata with
PSU good value? I don't like it's glossy front flap (remove), only 2
front USB and no front fan.
Click to expand...

FWIW, last one I built (last week)

Intel E2200
Asus P5KPL-AM
Antec NSK 4480
OCZ 2Gb
160Gb Seagate SATA
Lite-On LH-20A1S
2x 80mm fans

£212 total

The cpu is dual core but not Core 2 Duo, add another £30 if you want one,
all parts from Ebuyer with free delivery.
 
OK, I'll throw one together.

Based on this chart, I'll go from Intel E4500 to AMD 5600+. $117 versus $69
Click to expand...

That one is certainly powerful and has an average energy consumption. But I
would rather choose a low-energy AMD 4850e, cheaper and more than
sufficient for the intended purpose.
Motherboard Asus M3A78-EM $66
Click to expand...

I got this one some weeks ago - works very well, apart from the poor 2D
performance in some applications with windows xp.
You might have to pick up some adapters for USB later, if
you want more rear USB connectors than are provided.
Click to expand...

I would rather get a case that offers these conncectors on the front or get
one of these Silverstone FP35
http://www.silverstonetek.com/products/p_contents.php?pno=FP35&area=
with the added benefit of sound connectors in the front.

fup to uk.comp.homebuilt

Andreas
 
Can you specialists giveme some advice please. I'm in the UK.

Is the advice I've been given any good? Suggested I go from my old
slow system to a new system based on Intel. Proposed system seems
overkill. Opinions please.


REQUIREMENT:
I use my system for home use with a lot of personal office-like
activity (I'm retired).

I want to have reasonably good audio editing for good quality voice
recording of meetings. Want low system noise where possible.

Would like FEATURES (like lots of USB and on-board functions to save
buying plugins) but I don't need tons of outright POWER.


PRICE:
I can't fund expensive equipment so I try and buy for value rather
than leading edge technology. My current system was bought as middle
to trailing edge technology and has got more out of date since then!


CURRENT SYSTEM:
(a) AMD Duron cpu at 1800 MHz. Real 1800 MHz (approx sub-Athlon 2100+)
(b) Syntax mobo based on Via 266a chipset with 768 MB SD-RAM.
(c) 17 inch CRT which I will keep and re-use.
(d) four to seven hard drives (mix of SATA/PATA) using PCI adapters


PROPOSED SYSTEM (PC shop suggestion: total £450 inc VAT)
(1) Intel Core 2 Duo E4500 processor (£77)
Click to expand...
Intel Pentium Dual Core E2200 Socket 775 2.2GHz 800FSB Retail Boxed
Processor BX80557E2200 £51.96
(2) very recent Asus mobo (£89)
3 PCI, 6 SATA, 10 USB, 2 Fwire, 8ch sound, 4D chII-1066 memory
Click to expand...
Gigabyte GA-EG43M-S2H iG43 Socket 775 onboard graphics 8 channel audio
2 PCI 5 SATA 1 eSATA 6+6 USB 2 Firewire mATX Motherboard GA-EG43M-S2H
£75.69
(3) 4 GB memory Crucial/Kingston (£60)
Click to expand...
Crucial 2GB kit (2x1GB) DDR2 800MHz/PC2-6400 Ballistix Memory Non-ECC
Unbuffered CL4 Lifetime £20.99
(4) graphics card (£30)
Click to expand...
on motherboard
(5) sound blaster X-Fi Xtreme PCI 8ch (£33)
Click to expand...
on motherboard
(6) hard drive for booting only (£30)
(7) DVD-RW £22
(8) decent case/PSU = Antec Sonata (£92)
Click to expand...
Antec NSK 4480B Black ATX/MATX Mini Tower - With 380W EarthWatts PSU
£55.99
 
Motherboard Asus M3A78-EM $66
I got this one some weeks ago - works very well, apart from the poor 2D
performance in some applications with windows xp.
Click to expand...

I would suggest M3N-H... :)

--
@~@ Might, Courage, Vision, SINCERITY.
/ v \ Simplicity is Beauty! May the Force and Farce be with you!
/( _ )\ (Xubuntu 8.04.1) Linux 2.6.26.8
^ ^ 17:09:01 up 21 days 5:23 4 users load average: 1.00 1.04 1.00
¤£­É¶U! ¤£¶BÄF! ¤£´©¥æ! ¤£¥´¥æ! ¤£¥´§T! ¤£¦Û±þ! ½Ð¦Ò¼{ºî´© (CSSA):
http://www.swd.gov.hk/tc/index/site_pubsvc/page_socsecu/sub_addressesa
 
Man-wai Chang ToDie (33.6k) said:
I would suggest M3N-H... :)
Click to expand...

Or M3N78-EM if you need a mATX board. Nvidia's SATA performance should
be better.

--
@~@ Might, Courage, Vision, SINCERITY.
/ v \ Simplicity is Beauty! May the Force and Farce be with you!
/( _ )\ (Xubuntu 8.04.1) Linux 2.6.26.8
^ ^ 17:19:01 up 21 days 5:33 4 users load average: 1.14 1.12 1.03
¤£­É¶U! ¤£¶BÄF! ¤£´©¥æ! ¤£¥´¥æ! ¤£¥´§T! ¤£¦Û±þ! ½Ð¦Ò¼{ºî´© (CSSA):
http://www.swd.gov.hk/tc/index/site_pubsvc/page_socsecu/sub_addressesa
 
On Tue 02 Dec08 09:45 said:
I appreciate this is a home built group but spec yourself up a
Dell Vostro before you make a final decision, start here:

<http://www1.euro.dell.com/content/products/features.aspx/4x_vost
ro_220?c=uk&cs=ukbsdt1&l=en&s=bsd>

and work the 220 up, I ended up with this:

<http://configure.euro.dell.com/dellstore/config.aspx?
b=&c=uk&cs=ukbsdt1&kc=D4X22001&l=en&m_30=138820&oc=D122209
&rbc=D122209&s=bsd> OR http://tinyurl.com/4grlcf

£199 + VAT and shipping.

I got one as a home server and it hasn't missed a beat.
Click to expand...


Do you mean £199? It's £169 + VAT (= £194) plus £29 delivery.
That's £223 fully inclusive.

This was the spec. Looks quite good don't you think?


Pentium Dual-Core processor E2200
Vista Home Premium 32
MS Works 9.0
1024MB 800MHz Dual Channel DDR2 (2x512) [for 2048MB add £20.00]
80GB 7200rpm SATA Hard Drive
Integrated grpahics: Intel Graphic Media Accelerator X4500
16x DVD-ROM Drive [add £20.00 for RW]
Dell USB Keyboard
Dell 2 Button USB Optical Mouse
Integrated audio
1Yr Basic Warranty - next business day onsite

Dell Vostro 220 MT (ref: D122209)
 
Can you specialists giveme some advice please. I'm in the UK.

Is the advice I've been given any good?  Suggested I go from my old
slow system to a new system based on Intel.  Proposed system seems
overkill.  Opinions please.

REQUIREMENT:  
I use my system for home use with a lot of personal office-like
activity (I'm retired).

I want to have reasonably good audio editing for good quality voice
recording of meetings.  Want low system noise where possible.

Would like FEATURES (like lots of USB and on-board functions to save
buying plugins) but I don't need tons of outright POWER.

PRICE:
I can't fund expensive equipment so I try and buy for value rather
than leading edge technology.  My current system was bought as middle
to trailing edge technology and has got more out of date since then!

CURRENT SYSTEM:
(a) AMD Duron cpu at 1800 MHz. Real 1800 MHz (approx sub-Athlon 2100+)
(b) Syntax mobo based on Via 266a chipset with 768 MB SD-RAM.
(c) 17 inch CRT which I will keep and re-use.
(d) four to seven hard drives (mix of SATA/PATA) using PCI adapters

PROPOSED SYSTEM (PC shop suggestion: total £450 inc VAT)
(1)  Intel Core 2 Duo E4500 processor (£77)
(2) very recent Asus mobo  (£89)
    3 PCI, 6 SATA, 10 USB, 2 Fwire, 8ch sound, 4D chII-1066 memory
(3) 4 GB memory Crucial/Kingston   (£60)
(4) graphics card  (£30)
(5) sound blaster X-Fi Xtreme PCI 8ch (£33)
(6) hard drive for booting only  (£30)
(7) DVD-RW  £22
(8) decent case/PSU = Antec Sonata (£92)
(9) usual ancillary things: fan, webcam, KVM switch, mouse/keybd

------------

Bit fast isn't it?  And probably a huge jump.

It's too expensive. Any ideas where I can trim the cost back a bit.

Was told Intel cpu's have currently stolen a lead on AMD.  Also that
Intel mobos were no longer significantly more costly than AMD mobos.  
True enough?

Decent mobo can provide integrated function which is more costly to
add later so I don't want to pare this back to a "skeleton" mobo.

Decent case and PSU save endless trouble but is the Antec Sonata with
PSU good value? I don't like it's glossy front flap (remove), only 2
front USB and no front fan.
Click to expand...

The more resources you have the longer the system will be viable.
that said most systems are bogged down in junk that starts at boot and
serves no real use other than it will allow the application to launch
slightly faster if the user decides to us it. Do some research and
tweak your current system you may be happy.
But if buyin, buy asbig as you can afford.
Hit for what to do if you do get a new system install Linux on the old
one
http://www.ubuntu.com/ Offers a good product and excellent community
support and will run like a winged rodent exiting the underworld
 
Back
Top